Select Committee on Health Report


Table 4.3.2

GP FUNDHOLDER SURPLUSES USED FOR CAPITAL DEVELOPMENT IN PRIMARY CARE, 1996-97 AND 1997-98

£ million

ENGLAND1996-97 1997-98
Expenditure

39 53
Footnotes:

  1.  Figures for 1996-97 include GPFH Savings spent on, Premises Improvements for GMS, Computers to support GMS and Computers to support GPFH.

  2.  Figures for 1997-98 include GPFH Savings spent on, Premises and Equipment.

  3.  The source of data is FIS(FHS)4 part C for 1996-97 and part D for 1997-98. Figures for 1997-98 are provisional.


Payments to General Practitioners for GMS Practice Premises

  3.  The Statement of Fees and Allowances (SFA) sets out the arrangements by which pay"ments are made to general practitioners for the general medical services they make available to their patients. What follows is a brief description of the arrangements which assist GPs towards the cost of providing practice premises under the Rent and Rates scheme (SFA paragraph 51) and the Improvement Grant scheme (SFA paragraph 56).

Rented Premises

  4.  Under SFA paragraph 51, doctors who rent practice premises for the provision of GMS including those who occupy health centres, are reimbursed the actual rent charged by the landlord or the current market rent (CMR) as assessed by the District Valuer (DV), whichever is the lesser. The CMR is the rent which the DV considers might reasonably be expected to be paid for the premises concerned at the valuation date and is normally reviewed 3-yearly. This assessment is made in the light of knowledge of the area and rents charged for similar properties to that under consideration. In making the assessment, the DV will have regard to the terms of the standard lease in SFA paragraph 51 Schedule 4. While landlords may carry out upward only rent reviews, CMR assessments are based on the general nature of the GP property market in the area. This means that CMR assessments may go down as well as up.

  5.  In the past, some GPs have rented "shell" property from private sector landlords which the doctors have had converted into practice premises for the delivery of GMS. However, there is now an increasing interest by the private sector in providing purpose built premises either for sole occupation by GPs or in joint occupancy arrangements with other primary care providers. The Department is finalising guidance to be issued to Health Authorities on this type of NHS-private sector partnership which will also provide advice to GPs and private sector developers. As with any occupancy agreement, GPs should obtain legal and other professional advice before entering into this type of long term personal commitment, particularly where this will involve multiple occupancy arrangements.

Owner-Occupied Premises

  6.  SFA paragraph 51 also embraces the Cost Rent Scheme which assists GPs who borrow money to build new or carry out substantial work on existing practice premises. Instead of a CMR, cost rent reimbursement provides payments towards the cost of servicing the loan. While the scheme is usually accessed by owner occupier GPs, the scheme is also available to GPs who rent premises. There are three categories of project that qualify for Cost Rent and in each case the premises may be main or branch surgeries. The categories are:

    (i)  Newly erected purposes-built premises

    (ii)  Premises acquired for substantial alteration

    (iii)  Existing premises which are to be substantially altered.

    "Substantial alteration" must involve structural work either by extending the premises or by internal modification of the building.

  7.  The cost rent a doctor receives is linked to the cost of the capital borrowed. Cost rent reimbursement levels will be "fixed" or "variable" normally reflective of the bank interest rates attached to the loan. These "prescribed percentages" are set using Bank of England rates plus a margin for administrative costs. In this way, cost rent payments assist GPs in their borrowing costs and are not varied to reflect any changes in the value of the property.

Calculation of Cost Rent

  8.  There are several complex formulae to take account of varying circumstances which include new premises to be owned by the practice, new premises rented from a third party, premises bought for substantial modification, substantial modification of existing premises owned by the practice and so on. They all attempt to assess reasonable land and building cost in terms of a minimum investment for GPs and it is assumed that GPs will borrow the capital required to undertake the project. To this land and building cost is applied the prescribed percentage—a figure set by the Department based on prevailing interest rates. The resulting amount, or one based on the cost rent Schedule cost limits whichever is the less, produces the annual cost rent payable to the GP. Having raised the capital and built the surgery, the land and building belong to the practice with GPs responsible for ongoing repair and maintenance and disposal of their interest in the property.

The Cost Rent Schedule

  9.  The Schedule sets maxima on the size of premises and associated building costs used to calculate the level of reimbursement available under the scheme. To the building costs are added professional fees, planning consent charges, VAT actually incurred etc. Cost limits control the amount taken into account within the cost rent calculation for building costs. To the national cost limits set by the Department, HAs apply Building Cost Location Factors published in SFA 51 Schedule 3 to reflect local building costs. GPs who contain their cost rent commitments within the maxima of the scheduled cost limits effectively receive an interest-free loan or, at least, a subsidised interest rate on the capital actually or notionally raised for the project.

Notional Rent

  10.  GPs in receipt of Cost Rent reimbursement, may opt at any time to receive a notional rent based on Current Market Rent for the property, again assessed by the District Valuer. This provides GPs with a payment set at a level reflective of a rent that might be charged for similar property in the area. Payments do not include an element for VAT which might be levied in normal landlord-tenant rents. GPs in receipt of cost rent are unable to resume those payments when they exercise their option to receive notional rent payments. Notional rent payments are also normally reviewed on a 3-yearly basis to reflect the current market rent for similar GP property in the area. The scheme also allows for payments to be reviewed when GPs carry out any additional capital work on their premises.

Improvement Grant Scheme

  11.  The Improvement Grant Scheme provides a contribution towards the capital cost of improvements to practice premises. In the main, grants will be awarded for existing practice premises but the scheme allows premises not previously used for GMS to be considered. HAs have discretion to approve grants of between 33 per cent and 66 per cent (up to 90 per cent in the London Implementation Zone) of the cost of improvements in accordance with the provisions of the SFA. Examples of projects which might be carried out under the scheme include the provision of additional rooms, (eg a suitable room for minor surgery or practice manager) enlargement of existing rooms, additional or improved washing toilet facilities, improved access for the disabled, improved lighting, heating and ventilation, provision of car parking, double glazing and security systems.

Expenditure

  12.  Tables 4.3.3 and 4.3.4 show non-cash limited spend and cash-limited spend on GMS Premises for 1995-96 to 1997-98.


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries

© Parliamentary copyright 1998
Prepared 2 November 1998