Select Committee on Northern Ireland Affairs Minutes of Evidence



ANNEX 2

ADMISSION OF CHILDREN TO SPEECH AND LANGUAGE UNITS

CRITERIA AGREED BY:

    —  Educational Psychologists.

    —  HSS Trust Senior Clinical Medical Officers.

    —  HSS Trust Speech and Language Therapy Managers.

SPEECH AND LANGUAGE UNITS—REFERRAL CRITERIA

INTRODUCTION

  Children with severe speech and language problems whose intellectual ability is within the average range (as measured by a non-verbal intelligence scale) are likely to need more support than is ordinarily available to children in mainstream schools. They may require a structured language learning environment with highly specialized teaching and speech and language therapy support until such time as they become confident and competent in their understanding and use of language.

  A diagnosis of developmental speech and language disorder refers to those children who are not acquiring language skills in accordance with an age-appropriate development pattern. This will include children with difficulties in comprehension and production of language at all levels.

CRITERIA FOR PLACEMENT IN SPEECH AND LANGUAGE UNITS

  In framing these criteria, it is recognised that substantial numbers of young children will have difficulty with the development of speech and language skills which are of concern to their parents and, possibly, to nursery school teachers, speech and language therapists, class teachers etc. Because of the limited number of places available, it is suggested that Speech and Language Unit provision should be targeted at children who have a language disorder or a language delay of such severity that it is clearly predicted that it will prevent him/her having full and meaningful access to the NI Curriculum and to the social and cultural life of a mainstream school.

  We would propose that consideration of children for placement in a Speech and Language Unit should take place in two stages.

Stage 1

    (a)  The child's measured non-verbal IQ must be 85 or above.

    (b)  There must be a statistically significant discrepancy (P= 0.05) between the verbal IQ and the Performance IQ.

(N.B. FOR THOSE CHILDREN WHOSE ARTICULATION IS SO POOR THAT ADMINISTRATION OF A VERBAL SCALE IS NOT POSSIBLE,

A SIGNIFICANT DISCREPANCY EXISTS BY DEFAULT).

Stage 2

  If the child satisfies the criteria at Stage 1, Stage 2 criteria should be applied.

    (a)  The child will not be considered his/her standard score on a Language test* is above -1 Standard Deviation for his/her age group. Alternatively, a child will not be considered if his/her score on a suitable language test* is less than one year below his/her chronological age.

      * Scores obtained in the course of an assessment by an educational psychologist or a speech and language therapist will be acceptable providing that they were obtained within a period of three months prior to the statutory assessment.

    (b)  The child will be considered if it is predicted that his/her speech and language difficulties will prevent meaningful communication with teachers to such a degree that he/she will not be able to understand, or to demonstrate understanding of key educational concepts, word recognition, comprehension of reading etc.

    (c)  The child will be considered if it is predicted that his/her speech and language difficulties will impair his/her ability to:

      —  communicate socially with adults and peers; and/or

      —  participate meaningfully in, or example, talking and listening activities; and/or

      —  participate fully and meaningfully in the wider aspects of class and school life.

  It is suggested that, to be referred for placement in a Speech and Language Unit, a child must meet all criteria at Stage 1 and two of the three criteria at Stage 2.

  Placement in a Speech and Language Unit is not generally appropriate when a child's difficulties are primarily due to:

    —  primary sensori-neural hearing impairment;

    —  severe physical disability;

    —  emotional difficulties;

    —  lack of familiarity with English as a first language.

28 May 1998


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries

© Parliamentary copyright 1999
Prepared 19 April 1999