Previous Section Home Page

Pit Closures

Mr. Churchill : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer pursuant to his answer to the hon. Member for Clydebank and Milngavie (Mr. Worthington) of 21 October, Official Report, column 315, if he will now make it his policy to establish a study of the cost to be incurred by the loss of income tax, VAT and national insurance contributions and the payment of unemployment and other social security benefits in respect of the closure of the 31 pits originally indicated in the announcement of 13 October, so far as the figure can be assessed.

Mr. Dorrell : There is no means of accurately assessing these costs. To estimate the net cost of closing a pit it would be necessary to establish the costs of alternative courses of action. For example, the cost of subsidising a pit would have to be borne by electricity consumers, taxpayers or by diverting funds from other public expenditure programmes, all of which would have implications for employment elsewhere which are impossible to assess accurately.

Trinidad Agreement

Mr. Llwyd : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make it his policy to extend the terms of the Trinidad agreement to cover Zambia and Zimbabwe.

Mr. Dorrell : Debt relief on Trinidad terms has been extended by the Paris club to a total of 10 of the world's poorest and most heavily indebted countries, including Zambia, but Trinidad terms are not intended for less-indebted, lower-middle income countries such as Zimbabwe.

Departmental Properties

Mr. Redmond : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will list for each local authority area in south Yorkshire, how many residential properties are currently owned by his Department ; and if he will list, by location, those residential properties which are empty, giving the type of accommodation available, the length of time each property has been vacant, and its intended future use.

Sir John Cope : Departments of the Chancellor of the Exchequer do not own any residential property in South Yorkshire.

Debt

Mr. Dafis : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will make it his policy to increase the proportion of developing country debt eligible for write-off from 50 per cent. to 66 per cent.

Sir John Cope : The Government were responsible for the Trinidad initiative to tackle the debt burden of the poorest and most indebted countries, and hopes that Trinidad terms can be developed further in the direction of our original proposals which were for a benchmark figure of two thirds reduction applied immediately to the whole stock of debt.


Column 677

Public Record Office

Mr. Redmond : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer how many papers his Department has currently withdrawn from the Public Record Office ; if he will list their titles ; and when he estimates that they will be returned.

Sir John Cope : Government Departments have a statutory right under the Public Records Acts to retrieve records temporarily from the Public Record Office for their own administrative use. Her Majesty's Treasury currently has 173 records out on loan. To list them all would involve disproportionate cost. Records are returned as soon as departmental action has been completed.

Trinidad Terms

Mr. Dafis : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what efforts have been undertaken by his Department to persuade other creditor countries to join the Trinidad terms agreement.

Sir John Cope : The Government have given a strong lead in tackling the debt burden of the poorest and most indebted countries and was responsible for both the Toronto and the Trinidad initiatives. The Government are committed to the task of persuading its Paris club partners to agree further improvements to the Trinidad terms, including encouraging all creditors, without exception, to implement debt reduction under these agreed terms.

Value Added Tax

Mr. Stevenson : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what assessment has been made into the effect of value added tax changes that require payment on account rather than in arrears in Stoke-on-Trent, South ; and if he will make a statement.

Sir John Cope : It is not possible to analysise by constituency area the effects of the requirement that the largest VAT payers should make payments monthly in arrears rather than quarterly in arrears. Overall, the change brings United Kingdom practice into line with that in most other EC member states, and offsets the cash flow loss to the Exchequer which would otherwise arise as a result of the reintroduction in this financial year of postponed accounting for VAT on acquisitions from other EC countries.

Savings

Mr. Wareing : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the amount of (a) personal and (b) corporate savings in each of the years 1981 to 1991 inclusive ; and what was the total amount of savings represented as a proportion of gross domestic product in each of these years.

Mr. Dorrell : The figures for savings, before deducting depreciation and stock appreciation, are as follows :


                  |Personal sector  |Corporate sector |Total savings as                   

                  |savings          |savings          |percentage of GDP                  

                                                      |(A) at market                      

                                                      |prices                             

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1981              |22.3             |28.0             |19                                 

1982              |21.6             |30.8             |18                                 

1983              |19.9             |39.4             |19                                 

1984              |24.7             |40.7             |19                                 

1985              |25.9             |42.7             |19                                 

1986              |22.8             |46.0             |17                                 

1987              |19.6             |54.7             |18                                 

1988              |17.8             |56.4             |18                                 

1989              |23.5             |54.5             |18                                 

1990              |31.7             |50.7             |17                                 

1991              |39.8             |46.5             |15                                 

North Sea Gas

Mr. Salmond : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what estimate he has made of the effect on tax revenue (a) in total and (b) in percentage terms, of offsets against petroleum revenue taxation resulting from the project for the offshore transportation of gas from the central North sea via the central area transmission system to Teesside ; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Dorrell : I have made no such estimate.

Retail Prices Index

Mr. Blunkett : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what was the percentage change in (a) the retail prices index and (b) the health service prices index between September 1991 and September 1992 ; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Portillo [holding answer 6 November 1992] : The retail prices index rose by 3.6 per cent. and the health service prices index rose by 4.8 per cent.

Unlike the retail prices index, the health service prices index measures changes in input costs, whereas it is output costs which bear on the amount of health care delivered. Output costs in the NHS have over long periods moved in line with those in the economy, taking account of efficiency gains.

Auditors

Mr. Austin Mitchell : To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will bring forward proposals for legislation under which auditors of insurance companies would be prohibited from recruiting company directors.

Mr. Neil Hamilton : I have been asked to reply.

I see no reason to do so. Ethical guidance issued by the professional accountancy bodies states that no one should take part in the audit of a company if he has, during the period on which the report is to be made or at any time in the two years prior to the first day of that period, been an officer, other than auditor, or employee of that company. Under part II of the Companies Act 1989, recognised supervisory bodies are required to have adequate rules and practices as to professional integrity and independence.


Column 679

EDUCATION

Higher Education

Mrs. Dunwoody : To ask the Secretary of State for Education what percentage of 18-year-olds are in higher education in (a) the United Kingdom, (b) the United States of America and (c) Japan.

Mr. Forman : The readily available figures are given in the table and represent participation at all ages--generally 18 and over.


New entrants<1> to higher education, 1988                                           

Country              |(main ages on entry)|Participation                            

                                          |rate<2>                                  

                                          |(percentage)                             

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Japan<3>             |18                  |37-52                                    

United Kingdom<4>    |18-21               |37                                       

United States of                                                                    

  America<5>         |18                  |33-65                                    

<1>Includes full-time and part-time students entering higher education for the      

first time i.e. excluding postgraduate students and others already having a         

qualification in higher education.                                                  

<2>To aid comparison and overcome the problem of the varying lengths of courses in  

different countries, the participation rate is the percentage of all new entrants ( 

defined above) to a derived relevant single year group. The latter is calculated by 

taking the total populations for the ages providing at least 70 per cent. of the    

new entrants and dividing by the number of ages involved. For the United Kingdom    

this is the population of ages 18 to 21 divided by 4. OECD recommend this           

procedure.                                                                          

<3>The higher figure shown includes data for advanced special training schools (    

SENSHU') which may be equivalent to sub-degree higher education.                    

<4>Excludes the private sector and students from abroad. Includes nursing and       

paramedical students at Health Department establishments.                           

<5>The lower figure excludes students on two-year courses, some of which may not be 

equivalent to sub-degree higher education.                                          

Public Record Office

Mr. Redmond : To ask the Secretary of State for Education how many papers his Department has currently withdrawn from the Public Record Office ; if he will list their titles ; and when he estimates that they will be returned.

Mr. Forman : Government Departments have a statutory right under the Public Records Acts temporarily to retrieve records from the Public Record Office for their own administrative use.

The Department for Education regularly withdraws records relating to closed voluntary schools to deal with legal issues surrounding the disposal of premises. At present, the Department holds 50 records ; of which nine are for those purposes described above. The others are being scrutinised for early release to the public. To list them all would involve disproportionate cost.

It is unusual for this Department to withdraw records for more than two weeks and all are returned as soon as departmental action is complete.

Universal Education

Mrs. Bridget Prentice : To ask the Secretary of State for Education what contribution the United Kingdom is making to the

UNESCO-co-ordinated initiative, "Education for All" ; and what work his Department is doing towards achieving the objective of basic education for every child and adult around the world.


Column 680

Mr. Forman : The Government support the objective of ensuring universal access to basic education. In the United Kingdom education is compulsory for all children of school age. The Government also recognise the importance of basic education for adults. Under the Further and Higher Education Act 1992, the further education funding councils will be under a duty to secure the provision of adequate facilities for literacy and numeracy teaching for adults. The Goverment will also continue to promote education in developing countries in collaboration with other aid donors, including UNESCO, UNICEF and the World bank. The Overseas Development Administration aims to identify new projects which will improve the quality, availability and relevance of education in developing countries, with particular reference to promoting literacy for women.

Departmental Properties

Mr. Redmond : To ask the Secretary of State for Education if he will list, for each local authority area in South Yorkshire, how many residential properties are currently owned by his Department ; and if he will list, by location, those residential properties which are empty, giving the type of accommodation available, the length of time each property has been vacant, and its intended future use.

Mr. Forman : The Department owns no properties in South Yorkshire.

School Phobia

Mr. Hinchliffe : To ask the Secretary of State for Education what research has been undertaken into school phobia ; and what advice local education authorities receive in order to deal with this condition.

Mr. Forth : The most recent research on school phobia known to the Department is that undertaken by Mr. Nigel Blagg and summarised in his publication "School Phobia and its Treatment", published in 1987. The Department has not issued any guidance on the subject to date.

Nursery Education

Miss Lestor : To ask the Secretary of State for Education how much money has been made available for nursery education under the capital grants system for grant-maintained schools for the financial years 1991-92, 1992-93 and how much has been allocated for 1993-94.

Mr. Forth : No money has been specifically set aside for nursery education under the capital grants system. All bids for capital grants are considered on their merits in the light of the funds available and the competing needs of all the schools in the grant-maintained sector.

Miss Lestor : To ask the Secretary of State for Education what guidance he has given to chairmen and governors of grant-mainted schools concerning the eligibility of nursery education projects for support funding under the allocation of capital grants to grant-maintained schools for 1993-94.

Mr. Forth : No specific guidance has been issued to cover nursery provision. The guidance offered to schools on capital bids applies throughout the grant-maintained sector, and as such includes nursery projects.


Column 681

Workers Educational Association

Mr. Hinchliffe : To ask the Secretary of State for Education what is the current level of funding for the Workers Educational Association ; and what is the projected funding for this organisation for the next financial year.

Mr. Forman : The Workers Educational Association in England is currently funded by a mixture of direct grant from the Department for Education and education support grant via local education authorities. In 1992-93 DFE grant is £2,266,000, while ESG funding, 70 per cent. of which is also provided by central Government, amounts to £1.3 million.

From 1993-94, the Further Education Funding Council for England will take over responsibility for the grant currently paid by the Department for Education. It will be for the council to determine the level of that funding in the light of the overall resources available to it. The ESG funding will continue in 1993-94 at the same level as in 1992-93.

Discretionary Awards

Mr. Hinchliffe : To ask the Secretary of State for Education (1) what was the total expenditure, in each local education authority, for major discretionary awards in the last available financial year ;

(2) how many local education authorities did not give major discretionary awards to students in the last financial year.

Mr. Forman : The available information is shown in the table. Three LEAs--Avon, Berkshire and Sunderland--were unable to provide information ; one--Camden--made 149 discretionary awards at 50 to 100 per cent. of the mandatory rate ; and two--Trafford and Isles of Scilly--made no such awards.


Academic year 1990-91                                      

Discretionary awards paid at 50 to 100 per cent. of        

mandatory rate                                             

total expenditure on fees and maintenance                  

Local authority        |Total expenditure                  

-----------------------------------------------------------

City of London         |18,798                             

Camden                 |n/a                                

Greenwich              |353,670                            

Hackney                |645,103                            

Hammersmith            |307,388                            

Islington              |57,013                             

Kensington             |363,340                            

Lambeth                |984,677                            

Lewisham               |807,683                            

Southwark              |709,091                            

Tower Hamlets          |430,447                            

Wandsworth             |2,011,917                          

Westminster            |243,983                            

ILEA                   |6,252,653                          

Barking                |248,514                            

Barnet                 |137,877                            

Bexley                 |365,139                            

Brent                  |810,816                            

Bromley                |767,568                            

Croydon                |515,467                            

Ealing                 |869,155                            

Enfield                |456,151                            

Haringey               |105,806                            

Harrow                 |371,725                            

Havering               |439,685                            

Hillingdon             |317,122                            

Hounslow               |199,896                            

Kingston               |434,735                            

Merton                 |202,681                            

Newham                 |445,621                            

Redbridge              |907,650                            

Richmond               |559,539                            

Sutton                 |259,318                            

Waltham Forest         |580,722                            

Birmingham             |1,776,135                          

Coventry               |248,311                            

Dudley                 |275,699                            

Sandwell               |543,469                            

Solihull               |289,691                            

Walsall                |1,343,472                          

Wolverhampton          |223,502                            

Knowsley               |1,179,233                          

Liverpool              |2,806,557                          

St. Helens             |209,906                            

Sefton                 |931,970                            

Wirral                 |1,709,108                          

Bolton                 |849,613                            

Bury                   |470,671                            

Manchester             |417,897                            

Oldham                 |281,725                            

Rochdale               |364,178                            

Salford                |154,132                            

Stockport              |352,327                            

Tameside               |240,561                            

Trafford               |0                                  

Wigan                  |262,426                            

Barnsley               |908,022                            

Doncaster              |455,264                            

Rotherham              |259,742                            

Sheffield              |427,225                            

Bradford               |1,535,646                          

Calderdale             |500,408                            

Kirklees               |1,550,050                          

Leeds                  |1,511,568                          

Wakefield              |806,997                            

Gateshead              |710,585                            

Newcastle              |402,324                            

North Tyneside         |571,188                            

South Tyneside         |471,657                            

Sunderland             |n/a                                

Isles of Scilly        |0                                  

Clwyd                  |1,354,949                          

Dyfed                  |434,253                            

Gwent                  |827,120                            

Gwnedd                 |40,344                             

Mid Glamorgan          |810,978                            

Powys                  |726,730                            

South Glamorgan        |1,401,259                          

West Glamorgan         |1,039,103                          

Bedfordshire           |755,605                            

Buckinghamshire        |1,188,107                          

Cambridgeshire         |1,769,427                          

Cheshire               |5,361,145                          

Cleveland              |1,732,699                          

Cornwall               |1,083,959                          

Cumbria                |2,577,192                          

Derbyshire             |1,169,704                          

Devon                  |4,739,157                          

Dorset                 |2,856,554                          

Durham                 |1,876,144                          

Essex                  |2,737,523                          

Gloucestershire        |2,297,285                          

Hampshire              |6,466,014                          

Hereford and Worcester |1,455,101                          

Hertfordshire          |1,341,536                          

Humberside             |3,772,527                          

Isle of Wight          |367,022                            

Kent                   |4,698,803                          

Lancashire             |5,251,306                          

Leicestershire         |4,925,489                          

Lincolnshire           |1,463,177                          

Norfolk                |2,153,400                          

North Yorkshire        |8,114,410                          

Northamptonshire       |1,186,418                          

Northumberland         |655,407                            

Nottinghamshire        |2,739,570                          

Oxfordshire            |1,230,249                          

Shropshire             |1,550,763                          

Somerset               |1,573,456                          

Staffordshire          |1,510,034                          

Suffolk                |2,969,060                          

Surrey                 |1,305,778                          

Warwickshire           |553,503                            

West Sussex            |591,123                            

Wiltshire              |1,308,156                          

Avon                   |n/a                                

Berkshire              |n/a                                

                       |-------                            

Total                  |141,997,949                        

Mr. Hinchliffe : To ask the Secretary of State for Education (1) what action can be taken by students, in local education authorities where major discretionary awards have been cut or withdrawn, in order to finance non-degree or degree equivalent courses ; and if he will make a statement ;

(2) what steps he will take to ensure an equitable availability of major discretionary awards between local education authorities.

Mr. Forman : It is for each local education authority to determine its own policies and expenditure on discretionary awards in the light of local needs and priorities. The local authority grant settlement for 1992- 93 allowed for a substantial increase in overall education spending. Students who are unsuccessful in obtaining discretionary awards may seek help from, for example, their institutions' access funds, sponsors such as employers, educational trusts or other sources.

Schools

Mr. Hinchliffe : To ask the Secretary of State for Education how many local education authority schools were open and functioning in each year since 1979.

Mr. Forth : The table shows, for each year since 1979, the number of LEA-maintained schools in England which were open in January of each year.


Column 684


        |Schools        

------------------------

1979    |28,085         

1980    |28,006         

1981    |27,747         

1982    |27,323         

1983    |26,974         

1984    |26,479         

1985    |26,110         

1986    |25,800         

1987    |25,593         

1988    |25,389         

1989    |25,158         

1990    |24,999         

1991    |24,759         

<1>1992 |24,449         

<1> Provisional         

Disabled Students

Mr. Hinchliffe : To ask the Secretary of State for Education what level of funding local education authorities receive in order to ensure access to education establishments for disabled persons.

Mr. Forth : Local authorities do not receive any grant specifically for this purpose. Central Government support for local authorities is virtually entirely through general grant, which is not hypothecated to particular purposes. Local authorities are thus free to determine their own spending priorities. Information on local education authorities' spending to ensure access to education establishments for disabled persons is not collected centrally.

University Admissions

Dr. Wright : To ask the Secretary of State for Education if he will list, for the last five years, the figures for admission to British universities by type of school of those admitted ; and if he will give both the aggregate figure and the figure for each university.

Mr. Forman : The number of United Kingdom domiciled candidates in Great Britain accepted through the UCCA scheme for entry to full-time and sandwich first degree courses at United Kingdom universities are shown in the table.


Column 683


Academic Year Beginning                                     

                        |1986 |1987 |1988 |1989 |1990       

                        |0000s|0000s|0000s|0000s|0000s      

------------------------------------------------------------

Maintained Schools                                          

Grammar/Technical       |4.7  |4.6  |4.6  |5.1  |5.8        

Sixth Form College      |6.2  |6.7  |6.4  |7.2  |8.7        

Comprehensive           |20.9 |20.7 |20.8 |22.7 |25.6       

Other Secondary         |0.2  |0.2  |0.1  |0.1  |0.2        

                        |---  |---  |---  |---  |---        

Total<1>                |37.5 |37.8 |37.6 |40.8 |46.0       

                        |---  |---  |---  |---  |---        

Independent Schools<1>  |14.9 |14.7 |15.5 |16.8 |18.6       

FHE Sector<1>           |8.2  |8.3  |10.1 |11.3 |13.8       

                        |---  |---  |---  |---  |---        

Total<1>                |60.6 |60.8 |63.3 |69.1 |78.4       

                                                            

Not Classified<1><2>    |10.9 |11.9 |11.2 |11.6 |14.1       

Total Acceptances<1><2> |71.3 |72.7 |74.4 |80.6 |92.5       

Source: UCCA Statistical Supplements.                       

<1> Includes acceptances from Scotland.                     

<2> Includes acceptances of those who applied direct to     

UCCA, whether or not they were attending an FHE institution 

at the time.                                                

Information for each institution individually is not published by UCCA.

School Transport

Mr. Bates : To ask the Secretary of State for Education what action he proposes to take with regard to the proposal in the consultation paper "Competing for Quality : Competition in the Provision of Local Services" to introduce compulsory competitive tendering for transport centrally organised by local education authorities for journeys between home and school or college.

Mr. Forth : My right hon. Friend, and my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Wales, remain committed to imposing a rigorous competitive regime on local authorities' provision of vehicles for home to school and home to college transport. In the light of responses to "Competing for Quality", they have concluded that this can best be achieved by imposing on all authorities, not just those running their own transport fleets, a competitive tendering regime compatible with that already required by the Transport Act 1985 in respect of public transport subsidised by local authorities. This will enable authorities to continue to make co-ordinated, cost-effective arrangements for all transport provided from or assisted by public funds, as required by the 1985 Act. It will also mean that local transport operators will work under a single tendering regime.

The 1985 Act regime needs to be amended to provide for competition between private contractors and authorities' own work forces in accordance with the principles of the compulsory competitive tendering regime laid down in the Local Government Act 1988. This will require primary legislation, which will be brought forward at the earliest opportunity.

NATIONAL HERITAGE

Battlefield Sites

Mr. Redmond : To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage if he will list, by county for the United Kingdom, the initiatives he proposes to introduce to secure the preservation of battlefield sites.

Mr. Brooke : The Government have invited English Heritage to prepare a register of battlefield sites in England to inform planning decisions which may affect them. The National Army museum is currently undertaking the research for the register on behalf of English Heritage. The register should be available for consultation early next year. Responsibility for the preservation of battlefield sites in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland rests with the relevant Secretaries of State.

Local Authority Services

Mr. Steen : To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage how the Government intend to proceed on the proposed extension of compulsory competitive tendering to local authority managed arts facilities and public library support services.

Mr. Brooke : The Government believe that the wider application of competition to the provision of local authority services will bring significant benefits in terms of the quality and value for money for the public.


Column 686

Proposals to extend compulsory competitive tendering (CCT) to a range of local authority services, including arts facilities and library support services, were set out in the consultation paper "Competing for Quality", published in November 1991. I have discussed with my right hon. Friends the Secretaries of State for Scotland and for Wales the responses to that document which referred to arts and library services, and we are agreed on the way forward in those areas.

On arts facilities, my Department received some 180 responses, mostly from local authorities and arts organisations. We are grateful for the helpful comments contained in those responses. In reaching conclusions, I have also taken into account the Audit Commission's report "Local Authorities, Entertainment and the Arts" (January 1991), which identified three principal weaknesses in local authority arts management : lack of policy objectives, absence of monitoring of performance and inadequate financial control.

On the evidence before me, I am satisfied that there is scope to improve local authority arts provision through the introduction of increased competition. However, I have also concluded from that evidence that there are appreciable differences between the management of arts facilities and that of most of the other services to which the extension of CCT has been set out in a written reply by my right hon. and learned Friend the Secretary of State for the Environment. Particularly important considerations are the wide diversity between local authorities in the extent and type of arts facilities provided and the very long planning times required in drawing up arts programmes.

In view of these differences, I propose to commission consultants to undertake further studies in order to determine how competition might best be applied to this area of local authority management. In addition, to assist local authorities in clarifying and monitoring their service objectives, the Audit Commission will be invited to identify and disseminate models of good practice.

With regard to public library support services, we received 130 responses to the consultation paper from commercial library suppliers, individual librarians and members of the public as well as from local authorities. Many local authority responses drew on experience with existing contracts for library support services or on studies which they had already carried out into the potential for contracting out support work. I am grateful for the helpful way in which respondents dealt with our proposal.

From this evidence, it is clear to me that competition has already resulted in value for money from library support services and that there is little scope for further cost reductions in the areas covered in the consultation exercise. I have concluded, therefore, that CCT for support services would not necessarily be the best way forward for encouraging greater competition in the public library field.

However, I do see scope for extending the contracting out of services in the library field, if necessary on a compulsory basis. The consultation exercise showed a need to consider library operations on a wider basis, rather than arbitrarily designating certain aspects in advance as ancillary. I therefore propose a thorough investigation, based upon a series of pilot projects designed to examine the feasibility of contracting out the direct delivery of all or various parts of the library service. These will take place over the next 18 months and, throughout the investigation, I look forward to a close partnership with local authorities


Column 687

and other interested organisations including the library suppliers. My Department will establish a steering committee to advise and monitor the investigation.

Once the investigation is complete, I shall make the results widely available. I intend in so doing to set out a range of competitive options for library authorities to choose between, having regard to their particular circumstances.

Performances

Mr. Fisher : To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage if he will list the performances of (a) theatre, (b) dance, (c) opera and (d) music which he has attended in an official capacity since taking up his appointment.

Mr. Brooke : Since my appointment as Secretary of State for National Heritage I have attended performances of "Three Birds Alighting on a Field" at the Royal Court theatre, the Duenna at Opera North, a memorial concert for Sir Andrzej Panufnik at the Queen Elizabeth hall, a concert given by the Guildhall chamber orchestra and a private concert in honour of the eightieth birthday of Sir Georg Solti. I shall be attending the opening concert of the Scandinavian arts festival at the Barbican and the Royal Ballet's performance of "Mayerling" this week. I have also visited the Yorkshire Sculpture park, and the MENCAP art exhibition.

Ministerial Visits

Mr. Fisher : To ask the Secretary of State for National Heritage how many regional arts boards he has visited since taking up his appointment.

Mr. Brooke : I met the chairman and director of the Yorkshire and Humberside arts board when I visited Yorkshire on 1 October. My hon. Friend the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State has to date also met representatives of the Northern, North West and London arts boards on visits to those regions. In addition, I held a meeting with the chairmen-- or their representatives--of all the regional arts boards on 28 October.

HOME DEPARTMENT

Greyhound Racing

Mr. Meale : To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what action he will take to promote the well-being of greyhound racing.

Mr. Peter Lloyd : The promotion of greyhound racing is the responsibility of the industry itself. However, when general betting duty was reduced in the Budget, my right hon. Friend the Chancellor of the Exchequer expressed the hope that voluntary arrangements could be made for some of the money to go to greyhound racing. We understand that negotiations between greyhound racing and bookmakers are continuing in an effort to devise suitable arrangements for that purpose.

Mr. Page : To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will make a statement on the progress with the voluntary agreement between the off-course bookmakers and the greyhound racing industry over the transfer of the 0.25 per cent. reduction in betting duty introduced in April.


Column 688

Mr. Peter Lloyd : We understand that negotiations between the off- course bookmakers and the greyhound racing industry to devise suitable voluntary arrangements are continuing. We have been kept informed of developments, and hope that the negotiations can be brought to a successful conclusion in the near future.

Police (Housing)

Mr. Redmond : To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will set out the numbers and locations of empty service police housing quarters in South Yorkshire.

Mr. Charles Wardle : The Home Office does not hold information about the location of police housing, which is owned and managed by individual police authorities. According to information received from South Yorkshire police authority, eight houses were empty as at 31 March 1992. One of these is due to be re-allocated to a serving policy officer, and five have been identified for sale during the current financial year.

Emergency Services

Mr. Clelland : To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what was the total revenue expenditure in each of the English regions on police, fire and civil defence services in the years 1990-91 and 1991-92.

Mr. Charles Wardle : The available information on net revenue expenditure by English local authorities on these services in 1990-91 and 1991-92 is given in the table. Expenditure on these services is not aggregated on any regional basis.


Police                                            

Net current expenditure supported by Home Office  

specific grant                                    

(excluding loan charges)                          

£'000s                                            

--------------------------------------------------

Avon and Somerset   |102,351  |111,509            

Bedfordshire        |35,599   |39,148             

Cambridgeshire      |42,364   |47,116             

Cheshire            |62,370   |66,960             

Cleveland           |50,246   |54,802             

Cumbria             |39,612   |45,001             

Derbyshire          |61,261   |66,048             

Devon and Cornwall  |105,660  |117,649            

Dorset              |49,024   |52,006             

Durham              |44,964   |48,589             

Essex               |104,703  |115,540            

Gloucestershire     |40,236   |44,611             

Hampshire           |111,152  |124,869            

Hertfordshire       |58,743   |62,868             

Humberside          |69,697   |77,396             

Kent                |109,013  |128,734            

Lancashire          |108,135  |121,946            

Leicestershire      |61,274   |67,196             

Lincolnshire        |41,597   |47,235             

Norfolk             |48,115   |54,100             

Northamptonshire    |40,084   |45,498             

North Yorkshire     |47,396   |51,679             

Nottinghamshire     |75,709   |82,629             

Staffordshire       |74,272   |82,163             

Suffolk             |43,008   |48,042             

Surrey              |57,125   |63,421             

Sussex              |92,991   |105,647            

Thames Valley       |134,225  |149,414            

Warwickshire        |36,082   |39,842             

West Mercia         |68,707   |77,230             

Wiltshire           |40,885   |46,215             

                                                  

Greater Manchester  |228,550  |248,807            

Merseyside          |160,697  |178,881            

Northumbria         |121,364  |131,161            

South Yorkshire     |94,778   |103,165            

West Midlands       |229,256  |250,816            

West Yorkshire      |181,186  |197,226            

                                                  

City of London      |37,074   |40,820             

Metropolitan Police                               

  Department        |1,197,618|1,341,318          

                    |-------  |-------            

Total               |4,307,123|4,777,296          


Fire Service net expenditure                                           

(£000s)                                                                

                        Net expenditure                                

County councils        |1990-91        |1991-92                        

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Avon                   |17,562         |<1>19,411                      

Bedfordshire           |9,307          |<1>9,734                       

Berkshire              |13,546         |<1>13,586                      

Buckinghamshire        |10,206         |<1>10,700                      

Cambridgeshire         |10,485         |<1>11,160                      

Cheshire               |18,155         |18,642                         

Cleveland              |16,761         |<1>17,270                      

Cornwall               |8,648          |8,801                          

Cumbria                |10,176         |<1>10,079                      

Derbyshire             |15,954         |16,320                         

Devon                  |19,326         |18,971                         

Dorset                 |10,229         |<1>11,455                      

Durham                 |12,260         |<1>12,287                      

East Sussex            |13,319         |14,476                         

Essex                  |28,965         |29,994                         

Gloucestershire        |7,866          |<1>8,988                       

Hampshire              |23,462         |<1>24,763                      

Hereford and Worcester |10,933         |<1>11,286                      

Hertfordshire          |16,342         |<1>17,039                      

Humberside             |20,896         |20,985                         

Isle of Wight          |2,699          |2,885                          

Kent                   |27,778         |<1>31,839                      

Lancashire             |28,197         |<1>29,863                      

Leicestershire         |12,240         |<1>13,610                      

Lincolnshire           |9,387          |9,491                          

Norfolk                |12,047         |12,538                         

Northamptonshire       |9,064          |9,827                          

Northumberland         |7,589          |8,294                          

North Yorkshire        |13,165         |<1>13,129                      

Nottinghamshire        |17,769         |<1>18,642                      

Oxfordshire            |8,737          |<1>9,628                       

Shropshire             |6,896          |<1>7,193                       

Somerset               |7,329          |<1>7,684                       

Staffordshire          |17,901         |<1>18,087                      

Suffolk                |10,831         |<1>11,163                      

Surrey                 |21,974         |21,948                         

Warwickshire           |10,552         |<1>10,138                      

West Sussex            |12,035         |13,095                         

Wiltshire              |9,105          |<1>9,007                       

                                                                       

Fire and civil defence authorities                                     

London                 |215,031        |<1>221,533                     

Greater Manchester     |56,303         |58,993                         

Merseyside             |39,869         |<1>42,348                      

South Yorkshire        |28,070         |<1>27,900                      

Tyne and Wear          |28,577         |28,724                         

West Midlands          |53,580         |55,783                         

West Yorkshire         |47,087         |<1>48,588                      

Isles of Scilly        |86             |<1>93                          

                       |-------        |-------                        

England Total          |1,008,296      |1,047,970                      

<1> Outturn expenditure not available. Figures shown are local         

authority budget estimates.                                            


Column 690


Civil Defence                                       

Net current expenditure supported by Home Office    

specific grant                                      

£000s                                               

                            |1990-91|1991-92        

----------------------------------------------------

(i) County councils                                 

Avon                        |289    |321            

Bedfordshire                |208    |238            

Berkshire                   |403    |479            

Buckinghamshire             |362    |412            

Cambridgeshire              |384    |416            

Cheshire                    |501    |573            

Cleveland                   |212    |240            

Cornwall                    |320    |350            

Cumbria                     |379    |435            

Derbyshire                  |226    |259            

Devon                       |624    |663            

Dorset                      |321    |355            

Durham                      |241    |241            

East Sussex                 |319    |367            

Essex                       |482    |514            

Gloucestershire             |290    |295            

Hampshire                   |356    |426            

Hereford and Worcester      |240    |285            

Hertfordshire               |443    |497            

Humberside                  |351    |345            

Isle of Wight               |273    |297            

Kent                        |488    |550            

Lancashire                  |314    |311            

Leicestershire              |225    |248            

Lincolnshire                |391    |374            

Norfolk                     |421    |468            

Northamptonshire            |268    |293            

Northumberland              |308    |287            

North Yorkshire             |334    |364            

Nottinghamshire             |310    |349            

Oxfordshire                 |403    |424            

Shropshire                  |223    |276            

Somerset                    |322    |353            

Staffordshire               |289    |309            

Suffolk                     |298    |323            

Surrey                      |392    |384            

Warwickshire                |297    |321            

West Sussex                 |322    |340            

Wiltshire                   |339    |340            

                                                    

(ii) Fire and civil defence                         

  authorities                                       

London                      |1,638  |1,812          

Greater Manchester          |524    |574            

Merseyside                  |532    |628            

South Yorkshire             |436    |507            

Tyne and Wear               |431    |479            

West Midlands               |455    |495            

West Yorkshire              |454    |453            

                                                    

(iii) Police authorities                            

Avon-Somerset               |3      |5              

Greater Manchester          |4      |3              

Merseyside                  |7      |6              

Northumbria                 |11     |14             

Thames Valley               |12     |3              

West Mercia                 |0      |3              

West Midlands               |6      |3              

                                                    

(iv) London boroughs and                            

  City of London            |129    |94             

                            |-------|-------        

Total                       |17,810 |19,398         

Mr. A. Alexandrowicz

Mr. Gordon Prentice : To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department when the case of Anthony Alexandrowicz is to be considered by the Parole Board.

Mr. Peter Lloyd : Mr. Alexandrowicz is one of some 300 discretionary life prisoners who are now eligible for review


Column 691

under new procedures introduced as a result of section 34 of the Criminal Justice Act 1991. It is for the Parole Board to decide the order in which these cases are heard. To assist in this task, the board is provided with a list of those eligible in each prison establishment. These lists are compiled in accordance with the criteria announced in the Secretary of State's written answer to my hon. Friend the Member for Westminster, North (Sir J. Wheeler) on 9 March 1992, at column 396. Mr. Alexandrowicz will be notified as soon as his case is listed for hearing.

Primary Purpose Rule

Mr. Allen : To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what changes in trends have occurred since his announcement to adjust primary purpose guidance to allow entry to those spouses who can prove five years of marriage and supply evidence of devotion in this period.

Mr. Charles Wardle : I refer the hon. Member to the answer given to him on 4 November 1992, at columns 221-22.

Leave to Remain Status

Mr. Allen : To ask the Secretary of State for the Home Department what categories of status equivalent to exceptional leave to remain are operative in other EC countries ; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Charles Wardle : I refer the hon. Member to the reply given to him on 3 November, at column 125.


Next Section

  Home Page