Previous Section Index Home Page


Plastic Baton Rounds (Northern Ireland)

Mr. Livingstone: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence for what reasons plastic baton rounds replaced rubber bullets for use by the armed forces in Northern Ireland. [63931]

16 Dec 1998 : Column: 524

Mr. Spellar: Plastic baton rounds provide a more effective means of combating physical violence than the rubber bullets they replaced. The increased accuracy of plastic baton rounds also reduces the risk of accidental injury.

EU Defence Expenditure

Mr. William Ross: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how much has been spent by each nation in the EU in each of the last 10 years in pounds sterling on defence (a) in total and (b) per head of the population. [64195]

Mr. Spellar: The information requested for calendar years 1987 to 1997 is shown for NATO members of the European Union. Comparisons of defence spending between nations are conventionally given in US Dollars rather than pounds sterling. Figures for calendar years 1987 to 1995 are those which have been published in successive versions of the Statement on the Defence Estimates (SDE). Figures for 1996 are based on information drawn from NATO sources and those for 1997 are as published in the MOD Performance Report 1997-98 (Cm4170).

Where possible the figures are published against a common definition of defence spending so that true comparisons can be made. Some anomalies and inconsistencies will, however, remain. Particular care is needed in making year on year comparisons of the figures for the UK where there have been changes in the definition of defence spending in recent years and major transfers of responsibility to and from other Government Departments.

16 Dec 1998 : Column: 523

Defence expenditure
(US$ million)

19871988198919901991199219931994199519961997
Belgium4,1424,2153,9384,7234,7704,0783,7623,9484,5724,2403,769
Denmark2,1272,3362,1622,6102,6142,7992,7022,7413,1253,0862,816
France34,52935,90935,08542,79442,39945,65442,59344,38147,73546,40241,545
Germany34,23335,36933,63842,79339,89342,39938,62935,93341,90638,99033,416
Greece2,9723,4653,2083,7763,9074,2484,0764,3475,0595,5825,532
Italy16,80619,14819,75424,75223,58324,56721,18521,19020,04123,45821,837
Luxembourg768180100106121116124141141129
Netherlands6,5026,7446,4027,4297,2427,8717,0397,0908,1817,8506,888
Portugal1,1351,2611,3191,7112,0062,4152,2412,2812,8192,6012,559
Spain5,7387,3197,7009,5569,0339,6207,2117,6178,4648,6167,508
UK30,85934,91333,43638,43342,71643,12235,25734,06834,08634,52635,620

16 Dec 1998 : Column: 523

Defence expenditure per capita
(US $)

19871988198919901991199219931994199519961997
Belgium420427398474476406374390455417370
Denmark416455422508508542522528600589533
France623646628759748796738764820794708
Germany561578550550499530481438509475406
Greece298347320375388408392417481531526
Italy294334344430409424365371349409379
Luxembourg206219211262275312296311365338305
Netherlands447460434497482519461460527504442
Portugal111123128165203229226231285262257
Spain149188196243231246183194216219191
UK544614581670742750608585586587604

16 Dec 1998 : Column: 523

16 Dec 1998 : Column: 525

My Department does not regularly collect details of defence spending for EU members who are not members of NATO. Figures for these countries are shown in The Military Balance which is published by the International Institute for Strategic Studies. The figures given in this publication for the last two years are shown below:

Defence expenditure
(US$ millions)

19961997
Austria2,0981,786
Finland2,2551,956
Ireland757767
Sweden6,5015,481

Defence expenditure per capita
(US $)

19961997
Austria262222
Finland440381
Ireland209210
Sweden737619

Chile

Mr. Wilkinson: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many aircraft of the Royal Air Force participated at the biennial Air Show at Santiago, Chile in March (a) 1990, (b) 1992, (c) 1994, (d) 1996 and (e) 1998. [64016]

Mr. George Robertson [holding answer 15 December 1998]: The figures are as follows:

YearNumber of aircraft Details
19903Harrier GR5 x 2, VC10K
19928Harrier GR5/7 x 2; Tornado GR1 x 2; C130; Nimrod; Tristar; VC10K
19945Harrier GR7 x 2; C130; VC10K; Nimrod
19961C130
19985Tornado F3 x 2; Nimrod; VC10K; C130

Army Training and Recruitment Agency

Laura Moffatt: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what are the key targets for 1998-99 for the Chief Executive of the Army Training and Recruitment Agency. [64627]

Mr. Doug Henderson: The Chief Executive of the Army Training and Recruiting Agency has been set the following Key Target for 1998-1999.





16 Dec 1998 : Column: 526


    5. To meet the Adjutant General's requirement for soldiers' professional development training.


    6. To achieve efficiency savings of 6% (34.7M).

Army Personnel Centre

Laura Moffatt: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what are the key targets for 1998-99 for the Chief Executive of the Army Personnel Centre. [64625]

Mr. Doug Henderson: The Chief Executive of the Army Personnel Centre has been set the following Key Targets for 1998-1999:








Defence Military Assistance Fund

Mr. Menzies Campbell: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what is the breakdown of expenditure under the Defence Military Assistance Fund in each of the last three years. [63864]

Mr. George Robertson: The Defence Military Assistance Fund is a cash fund, which is available to subsidise the cost of overseas military assistance in support of the Defence Diplomacy and Support to Wider British Interests Missions. The latter mission includes support to defence sales. Assistance may include the provision of training (either in country or in the UK), advice (by either military or civilian personnel), Loan Service Personnel and Short Term Training Teams.

The table breaks down expenditure, by country, under the Defence Military Assistance Fund for each of the last three years. This breakdown covers centrally administered programmes only, and does not include military assistance activities funded by Top Level Budget Holders, since these costs cannot be identified separately. Nor does it cover costs borne by other Government Departments, which are a matter for the Departments concerned.

1997-98--DMAF Expenditure
£

CountryMOD Subsidy
Albania1,000
Austria5,700
Bahrain139,600
Baltic States631,900
Belarus18,200
Belize271,500
Brazil262,200
Brunei5,500
Bulgaria94,600
Chile581,600
Czech Republic193,300
Egypt135,400
Ethiopia38,700
Finland1,600
Georgia50,300
Germany100,000
Greece58,300
Hungary88,500
India253,200
Indonesia62,400
Ireland5,000
Jamaica27,700
Jordan146,400
Kenya145,100
South Korea279,700
Kuwait71,200
Macedonia56,200
Malaysia516,500
Moldova29,300
Morocco56,000
Nepal24,900
New Zealand37,700
Oman1,402,200
Pakistan63,500
Philippines68,000
Poland83,700
Portugal49,400
Qatar169,900
Romania276,400
Russia1,255,000
Saudi Arabia120,900
Singapore176,500
Slovakia39,100
Slovenia108,400
South Africa104,800
Spain23,600
Thailand39,900
Turkey155,600
UAE273,600
Ukraine407,300
Uruguay15,600
USA15,000
Yemen25,700
Zimbabwe36,300

16 Dec 1998 : Column: 527

1996-97--DMAF Expenditure
£

CountryMOD Subsidy
Albania30,900
Bahrain156,200
Baltic States572,500
Barbados196,000
Belarus52,600
Belize502,100
Brazil4,560
Bulgaria66,900
Chile920,110
Czech Republic148,800
Egypt67,780
Finland45,120
Georgia12,900
Greece84,710
Hungary43,000
India43,680
Indonesia1,675,280
Ireland24,240
Jamaica35,270
Jordan156,570
Kenya138,225
South Korea53,340
Kuwait2,570
Macedonia31,200
Malaysia164,390
Moldova30,910
Morocco33,590
Nepal102,800
Oman1,594,860
Pakistan97,490
Philippines20,000
Poland47,700
Portugal40,110
Romania89,000
Russia1,365,000
Saudi Arabia9,210
Slovakia33,500
Slovenia29,300
South Africa80,740
Spain32,760
Thailand57,760
Turkey108,740
UAE105,920
Ukraine251,400
Zimbabwe40,610

16 Dec 1998 : Column: 528

1995-96--DMAF Expenditure
£

CountryMOD Subsidy
Albania18,500
Bahrain19,260
Baltic States585,100
Barbados761,260
Belize834,930
Bulgaria27,800
Chile316,630
Czech Republic100,200
Dominica15,570
Egypt73,660
Greece39,900
Grenada16,490
Hungary18,500
Indonesia691,880
Jamaica12,285
Jordan60,390
Kenya95,590
Macedonia9,300
Malaysia188,780
Morocco26,170
Nepal91,040
New Zealand19,835
Oman749,570
Poland123,500
Portugal40,000
Romania27,800
Russia630,000
Slovakia37,100
Slovenia9,300
Spain9,385
St. Kitts and Nevis15,570
St. Vincent3,970
Thailand95,610
Turkey58,825
UAE54,990
Ukraine142,600

16 Dec 1998 : Column: 529


Next Section Index Home Page