House of Commons Public Bill Committee Proceedings

Session 2014 - 15
Internet Publications
Other Bills before Parliament

267

SUPPLEMENT TO THE VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS

Monday 24 November 2014

Report Stage Proceedings

Recall of MPs Bill, As Amended

NEW CLAUSES

Sir Greg Knight

Chris Heaton-Harris

Not selected  NC1

To move the following Clause—


“Extension of recall to UK members of the European Parliament

The Secretary of State shall within six months of this Act coming into force

publish a report on the process by which the right of recall can be introduced for

UK members of the European Parliament.”

Mr David Heath

Dr Julian Huppert

Negatived on division  NC2

To move the following Clause—


“Recall condition: method of petitioning an election court

(1)
This section applies when persons allege conduct by an MP which constitutes

misconduct in the office of member of parliament.

(2)
A petition under this section may be presented if signed by at least five hundred

persons who are registered as electors in the constituency of the MP named in the

petition.

(3)
The petition shall be in the prescribed form, state the prescribed matters and be

signed by all the petitioners, and shall be presented to the High Court, or to the

Court of Session, or to the High Court of Northern Ireland, depending on whether

the constituency to which it relates is in England and Wales, or Scotland or

Northern Ireland.

(4)
The petition shall be presented by delivering it to the prescribed officer or

otherwise dealing with it in the prescribed manner; and the prescribed officer

shall send a copy of it forthwith to The Speaker and to the MP therein named.

:
268

, continued

(5)
The election court shall be constituted as if it were constituted under section c123

(constitution of election court and place of trial) of the Representation of the

People Act 1983, and sections 124 and 126 of that Act shall apply as if were so

constituted.

(6)
“Prescribed” has the same meaning as in section 185 (Interpretation of Part III)

of the Representation of the People Act 1983.”

Mr David Heath

Dr Julian Huppert

Not called  NC3

To move the following Clause—


“Recall condition: consideration by election court

(1)
This section applies when a petition alleging conduct by an MP which constitutes

misconduct in the office of member of parliament has been received by an

election court as properly presented under section (The third recall condition:

method of petitioning an election court).

(2)
The court may consider such conduct wherever it is committed, and whether or

not it is committed directly in carrying out the office of member of parliament.

(3)
The court must examine evidence adduced of misconduct, and any evidence

produced in rebuttal by the MP.

(4)
The court must consider whether, on the basis of such evidence, it is reasonable

to believe that the MP has misconducted himself or herself, to such a degree as to

amount to an abuse of the public’s trust in the MP, without reasonable excuse or

justification.

(5)
If the court considers, on the basis of such evidence, that the allegation of

misconduct is—

(a)
not supported by the evidence; or

(b)
trivial or vexatious in nature; or

(c)
brought for party political purposes;


then the court must dismiss the petition.

(6)
If the decision of the court is that the alleged behaviour is such as to satisfy

subsection (4), then it must notify The Speaker that it has so determined.

(7)
Nothing in this section shall be construed as affecting any provision of the Bill

of Rights 1689.”

Mark Durkan

Jeremy Corbyn

Caroline Lucas

Not called  NC4

To move the following Clause—


“MP’s pledge

(1)
Each MP shall at the start of each Parliament subscribe to the Pledge set out in

this section.

:
269

, continued

(2)
An MP subscribing to the Pledge may do so—

(a)
in writing; or

(b)
in person at the same time as taking the Oath required by the

Parliamentary Oaths Act 1866.

(3)
The Pledge shall be—

  “I solemnly undertake that, in the course of my duties as a Member of

Parliament and service to my constituency, I shall act in adherence with

the Code of Conduct for Members of Parliament and uphold the

standards of public life with selflessness, integrity, objectivity,

accountability, openness, honesty and leadership.”

As an Amendment to Mark Durkan’s proposed New Clause (MP’s pledge) (NC4):—

Ms Margaret Ritchie

Jeremy Corbyn

Caroline Lucas

Not selected  (a)


Line  4,  leave out subsection (2) and insert—

“(2)
An MP subscribing to the Pledge may do so—

(a)
in writing, or

(b)
in person at the same time as, or in the place of, taking the Oath required

by the Parliamentary Oaths Act 1866 (“the 1866 Act”).

(2A)
An MP who has subscribed to the Pledge in this section under the provisions of

subsection (2)(b) shall be entitled to sit in the House of Commons as though they

had taken the Oath required by the 1866 Act and shall not be subject to any

penalty under section 5 of that Act.”

Mark Durkan

Jeremy Corbyn

Caroline Lucas

Not called  NC5

To move the following Clause—


“Complaint of breach of MP’s pledge

(1)
This section applies when persons complain that an MP has acted in a way that

represents a significant breach of the MP’s Pledge as set out in section (MP’s

Pledge).

(2)
A petition containing a complaint under subsection (1) may be presented to the

electoral court if signed by at least five hundred persons on the electoral roll

within the constituency of the MP named in the petition.

(3)
The Secretary of State may by regulation prescribe—

(a)
the form, content and process relating to the submission of such petitions;

and

(b)
the manner of constitution of an electoral court to adjudicate.

(4)
The electoral court must examine evidence submitted of the alleged breach of the

MP’s Pledge, and any evidence produced in rebuttal by the MP.

:
270

, continued

(5)
The court must consider whether, on the balance of evidence, it is reasonable to

believe that the MP has acted in a way that amounts to a significant breach of the

MP’s Pledge, without reasonable excuse or justification.

(6)
If the court finds in favour of the petitioners, then it must notify the Speaker, and

the MP named in the petition, that it has so determined.

(7)
Nothing in this section shall be construed as affecting any provision of the Bill

of Rights 1689.”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Mark Durkan

Not called  1

Clause  1,  page  1,  line  4,  leave out “the first or second” and insert “a”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Agreed to on division  14

Clause  1,  page  1,  line  18,  leave out subsection (4) and insert—

“(4)
The second recall condition is that, following on from a report from the

Committee on Standards, the House of Commons order the suspension of the MP

from the service of the House for a specified period of requisite length.

(4A)
A specified period is of requisite length for the purposes of subsection (4) if—

(a)
where the period is expressed as a number of sitting days, the period

specified is of at least 10 sitting days, or

(b)
in any other case, the period specified (however expressed) is a period of

at least 14 days.”

Mr David Heath

Dr Julian Huppert

Not called  2

Clause  1,  page  2,  line  9,  at end insert—

“( )
A further recall condition (misconduct in the office of member of parliament) is

that—

(a)
an election court has considered a petition claiming that the MP has

committed an act which constitutes misconduct in the office of member

of parliament; and

(b)
the court has determined, prima facie, that it is reasonable to believe such

an act may have been committed; and

(c)
the court has notified The Speaker of its decision under subsection (b).”

Dr Julian Huppert

Mr David Heath

Negatived on division  15

Clause  1,  page  2,  line  9,  at end insert—

“( )
A further recall condition (misconduct in public office) is that—

:
271

, continued

(a)
the MP has, after becoming an MP, been convicted of the common law

offence of misconduct in public office, and

(b)
the appeal period expires without the conviction having been overturned

on appeal.


Sections 2 to 4 contain more about this recall condition.”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Agreed to on division  24

Clause  1,  page  2,  line  9,  at end insert—

“( )
A further recall condition (section 10) is that—

(a)
the MP has, after becoming an MP, been convicted of an offence under

section 10 of the Parliamentary Standards Act 2009 (offence of providing

false or misleading information for allowances claims);

(b)
the appeal period expires without the conviction having been overturned

on appeal.


Sections 2 to 4 contain more about this recall condition.”

Mark Durkan

Not called  34

Clause  1,  page  2,  line  9,  at end insert—

“( )
A further recall condition is that the MP has been adjudged by an election court

(as set out in section (Complaint of breach of MP’s Pledge)) to have acted in a

way that is contrary to the MP’s Pledge as set out in section (MP’s Pledge)”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Agreed to on division  16

Clause  2,  page  2,  line  18,  leave out “The reference in” and insert “In”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Not called  25

Clause  2,  page  2,  line  18,  leave out “(the first recall condition)” and insert “and ( )

(the first and section 10 recall conditions)”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Not called  17

Clause  2,  page  2,  line  18,  leave out from “to an offence” to the end of the

subsection and insert—

:
272

, continued

“(a)
the reference to an offence includes an offence committed before the MP

became an MP and an offence committed before the day on which section

1 comes into force, but

(b)
the reference to an MP being convicted of an offence is only to an MP

being convicted of an offence on or after that day.”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Not called  26

Clause  2,  page  2,  line  21,  at end insert—

“( )
The reference in section 1(3) to an offence does not include an offence mentioned

in section 1(5A).”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Not called  27

Clause  3,  page  2,  line  43,  leave out “(the first recall condition)” and insert “and

(5A) (the first and section 10 recall conditions)”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Not called  28

Clause  3,  page  3,  line  3,  leave out subsections (2) to (4) and insert—

“( )
“Relevant appeal”, in relation to the first recall condition, means—

(a)
an appeal that—

(i)
is in respect of the conviction, sentence or order mentioned in

section 1(3), and

(ii)
is brought within the usual period, or

(b)
an appeal that—

(i)
is in respect of the determination of an appeal that was itself a

relevant appeal, and

(ii)
is brought within the usual period.

( )
“Relevant appeal”, in relation to the section 10 recall condition, means—

(a)
an appeal that—

(i)
is in respect of the conviction mentioned in section 1(5A) or of

any sentence or order imposed in relation to that conviction, and

(ii)
is brought within the usual period, or

(b)
an appeal that—

(i)
is in respect of the determination of an appeal that was itself a

relevant appeal, and

:
273

, continued

(ii)
is brought within the usual period.”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Not called  29

Clause  4,  page  3,  line  34,  after second “MP” insert—

“(a)
”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Not called  30

Clause  4,  page  3,  line  36,  at end insert “, or

(b)
is convicted of an offence mentioned in section 1( ) (relating to the

section 10 recall condition) within the meaning of that provision (see

section 2).”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Not called  31

Clause  4,  page  3,  line  37,  after “order”, insert “in relation to the conviction”

Thomas Docherty

Dr Julian Huppert

Stephen Twigg

Mr David Heath

Not called  32

Clause  4,  page  4,  line  4,  leave out paragraph (b) and insert—

“(b)
that—

(i)
in a case within subsection (1)(a), the conviction, sentence or

order has, or has not, been overturned on appeal;

(ii)
in a case within subsection (1)(b), the conviction has, or has not,

been overturned on appeal, and”

Mr David Heath

Dr Julian Huppert

Not called  3

Clause  5,  page  4,  line  16,  leave out “the first or second” and insert “a”



© Parliamentary copyright	Revised 25 November 2014