• Accessibility
• Email alerts
• RSS feeds
• Contact us

Session 2010 - 12
Internet Publications
Other Bills before Parliament

	1215
	SUPPLEMENT TO THE VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS
	Thursday 19 April 2012
	Committee of the whole House
	Proceedings
	Finance (No. 4) Bill
	[Second Day]
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Negatived on division  65
	Clause  4,  page  2,  line  37,  leave out subsection (2).
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Not called  66
	Clause  4,  page  3,  line  5,  leave out ‘ was born after 5 April 1938 but before 6 April
	1948’ and insert ‘is 65 or over at some time in the tax year, but under 75 throughout the
	tax year.’.
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Not called  67
	Clause  4,  page  3,  line  17,  leave out ‘had been born after 5 April 1948’ and insert ‘is
	under the age of 65 thoughout the tax year’.
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Not called  68
	Clause  4,  page  3,  line  19,  leave out paragraph (d).
	Committee of the whole House Proceedings: 19 April 2012       1216
	Finance (No. 4) Bill, continued
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Not called  69
	Clause  4,  page  3,  line  26,  leave out ‘was born before 6 April 1938’ and insert ‘is 75
	or over at some time in the tax year.’.
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Not called  70
	Clause  4,  page  3,  line  38,  leave out ‘had been born after 5 April 1948’ and insert ‘is
	under the age of 65 throughout the tax year.’.
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Not called  71
	Clause  4,  page  3,  line  40,  leave out paragraph (d).
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Not called  72
	Clause  4,  page  3,  line  42,  leave out subsection (5).
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Not called  73
	Clause  4,  page  3,  line  45,  leave out sub-paragraph (i).
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Not called  74
	Clause  4,  page  4,  line  2,  leave out subsection (7).
	Committee of the whole House Proceedings: 19 April 2012       1217
	Finance (No. 4) Bill, continued
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
	Stewart Hosie
		Not selected  4
	Page  2,  line  34,  leave out Clause 4.
		Clause Agreed to on division.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Withdrawn  9
	Clause  8,  page  4,  line  33,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  10
	Clause  8,  page  4,  line  34,  at end add ‘for recipients of child benefit’.
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
		Negatived on division  75
	Clause  8,  page  4,  line  35,  at end add—
		‘(2)     Schedule 1 will not come into effect until a study has been carried out into ways
		of mitigating the impact of the Schedule on families with only one earner,
		compared with families with two earners, and placed in the Library of the House
		of Commons.’.
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
	Stewart Hosie
		Not selected  2
	Page  4,  line  33,  leave out Clause 8.
		Clause Agreed to on division.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  11
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  7,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Committee of the whole House Proceedings: 19 April 2012       1218
	Finance (No. 4) Bill, continued
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  12
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  8,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  25
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  10,  leave out ‘£50,000’ and insert ‘£60,000’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  26
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  11,  leave out ‘one or both of conditions A and B are’ and
	insert ‘condition A is’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  13
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  12,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  27
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  leave out lines 19 to 24.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Douglas Carswell
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Negatived on division  28
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  24,  at end insert—
		‘(5)     A person (P) is not liable to a high income child benefit charge if the total adjusted
		net income for the year of that person and any partner does not exceed £100,000’.
	Mark Reckless
	Mr Douglas Carswell
		Not called  77
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  24,  at end insert—
		‘(5)     A person (P) is not liable to a high income child benefit charge if the total adjusted
		net income for the year of that person and any partner does not exceed £100,000,
		subject to any child or children in respect of whom child benefit is claimed being
		resident in the United Kingdom notwithstanding the European Communities Act
		1972.’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  14
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  26,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  29
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  29,  leave out from ‘met’ to end of line 30.
	Committee of the whole House Proceedings: 19 April 2012       1219
	Finance (No. 4) Bill, continued
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  30
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  31,  leave out ‘and B’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  31
	Schedule  1,  page  131,  line  32,  leave out from ‘is’ to end of line 13 on page 132 and
	insert ‘100%’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  32
	Schedule  1,  page  132,  line  14,  leave out from beginning to end of line 2 on page
	133.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  33
	Schedule  1,  page  133,  leave out lines 16 to 26.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  34
	Schedule  1,  page  133,  line  29,  leave out ‘another’ and insert ‘a higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  35
	Schedule  1,  page  133,  line  30,  leave out from ‘681B(1)(a)’ to end of line 33.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  36
	Schedule  1,  page  133,  leave out lines 36 to 39.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  37
	Schedule  1,  page  134,  leave out lines 3 and 4.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  38
	Schedule  1,  page  134,  leave out lines 10 to 12.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  15
	Schedule  1,  page  134,  line  28,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Committee of the whole House Proceedings: 19 April 2012       1220
	Finance (No. 4) Bill, continued
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  39
	Schedule  1,  page  134,  leave out lines 34 to 37.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  16
	Schedule  1,  page  135,  line  9,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  40
	Schedule  1,  page  135,  leave out lines 13 to 23.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  41
	Schedule  1,  page  135,  leave out lines 37 to 40.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  17
	Schedule  1,  page  135,  line  38,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  18
	Schedule  1,  page  136,  line  9,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  42
	Schedule  1,  page  136,  leave out lines 13 to 23.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  19
	Schedule  1,  page  136,  line  35,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  20
	Schedule  1,  page  136,  line  38,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  21
	Schedule  1,  page  136,  line  45,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Committee of the whole House Proceedings: 19 April 2012       1221
	Finance (No. 4) Bill, continued
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  22
	Schedule  1,  page  137,  line  13,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  23
	Schedule  1,  page  137,  line  22,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Mr Christopher Chope
	Mr Edward Leigh
		Not called  24
	Schedule  1,  page  137,  line  26,  leave out ‘high’ and insert ‘higher’.
	Ed Balls
	Rachel Reeves
	Owen Smith
	Cathy Jamieson
	Chris Leslie
	Stewart Hosie
		Not selected  3
	Page  131,  line  2,  leave out Schedule 1.
		Schedule Agreed to on division.
		Bill (Clauses 1, 4, 8, 189 and 209 and Schedules 1, 23 and 33) to be reported.

• A-Z index
• Glossary
• Contact us
• Freedom of Information
• Jobs
• Using this website
• Copyright