This Table of Contents lists column numbers, headings, time lines and names of Members in the Commons Hansard Debates text for
Tuesday 23 Apr 1996
Clicking on an item will fetch the appropriate file and position it with the item at the top of the screen.
Column: 179
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Social Security (Mr. Roger Evans)
Mr. Pike
Mr. Evans
Mr. John Marshall
Mr. Evans
Mr. Bradley
Column: 180
Mr. Evans
The Secretary of State for Social Security (Mr. Peter Lilley)
Mrs. Lait
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Sheerman
Mr. Lilley
Column: 181
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Social Security (Mr. Oliver Heald)
Mr. Butler
Mr. Heald
Mr. Frank Field
Mr. Heald
Mr. Waterson
Mr. Heald
Ms Lynne
Column: 182
Mr. Heald
Mr. Wicks
Mr. Heald
Madam Speaker
Mr. Heald
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Whittingdale
Column: 183
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Ashton
Mr. Lilley
Sir Norman Fowler
Column: 184
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Wigley
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Robert G. Hughes
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Chris Smith
Column: 185
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Arnold
Column: 186
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Barry Jones
Mr. Lilley
Mr. John Greenway
Mr. Lilley
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Social Security (Mr. Andrew Mitchell)
Mr. Sutcliffe
Column: 187
Mr. Mitchell
Mrs. Roe
Mr. Mitchell
Mr. Hain
Mr. Mitchell
Column: 188
Mr. Heald
Mr. Coombs
Mr. Heald
Mr. Denham
Mr. Heald
Mr. Heald
Mr. Leigh
Mr. Heald
Column: 189
Mr. Cousins
Mr. Heald
Mr. Anthony Coombs
Mr. Heald
Mr. Roger Evans
Mr. O'Hara
Column: 190
Mr. Evans
Mr. Lilley
Mr. Brazier
Mr. Lilley
Madam Speaker
Mr. Andrew Mitchell
Column: 191
Mrs. Clwyd
Mr. Mitchell
Dr. Spink
Mr. Mitchell
The Prime Minister (Mr. John Major)
Mr. Madden
Column: 192
The Prime Minister
Mr. Whitney
The Prime Minister
The Prime Minister
Ms Armstrong
The Prime Minister
Column: 193
The Prime Minister
Mr. Arnold
The Prime Minister
Mr. Blair
The Prime Minister
Mr. Blair
Column: 194
The Prime Minister
Mr. Blair
The Prime Minister
The Prime Minister
Sir Wyn Roberts
The Prime Minister
Column: 195
Mr. Ashdown
The Prime Minister
The Prime Minister
Mr. Hughes
Column: 196
The Prime Minister
Mr. Donald Anderson
The Prime Minister
The Prime Minister
Mr. Congdon
The Prime Minister
Column: 197
Madam Speaker
Column: 198
3.32 pm
Mr. Iain Duncan Smith (Chingford)
Column: 199
Column: 200
3.42 pm
Mr. Charles Kennedy (Ross, Cromarty and Skye)
Column: 201
Column: 202
Division No. 103 (European Communities (European Court)) [23 Apr 1996]
Column: 203
Column: 204
Mr. George Foulkes (Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley)
Madam Speaker
Madam Speaker
Column: 205
4 pm
The Minister of State, Northern Ireland Office (Mr. Michael Ancram)
Mr. Peter Robinson (Belfast, East)
The First Deputy Chairman of Ways and Means (Sir Geoffrey Lofthouse)
Column: 206
Mr. Robinson
Column: 207
Column: 208
Mr. David Wilshire (Spelthorne)
Mr. Robinson
Dr. Joe Hendron (Belfast, West)
4.15 pm
Mr. Robinson
Column: 209
Mr. Robert McCartney (North Down)
Mr. Robinson
Column: 210
The Secretary of State for Northern Ireland (Sir Patrick Mayhew)
Column: 211
Mr. David Trimble (Upper Bann)
Sir Patrick Mayhew
4.30 pm
Column: 212
Mr. Robert McCartney
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Rev. Ian Paisley (North Antrim)
Sir Patrick Mayhew
The Chairman of Ways and Means (Mr. Michael Morris)
Rev. Ian Paisley
Column: 213
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Mr. Tony Worthington (Clydebank and Milngavie)
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Worthington
Column: 214
Mr. Barry Porter (Wirral, South)
Mr. Worthington
Mr. Eddie McGrady (South Down)
Mr. Worthington
Mr. Robert McCartney
Mr. Worthington
Rev. Ian Paisley
Column: 215
Mr. Worthington
4.45 pm
Mr. Trimble
Dr. Norman A. Godman (Greenock and Port Glasgow)
Mr. Trimble
Column: 216
Mr. McGrady
Column: 217
Mr. Wilshire
Column: 218
Mr. Clive Soley (Hammersmith)
Column: 219
5 pm
Mr. William Ross (East Londonderry)
Column: 220
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. Trimble
Column: 221
Mr. Robinson
Column: 222
Division No. 104 (Northern Ireland (Entry to Negotiations, etc) Bill) [23 Apr 1996]
Column: 224
Mr. Eric Illsley (Barnsley, Central)
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Column: 225
Mr. Illsley
5.30 pm
Mr. Dennis Canavan (Falkirk, West)
The Chairman
Mr. Canavan
Column: 226
Mr. Wilshire
Column: 227
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. Wilshire
Mr. Kevin McNamara (Kingston upon Hull, North)
Mr. Wilshire
Column: 228
5.45 pm
Mr. Trimble
Column: 229
Mr. Wilshire
Mr. Trimble
Column: 230
Column: 231
Mr. Peter Robinson
6 pm
Mr. Trimble
Column: 232
Mr. Robinson
Mr. McGrady
Column: 233
Mr. William Ross
Mr. McGrady
Mr. Ross
Mr. McGrady
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. McGrady
Column: 234
Mr. Robert McCartney
Mr. William Ross
Mr. McCartney
6.15 pm
Mr. Wilshire
Column: 235
Mr. McCartney
Mr. Kevin McNamara (Kingston upon Hull, North)
Mr. McCartney
Mr. Wilshire
Mr. McCartney
Mr. William Ross
Mr. McCartney
Mr. Ross
Column: 236
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Ross
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. Ross
Mr. McNamara
Mr. Ross
Mr. John D. Taylor (Strangford)
Mr. Ross
Column: 237
Mr. Robert McCartney
Mr. Ross
The Chairman
Mr. Ross
Mr. Robert McCartney
Mr. Ross
Miss Kate Hoey (Vauxhall)
Column: 238
Mr. Trimble
Miss Hoey
Mr. McNamara
Mr. Ken Maginnis (Fermanagh and South Tyrone)
Column: 239
6.30 pm
Mr. McNamara
Mr. Ancram
Column: 240
Column: 241
Column: 242
6.45 pm
Mr. William Ross
Column: 243
Mr. Ancram
Mr. McGrady
Mr. Ancram
Mr. McGrady
Mr. Ancram
Column: 244
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Ancram
Mr. McNamara
Mr. William Ross
Mr. Hume
Mr. Ancram
Mr. McNamara
Column: 245
Mr. Ancram
Miss Hoey
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. Hume
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Hume
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Peter Robinson
Miss Hoey
Mr. Robert McCartney
Column: 246
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Robinson
The First Deputy Chairman of Ways and Means (Sir Geoffrey Lofthouse)
Mr. Robinson
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Robert McCartney
Mr. McGrady
The First Deputy Chairman
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Worthington
Mr. Ancram
Rev. Ian Paisley
The First Deputy Chairman
7 pm
Mr. Ancram
Column: 247
Rev. Ian Paisley
The First Deputy Chairman
Mr. Ancram
Column: 248
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. Ancram
Rev. Ian Paisley
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Wilshire
Column: 249
The First Deputy Chairman
Mr. Ancram
Rev. Ian Paisley
The First Deputy Chairman
Mr. McNamara
The First Deputy Chairman
Mr. McNamara
Column: 250
Rev. Ian Paisley
7.15 pm
Mr. Robert McCartney
Mr. Peter Robinson
Column: 251
Mr. Worthington
Mr. Harry Barnes (North-East Derbyshire)
Column: 252
Miss Hoey
Mr. Canavan
Column: 253
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Canavan
7.30 pm
Mr. McNamara
Column: 254
The First Deputy Chairman
Rev. Ian Paisley
The First Deputy Chairman
Mr. Robert McCartney
The First Deputy Chairman
Mr. McCartney
Column: 255
Mr. William Ross
Mr. Barnes
Mr. Ross
Column: 256
Mr. Robert McCartney
Mr. Ancram
Rev. Martin Smyth (Belfast, South)
Mr. Ancram
Mr. William Ross
Mr. Ancram
Column: 257
7.45 pm
Mr. Robert McCartney
Mr. Ancram
Mr. McCartney
Mr. Ancram
Mr. McCartney
Column: 258
Mr. Trimble
The First Deputy Chairman
Mr. Trimble
Column: 259
Mr. Jim Dowd (Lewisham, West)
Mr. McNamara
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Barnes
Mr. Trimble
Column: 260
Mr. Barnes
8 pm
Column: 261
Mr. Wilshire
Mr. Dowd
Column: 262
Column: 263
8.15 pm
Mr. William Ross
Column: 264
Mr. Barnes
Rev. Martin Smyth
Column: 265
Mr. Barnes
Rev. Martin Smyth
Mr. Ancram
Column: 266
Mr. William Ross
Mr. Ancram
Column: 267
Mr. Barnes
Mr. Ancram
8.30 pm
Mr. William Ross
Column: 268
Mr. Ancram
Mr. McGrady
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Ross
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Wilshire
Column: 269
Mr. Barnes
Mr. Wilshire
Mr. Barnes
Rev. Martin Smyth
The Second Deputy Chairman of Ways and Means (Dame Janet Fookes)
Column: 270
Rev. Martin Smyth
The Second Deputy Chairman
Mr. Wilshire
Mr. Archy Kirkwood (Roxburgh and Berwickshire)
The Second Deputy Chairman
Mr. Kirkwood
8.45 pm
Column: 271
Column: 272
Mr. Trimble
Column: 273
Column: 274
Mr. William Ross
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Ross
9 pm
Mr. Trimble
Column: 275
Mr. McNamara
Mr. Maginnis
Mr. McNamara
Mr. Ancram
Mr. McNamara
Column: 276
Mr. Maginnis
Mr. William Ross
Column: 277
9.15 pm
Column: 278
Mr. Ancram
Column: 279
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Ancram
Column: 280
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Ancram
Mr. William Ross
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Maginnis
Column: 281
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Canavan
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Maginnis
9.30 pm
Mr. Ancram
Mr. William Ross
Mr. Ancram
Column: 282
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Maginnis
Column: 283
Mr. Ancram
Rev. Ian Paisley
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Maginnis
Column: 284
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Canavan
Mr. Ancram
Rev. Ian Paisley
Mr. Ancram
Column: 285
9.45 pm
Mr. Kirkwood
Mr. McGrady
The Second Deputy Chairman
Mr. McGrady
Column: 286
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Column: 287
Mr. William Ross
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Mr. Ross
The Second Deputy Chairman
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Mr. Ross
Column: 288
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Ms Marjorie Mowlam (Redcar)
Mr. Wilshire
Mr. Wilshire
Mr. McGrady
Column: 289
Rev. Martin Smyth
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Mr. John D. Taylor
Column: 290
Mr. McGrady
Mr. Taylor
Mr. McGrady
Mr. Trimble
Madam Deputy Speaker
Column: 291
Mr. Trimble
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Column: 292
Mr. Trimble
10.15 pm
Mr. Wilshire
Column: 293
Mr. Peter Robinson
Column: 294
Mr. McGrady
Rev. Ian Paisley
Column: 295
10.30 pm
Mr. Robert McCartney
Rev. Ian Paisley
Column: 296
Mr. Wilshire
Rev. Ian Paisley
Mr. Illsley
Mr. Robert McCartney
Column: 297
Mr. Illsley
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. Illsley
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Illsley
Rev. Ian Paisley
Mr. Illsley
Column: 298
10.45 pm
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Column: 299
Column: 300
Mr. Wilshire
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Column: 301
Column: 302
Mr. Wilshire
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Column: 303
11 pm
Mr. Trimble
Column: 304
Mr. Wilshire
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Mr. Wilshire
Column: 305
Mr. Peter Robinson
The First Deputy Chairman
Mr. Robinson
Mr. McGrady
Column: 306
11.15 pm
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. McGrady
Column: 307
Mr. Robert McCartney
Mr. McGrady
Mr. McCartney
Mr. William Ross
Column: 308
Mr. McCartney
Rev. Ian Paisley
Mr. McCartney
Mr. Worthington
Column: 309
11.30 pm
Mr. McGrady
Mr. Worthington
Column: 310
Rev. Martin Smyth
Mr. Worthington
Rev. Martin Smyth
Mr. Worthington
Rev. Ian Paisley
Mr. Worthington
Column: 311
Mr. William Ross
Column: 312
11.45 pm
Mr. Soley
Column: 313
Mr. Roy Beggs (East Antrim)
Column: 314
Mr. Soley
Rev. Ian Paisley
Mr. Soley
Column: 315
Rev. Ian Paisley
Column: 316
12 midnight
Mr. McNamara
Column: 317
Mr. Ancram
Column: 318
Column: 319
Mr. Trimble
12.15 am
Mr. Ancram
Column: 320
Mr. McNamara
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Soley
Mr. Ancram
Column: 321
Mr. William Ross
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Trimble
Mr. Ancram
Column: 322
Mr. Peter Robinson
Mr. Ancram
Mr. Robinson
Mr. Ancram
Column: 323
12.30 am
Sir Patrick Mayhew
Column: 324
12.33 am
Mr. McNamara
12.34 am
Mr. Wilshire
12.37 am
Dr. Hendron
Column: 325
Column: 326
12.44 am
Mr. Peter Robinson
Column: 327
Column: 328
12.51 am
Ms Mowlam
Column: 329
12.55 am
Rev. Ian Paisley
Ms Mowlam
Rev. Ian Paisley
Column: 330
Column: 331
Column: 332
Madam Deputy Speaker (Dame Janet Fookes)
Rev. Ian Paisley
Column: 333
Column: 334
1.17 am
Mr. David Trimble (Upper Bann)
Column: 335
Column: 336
1.22 am
Mr. McGrady
Column: 337
Column: 338
1.35 am
Mr. Nick Ainger (Pembroke)
Column: 339
1.37 am
Mr. A. J. Beith (Berwick-upon-Tweed)
Column: 340
Column: 341
1.47 am
The Minister of State, Home Office (Miss Ann Widdecombe)
Column: 342
Column: 343
Mr. Beith
Miss Widdecombe
Column: 344
Column: 345
Mr. Beith
Miss Widdecombe
Column: 346