Previous Section Home Page

Column 762


Population, number of staff employed and political control of each                              

local authority in Wales                                                                        

                                                      |Staff per                                

                          |Population<1>|Total        |1,000        |Political                  

                          |(000s)       |Staff<2>     |population   |control                    

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

County Councils                                                                                 

Clwyd                     |416          |14,041       |33.8         |LAB                        

Dyfed                     |352          |14,733       |41.9         |IND                        

Gwent                     |450          |17,988       |39.9         |LAB                        

Gwynedd                   |240          |9,342        |38.9         |IND                        

Mid Glamorgan             |544          |21,578       |39.6         |LAB                        

Powys                     |120          |<3>-         |<3>-         |IND                        

South Glamorgan           |413          |14,531       |35.2         |LAB                        

West Glamorgan            |371          |14,109       |38.0         |LAB                        

                                                                                                

Borough/District Councils                                                                       

Aberconwy                 |54           |483          |8.9          |NOC                        

Alyn and Deeside          |75           |601          |8.0          |LAB                        

Arfon                     |57           |561          |9.9          |PC                         

Blaenau Gwent             |77           |1,119        |14.5         |LAB                        

Brecknock                 |42           |251          |6.0          |IND                        

Cardiff                   |299          |3,630        |12.2         |LAB                        

Carmarthen                |56           |454          |8.1          |IND                        

Ceredigion                |69           |559          |8.1          |IND                        

Colwyn                    |57           |465          |8.2          |LDEM                       

Cynon Valley              |65           |634          |9.7          |LAB                        

Delyn                     |70           |661          |9.4          |IND                        

Dinefwr                   |39           |246          |6.4          |LAB                        

Dwyfor                    |27           |258          |9.5          |IND                        

Glyndwr                   |42           |345          |8.2          |IND                        

Islwyn                    |67           |736          |11.0         |LAB                        

Llanelli                  |74           |732          |9.9          |LAB                        

Lliw Valley               |65           |568          |8.8          |LAB                        

Meirionnydd               |33           |349          |10.7         |PC                         

Merthyr Tydfil            |60           |771          |12.9         |LAB                        

Monmouth                  |78           |570          |7.3          |CON                        

Montgomeryshire           |54           |460          |8.5          |IND                        

Neath                     |66           |626          |9.5          |LAB                        

Newport                   |137          |1,426        |10.4         |LAB                        

Ogwr                      |135          |1,259        |9.3          |LAB                        

Port Talbot               |51           |533          |10.4         |LAB                        

Preseli Pembroke          |71           |585          |8.3          |IND                        

Radnorshire               |24           |207          |8.5          |IND                        

Rhondda                   |78           |975          |12.4         |LAB                        

Rhuddlan                  |55           |495          |9.0          |IND                        

Rhymney Valley            |104          |1,188        |11.4         |LAB                        

South Pembroke            |43           |331          |7.7          |IND                        

Swansea                   |189          |2,528        |13.4         |LAB                        

Taff Ely                  |101          |804          |7.9          |LAB                        

Torfaen                   |91           |905          |10.0         |LAB                        

Vale of Glamorgan         |115          |868          |7.6          |LAB                        

Wrexham Maelor            |117          |1,297        |11.1         |LAB                        

Ynys Mon                  |69           |536          |7.7          |IND                        

<1> OPCS 1993 mid-year estimate.<2> Joint staffing watch data, June 1994 (provisional) except   

for Aberconwy (March 1993 figure) and Cynon Valley (March 1994 provisional figure); number of   

persons, full or part-time, in general services (excluding law or order).                       

<3> -denotes data not available for 1993 or 1994.                                               

Cadw

Mr. Llwyd: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales when Cadw will reopen an office in Gwynedd; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Gwilym Jones: This is a matter for the agency and I have asked the chief executive, Mr. John Carr, to write to the hon. Member.


Column 763

Letter from E. A. J. Carr to Mr. Elfyn Llwyd, dated13 February 1995:

The Secretary of State has asked me to reply to your Question in which you asked when Cadw would re-open an office in Gwynedd. The Agency has never had a public office in Gwynedd although it does have a Works management unit at Caernarfon. Our professional and field staff, however, travel frequently throughout Wales, providing a direct point of contact for members of public who may be potential grant applicants; offering advice to local authorities on statutory procedures and best practice in conservation; and also liaising with a range of bodies and organisations which have an interest in preserving and promoting the built heritage of Wales.

Cadw is committed to improving the standard of services it provides to the public generally and its customers, in particular, across the range of Agency activities. The views of customers on how well they feel we deliver those services, and suggestions for how we may better meet their needs, are always welcome and given careful consideration.

At present, however, the Agency has no plans to open a public office in the North Wales area.

Nature Conservation

Mr. Llwyd: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales when he will issue planning policy guidance on nature conservation in Wales; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Gwilym Jones: Draft guidance is being prepared and I intend to consult Welsh interests before the summer.

Mr. Dafis: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales when he intends to publish a Welsh Office equivalent of planning policy guidance 9, "Nature Conservation".

Mr. Gwilym Jones: Draft guidance is being prepared and I intend to consult Welsh interests before the summer.

Sustainable Development

Mr. Llwyd: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if it is his policy to implement in Wales the United Kingdom strategy for sustainable development in January 1994; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Gwilym Jones: The Government's strategy for sustainable development, published in January 1994, covers all parts of the United Kingdom; and provides a framework for action. In line with this, on 31 January 1995, my right hon. Friend published "The Environmental Agenda for Wales" setting out our plans for striking a sensible balance between development and conservation needs in the Principality. A copy of the agenda is available in the Library of the House.

Environmental Agenda

Mr. Llwyd: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales, what is the status of his statement on the environmental agenda for Wales in the planning system; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Gwilym Jones: The agenda reflects existing planning policies and should be taken into account by local planning authorities, where relevant, together with detailed planning policy guidance.

Community Areas and Councils

Mr. Llwyd: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will publish for each county and district council area in Wales and for Wales as a whole the number of (a) community areas, (b) community and town councils and (c) community or town councils which have (i) ceased


Column 764

to exist or (ii) been established during each of the last 10 years.

Mr. Gwilym Jones: The information requested by the hon. Member at (c) can be obtained only at disproportionate cost. The information requested at (a) and (b) is set out in the following table.


Numbers of community areas and town/community councils in                                                     

Wales                                                                                                         

                                                                  |Numbers of                                 

                                            |Numbers of           |town                                       

County                |District borough     |community            |community                                  

Councils              |councils             |areas                |councils                                   

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Clwyd                                       |127                  |122                                        

                      |Alyn and Deeside     |13                   |13                                         

                      |Colwyn               |19                   |16                                         

                      |Delyn                |21                   |21                                         

                      |Glyndwr              |35                   |35                                         

                      |Rhuddlan             |10                   |8                                          

                      |Wrexham Maelor       |29                   |29                                         

                                                                                                              

Dyfed                                       |202                  |202                                        

                      |Carmarthen           |41                   |41                                         

                      |Ceredigion           |51                   |51                                         

                      |Dinefwr              |23                   |23                                         

                      |Llanelli             |9                    |9                                          

                      |Preseli Pembrokeshire|52                   |52                                         

                      |South Pembrokeshire  |26                   |26                                         

                                                                                                              

Gwent                                       |82                   |66                                         

                      |Blaenau Gwent        |9                    |5                                          

                      |Islwyn               |12                   |0                                          

                      |Monmouth             |31                   |31                                         

                      |Newport              |14                   |14                                         

                      |Torfaen              |16                   |16                                         

                                                                                                              

Gwynedd                                     |122                  |122                                        

                      |Aberconwy            |18                   |18                                         

                      |Arfon                |17                   |17                                         

                      |Dwyfor               |17                   |17                                         

                      |Meirionnydd          |30                   |30                                         

                      |Ynys Mon             |40                   |40                                         

                                                                                                              

Mid Glamorgan                                100                   50                                         

                      |Cynon Valley         |11                   |3                                          

                      |Merthyr Tydfil       |12                   |1                                          

                      |Ogwr                 |22                   |22                                         

                      |Rhondda              |31                   |0                                          

                      |Rhymney Valley       |14                   |14                                         

                      |Taff Ely             |10                   |10                                         

                                                                                                              

Powys                                       |108                  |108                                        

                      |Brecknock            |36                   |36                                         

                      |Montgomeryshire      |45                   |45                                         

                      |Radnorshire          |27                   |27                                         

                                                                                                              

South Glamorgan                              54                    28                                         

                      |Cardiff              |30                   |5                                          

                      |Vale of Glamorgan    |24                   |23                                         

                                                                                                              

West Glamorgan                               68                    42                                         

                      |Port Talbot          |12                   |0                                          

                      |Lliw Valley          |14                   |14                                         

                      |Neath                |14                   |14                                         

                      |Swansea              |28                   |14                                         

                                                                                                              

Total for Wales                             |863                  |740                                        

Departmental Staff

Mr. Alex Carlile: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is the total number of staff employed by his Department (a) in Cardiff and (b) the rest of Wales.

Mr. Redwood: At 1 February, my Department, including Cadw, employed 1,701 permanent full-time equivalent staff in Cardiff and 566.5 permanent full-time equivalent staff throughout the rest of Wales.

Departmental Expenditure

Mr. Alex Carlile: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what was the total budget of his Department in (a) 1979, (b) 1986 and (c) 1994.

Mr. Redwood: Public expenditure within the responsibility of the Welsh Office totalled £1,769 million and £3,028 million in 1979 80 and 1986 87 respectively and that for 1994 95 is estimated to be £6, 585 million.

Quangos

Mr. Alex Carlile: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what was the total remuneration paid to members of quangos in Wales in 1993 94.

Mr. Redwood: The remuneration paid to members of executive non- departmental public bodies in 1993 94 was £773,226.57--excluding national insurance and pension contributions--made up as follows:


                                               |£                          

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Agricultural Wages Committees                  |992.95                     

Arts Council of Wales                          |nil                        

Cardiff Bay Development Corporation            |102,000.00                 

Countryside Council for Wales                  |96,760.00                  

Curriculum and Assessment Authority            |24,909.62                  

Development Board for Rural Wales              |112,479.00                 

Further Education Funding Council              |<1>32,358.00               

Higher Education Funding Council               |<1>31,417.00               

Housing for Wales                              |57,965.00                  

Land Authority for Wales                       |78,500.00                  

National Library of Wales                      |nil                        

National Museum of Wales                       |nil                        

Royal Common Ancient and Historical Monuments  |nil                        

Sports Council for Wales                       |24,753.00                  

Wales Tourist Board                            |71,000.00                  

Wales Youth Agency                             |4,900.00                   

Welsh Development Agency                       |<1>121,407.00              

Welsh Language Board                           |<2>4,785.00                

Welsh National Board for Nursing Midwifery and                             

  Health Visiting                              |9,000.00                   

<1> Excludes chief executive.                                              

<2> £1,712 was paid to chairman prior to the board's inception as an       

executive NDPB.                                                            

Artificial Limb and Appliance Service

Mr. Morgan: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales if he will place in the Library a copy of the letter dated 31 January from the British Limbless Ex-Servicemen's Association concerning the future management organisation of the artificial limb and appliance services Wales.

Mr. Redwood: With the agreement of the British Limbless Ex- Servicemen's Association, a copy of its letter of 31 January has been placed in the Library of the House.


Column 766

Prescribing

Mr. Morgan: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales, pursuant to his answers of 23 January, Official Report, column 66, 26 January, Official Report, columns 379 80, and 30 January, Official Report, column 535, what was the aggregate cost of prescribing for each family health services area authority divided by generic and brand name prescribing and for the total of fundholding GPs and non-fundholders.

Mr. Redwood: Data for October 1993 and October 1994 are as follows:


£000                                                        

                     October 1993    October 1994           

                    |Generic|Other  |Generic|Other          

------------------------------------------------------------

Clwyd Fundholders   |583    |583    |693    |599            

Non-fundholders     |705    |1,037  |764    |1,028          

                                                            

Dyfed Fundholders   |202    |180    |501    |469            

Non-fundholders     |914    |1,183  |791    |929            

                                                            

Gwent Fundholders   |314    |403    |427    |489            

Non-fundholders     |929    |1,277  |994    |1,209          

                                                            

Gwynedd Fundholders |18     |14     |174    |202            

Non-fundholders     |708    |1,051  |665    |1,080          

                                                            

Mid Glamorgan                                               

  Fundholders       |283    |250    |368    |265            

Non-fundholders     |1,403  |1,879  |1,556  |1,981          

                                                            

Powys Fundholders   |104    |128    |174    |209            

Non-fundholders     |206    |296    |178    |230            

                                                            

South Glamorgan                                             

  Fundholders       |114    |99     |353    |351            

Non-fundholders     |1,071  |1,299  |990    |1,088          

                                                            

West Glamorgan                                              

  Fundholders       |560    |608    |702    |644            

Non-fundholders     |605    |867    |619    |816            

Note:                                                       

Data for October 1992 are not readily available.            

Child Abuse

Mr. Morgan: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales on what date his Department was first informed in writing by a child care officer of allegations relating to wide spread child sex abuse at north Wales children's homes; and what steps his Department took to investigate the allegations.

Mr. Redwood: The Department received in June 1991 allegations from a child care worker formerly employed by Gwynedd county council, about sexual abuse of children in children's homes in north Wales. These matters became the subject of inquiries by the North Wales police.

Mr. Morgan: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what proposals he has for the Queen's counsel to be appointed to read the papers relating to child sex abuse cases in north Wales from the files of the Clwyd and Gwynedd county social services departments and the North Wales police also to be given duties to interview individuals who wish to volunteer statements to the Queen's counsel; and if he will make a statement.


Column 767

Mr. Redwood: Details of the investigation will be announced as soon as possible.

Local Agenda 21

Mr. Dafis: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what action he proposes to take to promote the drawing up of local agenda 21s.

Mr. Gwilym Jones: Action by councils in this general area is being taken forward under their local Agenda 21 initiative, co-ordinated at the United Kingdom level by the local authority associations. Although local strategies under agenda 21 are for individual councils to develop, the environmental agenda for Wales, recently published by my right hon. Friend, encourages Welsh councils, and others, to take a range of practical "green" measures.

Minerals Planning Guidance

Mr. Dafis: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales what is the latest version of minerals planning guidance on aggregates provision which applies to Wales; when it went out of print; and what steps he intends to take to ensure that the guidance on this subject issued by his Department will be taken fully into account by local authorities in Wales.

Mr. Gwilym Jones: Minerals planning guidance note 6--MPG 6-- "Guidelines for Aggregates Provision in England and Wales", is extant in so far as it relates to Wales: it went out of print in July 1994, although Her Majesty's Stationery Office can still supply copies through an out-of-print service. In October 1993, my right hon. Friend wrote to the leaders of all local authorities in Wales reminding them that government guidance must be fully taken into account when discharging their planning responsibilities.

NHS Suppliers (Payment)

Mr. Morgan: To ask the Secretary of State for Wales, pursuant to his answer of 26 January, Official Report, column 377, if he will place a copy in the Library of the guidance issued on prompt settlement of bills to NHS organisations; if he will list which NHS organisations have been sent a copy of this guidance; and if he will make a further statement.

Mr. Redwood: The guidance has been placed in the Library of the House.

SCOTLAND

Objective 1 Funding

Mrs. Ray Michie: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) if he will list the projects that have been approved for European Union objective 1 funding for the highlands and islands in the first round of (a) the European regional development fund and (b) the European social fund; what was the expenditure approved for each project and what was the total expenditure; and if he will place this information in the Library;

(2) what limitations apply to Government Departments for applying for European Union objective 1 funding for projects in the highlands and islands;


Column 768

(3) how much finance from objective 1 funds for the highlands and islands has so far been earmarked for (a) energy supply networks and (b) transport infrastructure; and if he will list the relevant projects;

(4) if he will list the projects that were not approved for European Union objective 1 funding for the highlands and islands in the first round of (a) the European social fund and (b) the European regional development fund;

(5) if he will list the successful applications for European Union objective 1 funding for the highlands and islands which are located in Argyll and Bute;

(6) what has been the total level of funding from objective 1 funds for the highlands and islands that has so far been earmarked for each Scottish Office Department; and what this is as a percentage of the total expenditure so far committed to projects.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton: Government Departments are able to compete for objective 1 funding on the same basis as other potential project sponsors.

To date, no funds have been allocated to the Scottish Office from the European regional development fund. Contributions from the European agricultural guidance and guarantee fund and the financial instrument for fisheries guidance of 47.08 million ecu, about £37 million, and 19.80 million ecu, about £16 million, respectively are expected over the life of the programme--1994 to 1999--in relation to schemes administered by the Scottish Office Agriculture and Fisheries Department for the benefit of farmers, crofters, food processors, fishermen, fish farmers, fishing industry organisations and local fishing port authorities and enterprises. Applications for support from the European social fund towards Government training programmes is made by Highlands and Islands Enterprise. These programmes will not take up any more than 40 per cent. of the European social fund resources.

In relation to the more specific questions on the first round of project consideration, as the information requested is lengthy, I shall arrange for copies of the tables to be placed in the House Library.

Cochlear Implants

Mr. Worthington : To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) what calculation he has made of the numbers of profoundly deaf children who would benefit from cochlear implants;

(2) what is the cost of a cochlear implant operation for a profoundly deaf child; and how many children in Scotland have received this operation in the current financial year;

(3) what representations he has received from the surgeons carrying out cochlear implants in Scotland about the best age for carrying out this operation; and what he is doing to match funding to the number of children needing this operation.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton: The national services division of the common services agency, which is responsible for purchasing this service, has commissioned an assessment of need for paediatric cochlear implantation in Scotland which will be published shortly. The findings of this report will inform future provision and funding levels for the service.

No representations have been received from surgeons carrying out cochlear implants in Scotland about the best age for undertaking the operation. A recent Medical


Column 769

Research Council evaluation study has indicated that, in general terms, cochlear implantation has favourable outcomes up to the age of seven years.

The cost of a paediatric cochlear implant operation is £28,725 in 1994 95. Five children have received this operation in Scotland in the current financial year. The numbers of children referred for operation to centres outwith Scotland is not held centrally.

Coastal Policy

Mr. Macdonald: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland (1) what is the expected publication date for the Scottish Office coastal discussion paper;

(2) what progress has been made on producing national planning policy guidance on the coast;

(3) what initiatives the Scottish Office is undertaking to promote coastal zone management in Scotland.

Sir Hector Monro: My officials are working on a discussion paper on coastal policy issues, which will be published as soon as possible. The paper will provide an overview of existing policies affecting the coast and will consider the need for planning guidance. It will also discuss the concept of coastal zone management as it applies to Scottish circumstances putting particular emphasis on partnership and the voluntary principle.

NHS Abortions

Mrs. Bridget Prentice: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many NHS abortions were performed under 13 weeks of pregnancy on women resident in each health board in 1993; and of these operations, how many involved admission and discharge on the same day.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton: The information is shown in the table below.


NHS therapeutic abortions performed in 1993 with an estimated                             

gestation of under 13 weeks; by health board of residence                                 

                                                  |Number discharged                      

Health board of               |Total              |on day of admission                    

residence                                                                                 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All Areas                     |9,963              |8,846                                  

Argyll and Clyde              |518                |422                                    

Ayrshire and Arran            |633                |623                                    

Borders                       |152                |146                                    

Dumfries and Galloway         |193                |47                                     

Fife                          |667                |576                                    

Forth Valley                  |445                |418                                    

Grampian                      |1,189              |997                                    

Greater Glasgow               |1,974              |1,858                                  

Highland                      |405                |332                                    

Orkney/Shetland/Western Isles |85                 |13                                     

Lanarkshire                   |848                |642                                    

Lothian                       |1,877              |1,826                                  

Tayside                       |977                |946                                    

Note:                                                                                     

Abortions performed on Scottish residents in England and Wales are excluded. All figures  

are provisional.                                                                          

Mrs. Bridget Prentice: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many abortions were performed on women resident in each health board in 1993; and, of these operations, how many were performed in NHS hospitals.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton: The information requested is shown in the table.


Column 770


Therapeutic Abortions in 1993; by health board of residence                               

                                                  |Number performed in                    

Health Board of               |Total              |NHS hospitals                          

Residence                                                                                 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All Areas                     |11,048             |10,922                                 

Argyll and Clyde              |601                |594                                    

Ayrshire and Arran            |671                |668                                    

Borders                       |164                |164                                    

Dumfries and Galloway         |216                |214                                    

Fife                          |761                |759                                    

Forth Valley                  |493                |485                                    

Grampian                      |1,363              |1,317                                  

Greater Glasgow               |2,142              |2,115                                  

Highland                      |453                |451                                    

Orkney/Shetland/Western Isles |96                 |96                                     

Lanarkshire                   |906                |896                                    

Lothian                       |2,093              |2,084                                  

Tayside                       |1,089              |1,079                                  

Abortions performed on Scottish residents in England and Wales are excluded. All figures  

are provisional.                                                                          

Sheriff Court Houses

Mr. Home Robertson: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the Sheriff court houses in Scotland which do not satisfy the objectives set out in the justice charter for Scotland in respect of (a) accessibility for disabled people, (b) adequate and comfortable accommodation, (c) refreshment facilities and (d) services for defence witnesses and lawyers.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton: Work is currently being undertaken to establish an independent assessment of the facilities provided in Sheriff court houses against the aims and objectives set out in the justice charter for Scotland. In recent years, a major programme of capital investment amounting to some £20 million per annum has been undertaken to improve facilities by providing new and refurbished court accommodation and this programme of work continues.

Scottish Avalanche Information Service

Mr. Charles Kennedy: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what plans he has to increase funding to the Scottish avalanche information service following the recent avalanche on Liathach, Torridon, Wester Ross; and if he will make a statement.

Sir Hector Monro: The Scottish avalanche information service is administered by the Scottish Sports Council and is funded from the grant in aid total provided to the council by the Scottish Office. Any increase in funding is therefore a matter for the council in the first instance. The coverage of the scheme is reviewed regularly and at the end of this winter season, the council will be considering whether changes to the existing arrangements are necessary.

Local Authority Schools (Recruitment)

Mr. Worthington: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the local authority schools in Scotland that seek to recruit nationally.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton: This information is not held centrally. However, I am not aware of any local authority school that recruits nationally, either as regards staff or pupils, although education authorities do place advertisements from time to time.


Column 771

Local Authority Schools (Funding)

Mr. Worthington: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the schools in Scotland that he directly funds independently of local authorities.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton: The Scottish Office Education Department provides annual grants for the operation of the following schools:

Dornoch academy, Sutherland

Jordanhill school, Glasgow

and provides grants towards the costs of operating the following schools:

Royal Blind school, Edinburgh

Donaldson's college, Edinburgh

Harmeny school, Balerno, Midlothian

East Park Home school, Glasgow

Stanmore House residential school, Lanark

Corseford residential school, Kilbarchan

Craighalbert centre, Cumbernauld

The New school, Butterstone, Dunkeld

The Scottish Home and Health Department provides occasional grants towards the capital costs of secure accommodation provision at St. Mary's Kenmure, Bishopbriggs and at Rossie school, near Montrose.

Local Government Reorganisation

Mr. Worthington: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland whether the special circumstances of the music school attached to Douglas academy in Milngavie will be fully taken into account when he decides the financial allocation to the new East Dunbartonshire council.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton: As the October 1992 consultation paper "Shaping the New Councils" made clear, the distribution of aggregate external finance to the new councils following local government re- organisation will be subject to consultation with Convention of Scottish Local Authorities in the distribution committee of the working party on local government finance. As at present, the distribution will be determined by the client group assessment methodology. The distribution committee will be considering during the course of this year the preparation of grant aided expenditure assessment for each of the new councils.

Mr. Worthington: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will make a statement on his policy with regard to the music school attached to Douglas academy in Milngavie and similar establishments; and what plans he has to give special financial help to such ventures when the new councils are set up.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton: The Government recognise the important contribution which the music school and other similar schools in Scotland make to the education system. It was following recommendations in a report by the Scottish Education Department in 1976 that these schools were set up.


Column 772

The framework in the Local Government etc. (Scotland) Act 1994 should ensure maximum continuity between the existing and the new authorities in terms of provision of education services.

Provisions already exist under section 23(2) of the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 to safeguard the financial position of an authority which, as in the case of Douglas academy, is providing education for pupils from another authority's area. Section 23(2) provides a mechanism whereby such an authority may recoup the costs incurred by so doing.

Procurator Fiscals

Mr. Salmond: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many procurator fiscals or deputy procurator fiscals were attached to each procurator fiscal office in Scotland and if he will provide a breakdown of the average number of cases per procurator fiscal or deputy procurator fiscal in each office in (a) 1974, (b) 1984 and (c) 1994; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Lang: Precise staffing figures for 1974 are not available. In any event, the procurator fiscal service took over prosecution in the district court between 1975 and 1976 and this makes comparison of staffing levels prior to then inappropriate. The figures requested are provided below for the years 1976, 1984 and 1994. Little significance can be attached to them, since scope for comparison between staffing levels and bare case numbers is restricted by differing degrees of complexity and duration of cases, geographical considerations, and inter-office assistance.


                                                       |Average            

                                                       |per staff          

1976                     |PF       |Deputes  |Cases    |member             

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Aberdeen                 |1        |5        |10,207   |1,701              

Airdrie                  |1        |4        |6,547    |1,309              

Alloa                    |1        |-        |1,478    |1,478              

Arbroath                 |1        |-        |1,929    |1,929              

Ayr                      |1        |2        |5,246    |1,749              

Banff                    |1        |-        |1,401    |1,401              

Campbeltown              |1        |-        |826      |826                

Cupar                    |1        |-        |1,690    |1,690              

Dingwall/Tain            |1        |1        |2,526    |1,263              

Dornoch                  |1        |-        |546      |546                

Dumbarton                |1        |4.5      |5,663    |1,030              

Dumfries                 |1        |2        |5,311    |1,770              

Dundee                   |1        |4.5      |11,104   |2,019              

Dunfermline              |1        |1        |4,716    |2,358              

Dunoon                   |1        |-        |1,349    |1,349              

Duns                     |1        |-        |902      |902                

Edinburgh                |1        |13.5     |31,330   |2,161              

Elgin                    |1        |1.5      |3,268    |1,307              

Falkirk                  |1        |2        |5,143    |1,714              

Forfar                   |1        |-        |1,805    |1,805              

Fort William             |1        |-        |904      |904                

Glasgow                  |1        |35       |63,852   |1,774              

Greenock                 |1        |4        |7,281    |1,456              

Haddington               |1        |1        |2,761    |1,381              

Hamilton                 |1        |7.5      |12,366   |1,455              

Inverness                |1        |2        |5,395    |1,798              

Kilmarnock               |1        |4        |7,468    |1,494              

Kirkcaldy                |1        |2        |5,578    |1,859              

Kirkcudbright            |1        |-        |747      |747                

Kirkwall                 |1        |-        |612      |612                

Lanark                   |1        |1        |1,726    |863                

Lerwick                  |1        |-        |598      |598                

Linlithgow               |1        |2        |5,259    |1,753              

Oban                     |0.5      |-        |993      |993                

Paisley                  |1        |7        |11,334   |1,417              

Perth                    |1        |3        |5,527    |1,382              

Peterhead                |1        |-        |1,368    |1,368              

Portree                  |1        |-        |434      |434                

Rothesay                 |1        |-        |601      |601                

Selkirk/Jedburgh/Peebles |1        |1        |4,676    |2,338              

Stirling                 |1        |2        |3,987    |1,329              

Stonehaven               |1        |-        |1,821    |1,821              

Stornoway/Lochmaddy      |1        |-        |575      |575                

Stranraer                |1        |-        |1,113    |1,113              

Wick                     |1        |-        |1,204    |1,204              


                                                |Average            

                                                |per staff          

1984              |PF       |Deputes  |Cases    |member             

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Aberdeen          |1        |7.5      |14,888   |1,752              

Airdrie           |1        |5        |7,817    |1,303              

Alloa             |1        |1        |2,510    |1,255              

Arbroath          |1        |1        |2,467    |1,234              

Ayr               |1        |3        |7,316    |1,829              

Banff             |1        |-        |910      |910                

Campbeltown       |1        |-        |704      |704                

Cupar             |1        |-        |2,212    |2,212              

Dingwall          |1        |-        |1,513    |1,513              

Dornoch           |1        |-        |641      |641                

Dumbarton         |1        |5        |7,112    |1,185              

Dumfries          |1        |3        |7,295    |1,823              

Dundee            |1        |7        |14,061   |1,758              

Dunfermline       |1        |3        |5,912    |1,478              

Dunoon            |1        |-        |1,565    |1,565              

Duns              |1        |-        |743      |743                

Edinburgh         |1        |19.5     |57,952   |2,827              

Elgin             |1        |1        |3,909    |1,955              

Falkirk           |1        |3        |8,000    |2,000              

Forfar            |1        |-        |2,822    |2,822              

Fort William      |1        |-        |1,200    |1,200              

Glasgow           |1        |54.5     |71,948   |1,296              

Greenock          |1        |4        |6,641    |1,328              

Haddington        |1        |1        |3,211    |1,606              

Hamilton          |1        |11       |18,720   |1,560              

Inverness         |1        |3        |6,004    |1,501              

Jedburgh          |1        |-        |1,435    |1,435              

Kilmarnock        |1        |6        |11,230   |1,604              

Kirkcaldy         |1        |3        |7,294    |1,824              

Kirkcudbright     |1        |-        |919      |919                

Kirkwall          |1        |-        |592      |592                

Lanark            |1        |1        |2,168    |1,084              

Lerwick           |1        |-        |880      |880                

Linlithgow        |1        |3        |6,987    |1,747              

Oban              |1        |-        |1,499    |1,499              

Paisley           |1        |8.5      |11,541   |1,215              

Peebles           |1        |-        |611      |611                

Perth             |1        |3        |7,951    |1,988              

Peterhead         |1        |1        |2,204    |1,102              

Portree/Lochmaddy |1        |-        |708      |708                

Rothesay          |1        |-        |605      |605                

Selkirk           |1        |-        |1,639    |1,639              

Stirling          |1        |2        |4,870    |1,593              

Stonehaven        |1        |-        |2,581    |2,581              

Stornoway         |1        |-        |817      |817                

Stranraer         |1        |-        |2,164    |2,164              

Tain              |1        |-        |1,443    |1,443              

Wick              |1        |-        |1,116    |1,116              


                                                     |Average            

                                                     |per staff          

1994                   |PF       |Deputes  |Cases    |member             

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Aberdeen               |1        |12       |13,436   |1,034              

Airdrie                |1        |6        |6,645    |949                

Alloa                  |1        |1        |2,588    |1,294              

Arbroath               |1        |1        |3,060    |1,530              

Ayr                    |1        |4.5      |7,353    |1,337              

Banff                  |1        |-        |923      |923                

Campbeltown            |1        |-        |693      |693                

Cupar                  |1        |1        |2,111    |1,056              

Dingwall               |1        |-        |1,295    |1,295              

Dornoch/Tain           |1        |-        |1,738    |1,738              

Dumbarton              |1        |5.5      |7,339    |1,129              

Dumfries               |1        |4        |6,457    |1,291              

Dundee                 |1        |6.5      |11,044   |1,473              

Dunfermline            |1        |3        |7,035    |1,759              

Dunoon                 |1        |-        |1,145    |1,145              

Duns/Jedburgh          |1        |-        |3,323    |3,323              

Edinburgh/Peebles      |1        |26.5     |30,243   |1,100              

Elgin                  |1        |1        |3,658    |1,829              

Falkirk                |1        |5        |7,348    |1,225              

Forfar                 |1        |-        |2,235    |2,235              

Fort William           |1        |-        |1,524    |1,524              

Glasgow                |1        |61       |69,451   |1,120              

Greenock/Rothesay      |1        |4        |5,504    |1,101              

Haddington             |1        |1        |3,997    |1,999              

Hamilton               |1        |17       |17,255   |959                

Inverness              |1        |3        |6,634    |1,659              

Kilmarnock             |1        |7        |9,489    |1,186              

Kirkcaldy              |1        |3.5      |7,687    |1,708              

Kirkwall/Lerwick       |1        |-        |1,487    |1,487              

Lanark                 |1        |1        |3,723    |1,861              

Linlithgow             |1        |2.5      |6,973    |1,992              

Oban                   |1        |-        |1,123    |1,123              

Paisley                |1        |11       |10,746   |896                

Perth                  |1        |4.5      |7,623    |1,386              

Peterhead              |1        |-        |2,617    |2,617              

Portree/Lochmaddy      |1        |-        |721      |721                

Selkirk                |1        |-        |1,781    |1,781              

Stirling               |1        |3.5      |4,656    |1,035              

Stonehaven             |1        |-        |2,008    |2,008              

Stornoway              |1        |-        |904      |904                

Stanraer/Kirkcudbright |1        |1        |3,481    |1,741              

Wick                   |1        |-        |1,038    |1,038              

Mr. Salmond: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what resources were allocated to each procurator fiscal's office in Scotland for each of the last 10 years; and if he will break down this figure to show the average amount allocated per case dealt with by each office; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Lang: Resources are not allocated to individual offices on a per -case basis; they are allocated and managed regionally for the departmental settlement on a basis of past performance, local factors and forecast work load. Allocations per case would be unreliable, there being no meaningful comparison to be made on such a basis because of differing degrees of complexity and duration of cases, geographical variations and inter-office assistance.

Mr. Salmond: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list the number of cases dealt with by each procurator fiscal's office giving the numerical and percentage breakdown of cases which (a) were marked no proceedings, (b) were dealt with through fiscal fines, (c) proceeded to court, (d) resulted in charges being proved and (e) resulted in persons receiving a custodial sentence for the last 10 years for which figures are available; and if he will make a statement.


Column 775

Mr. Lang: As the information requested is lengthy I have arranged for it to be placed in the Library of the House.

GP Fundholders

Mr. Godman: To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland how many general practitioner fundholders in (a) Inverclyde, (b) Strathclyde and (c) Scotland as a whole have over-run their budgets; and what was the average amount of the over-run in each of the last two years.


Next Section

  Home Page