Select Committee on Defence Minutes of Evidence


Memorandum submitted by the Ministry of Defence (22 June 2000)

PREFACE

  A key outcome of the Strategic Defence Review was a commitment to formulate an Armed Forces Overarching Personnel Strategy (AFOPS) as part of the "Policy for People" which was introduced to give more emphasis to personnel issues. The need for such a robust and responsive personnel strategy was reinforced by the upsurge in operational activity over the last year. The Strategy is a key element in showing our continuing commitment to our personnel and their families and reinforces the message that we place people at the centre of our plans. It will be a vital tool in sustaining operational capability over the longer term. Following its launch by the Secretary of State for Defence, in his speech opening the Defence Debate of 22 February 2000, the Strategy's Main Document and its supporting Action Plan were implemented formally across the Services on 1 April 2000.

  The AFOPS will provide the strategic framework within which we will develop Service personnel policies for the future. The Strategy is not designed to duplicate single Service personnel strategies, but to promote operational effectiveness. It does so by providing a clear sense of direction, encapsulating top management's vision of the future for Service personnel. The Strategy sets out the overall direction the Department wishes to pursue in achieving its objectives by good management and care of its people, whilst maintaining the diversity, identity and ethos of the single Services. At the highest level it provides the context and sets out the principles within which Departmental and single-Service personnel policies can be developed. It provides the vehicle through which Service personnel issues are linked to the wider Departmental planning process. The Deputy Chief of the Defence Staff (Personnel) post provides the central focus for taking the Strategy forward.

  The AFOPS is based around the philosophy that we need to care for our people from before the point of recruitment until beyond retirement B the "Cradle to Grave and beyond "philosophy. The Strategy's visions and aims are set out in the Armed Forces Personnel Policy Statement and are reflected in the vision for Service men and women thus:

    "To generate and maintain modern, joint, battle winning forces, by placing Service personnel and their families at the centre of our plans, investing in them and giving them confidence in their future."

  The Strategy identifies 28 "headline" areas of personnel policy, ranging from "recruitment" and "individual training', to "mobility" to "families' and "veterans' . For each area there is a Personnel Strategy Guideline which sets out the high-level policy, guiding principles and goals. The Personnel Strategy Guidelines have been built around five key themes:

    —  Cultivate: "prepare the ground" for obtaining personnel;

    —  Obtain: attract, acquire and train high quality, motivated people;

    —  Retain: provide personnel with a rewarding career which stimulates and develops them and provides the foundation of a second career on leaving the Services;

    —  Sustain: provide an environment in which Service men and women and their families will be willing to maintain their commitment;

    —  Remember: provide ex-Service personnel and their dependants with help and support, particularly with resettlement back into civilian life.

  Linked to the AFOPS are the three single-Service personnel strategies. These cascade the top level statement in a single-Service context.

PART A—THE ARMED FORCES AS PART OF SOCIETY

1.  In what specific areas do the core values and standards of the Armed Forces need to differ from those in wider society? In what ways have these changed in the last 10 years and what changes are envisaged in the next 10 years?

  1.1  As part of the rapid social change over the last ten years in both the United Kingdom and in Europe, the rights of the individual have increasingly been accorded greater importance. This has been reflected in new and changing European and national employment and social legislation. These changes have important implications for Service personnel policies.

  1.2  The Armed Forces occupy a unique position in society. Theirs is the only profession whose role is to exercise lethal force on behalf of the nation and which in turn carries an unlimited liability—that they may, in extreme circumstances, be required to die on behalf of others. Military discipline possesses its unique character precisely for that reason. The high levels of operational effectiveness which British forces so frequently demonstrate must be preserved. Personnel policies exist to maintain this operational capability and that is their principal determinant. This is why the Services' unique characteristics require core values and standards that, in some areas, are different from those that other employers might reasonably expect. Both the Army and the RAF have recently issued "Standards and Values' pamphlets to all personnel, setting out the standards and values they expect from their personnel.

  1.3  The Armed Forces are, nevertheless, an integral part of the fabric of British society. That same society provides the Services with their legitimacy, personnel, money and support. Indeed, some have asked whether the private conduct of personnel should be of any concern to Service authorities if it does not affect a person's ability to do their job. There is a risk that if what the Services expect becomes entirely divorced from the expectations of society, they will lose the legitimacy and support that is vital to their existence. The Department must therefore strike a balance between the requirements of the Armed Forces, derived from the operational demands placed upon them, and the rights and freedoms to which Service personnel are entitled as citizens.

  1.4  This is a difficult issue with powerful arguments on both sides. On the one hand, the attitudes of society to personal conduct are undoubtedly changing. In general, society has become more liberal in recent years and standards of personal behaviour, considered to be now acceptable in society at large, cannot easily be transposed into a military environment. For example, there is ample evidence to suggest that younger people are less deferential and find it difficult to adapt to a hierarchical, command-based organisation. Equally, conduct that openly discriminates, abuses position, trust or rank is more damaging to the Services, because these values strike at the very heart of the military ethos. Where lives can depend on personal trust, mutual support and obedience, as they do in the unique working circumstances of the Services, misconduct can be extremely corrosive to team cohesion and, ultimately, operational effectiveness. There must therefore be rules to discourage any conduct that would imperil such trust and effectiveness. The Services would need to be absolutely sure of the consequences before making any change to the principle that in some cases the Services require standards of behaviour that are more demanding than those required by society at large. Finding the balance between the perceived military need and what can reasonably be expected in a modern society is therefore an immense challenge.

  1.5  The Services have also to consider the extent to which the Armed Forces have a requirement to be fully or partially exempt from social and employment legislation in order to maintain their combat effectiveness, and whether personnel policies followed in the Services should differ markedly from those that apply more generally in society because of the unique circumstances of the Armed Forces. A recent example of the challenges faced in developing values and standards based personnel policies for the Armed Forces, in both the present and a changing society, linked to the requirements of the Services to sustain their cohesion and operational effectiveness, is the issue of homosexuality. The Code of Social Conduct, introduced earlier this year, sets out clearly the standards expected of Armed Forces personnel in terms of personal relationships (see also Questions 7 and 9 below). The Services have also taken steps to recognise the forthcoming incorporation into domestic legislation of the Articles of the European Convention on Human Rights.

  1.6  In sum, the Armed Forces must represent the society they serve but the overriding need for them to be operationally effective means that they may require values and standards which differ markedly in some respects from those of the rest of society. Other armed forces are facing similar issues. Much depends on the outcome of an evolving debate involving the Services, Service personnel, experts, interest groups and the general public. The Department's aim is for that debate to be informed, knowledgeable and for all concerned to be aware of the special and often particularly demanding requirements of Service life and operational needs.

2.  How can society, and in particular the young people whom the Armed Services need to attract as recruits, be persuaded that the differences which remain between the Services and wider society are necessary and contribute to the Services' ability to fulfil their role?

  2.1  The Armed Forces must reflect the society from which they are drawn, but there must also be an acknowledgement, by society and the Services themselves, of the need to be different in some areas in order to preserve operational effectiveness. Life in the Armed Forces is plainly not the same as civilian life and the functions and roles of the Services clearly make complete compatibility impossible. In the opinion of Services' recruiting staffs who, by virtue of their activity, are in daily contact with the British public, the principal differences voiced by the general public between Service and civilian life are:

    —  a tougher disciplined environment;

    —  a longer commitment to a career.

  2.2  There have been a number of recurrent recruiting challenges with which all three Services have had to contend since the early 1990s. The Services are continually reviewing personnel policies to attempt to surmount these, and to develop complementary strategies to meet the challenges posed by a more liberalised society. Examples of challenges faced by the Services are:

    —  Force reductions and redundancy measures in the early/mid 1990s left the public with the impression that the Armed Forces were no longer recruiting.

    —  The recruiting market has become increasingly competitive (the "war for talent"), and more young people are now opting for further education.

    —  The demographic trough: There is a third fewer 17-18 year-olds today from whom the Services can recruit than there was 19 years ago. The numbers aged 16-24 years have also fallen about a sixth in the same time frame and are still falling.

    —  Unemployment levels are currently low, and various programmes/initiatives such as "New Deal" are also effectively reducing unemployment amongst the Armed Forces target age group.

    —  There has been an appreciable decrease in the fitness levels of potential young recruits, thus reducing the number of those suitable.

    —  There has also been a well documented rise of drug abuse amongst 16-24 year-olds. This has naturally led to an increase in criminal convictions, thereby reducing the potential recruiting pool even further. The Armed Forces demand of their personnel in this age group that they live and work in a drug-free environment.

    —  With the last serviceman to be enlisted for compulsory military service discharged from the British Armed Forces in 1963, most people of target recruitment age have been brought up at a time when there has been no family connection with (and hence no knowledge or understanding of) Service life. Such knowledge is now often gleaned from the media and entertainment, both of which find it easy and profitable to emphasise and highlight differences between civil and Service life styles.

    —  In contemporary society, there is an increasing trend for young people to live at home with their parents (80% of 15-19 year-olds in 1994). This prolonged stay in the "parental nest" increases, in some instances, the influence of the parents on the young in their choice of career.

    —  Young people today are more likely, than before, to be concerned with social and environmental issues and less concerned with the perceived traditional Armed Forces "values' of Queen and Country.

  2.3  Despite the recruiting challenges, Armed Forces recruiting—particularly over the past two years—has been buoyant;

    —  In 1998-99 the Army achieved its best recruiting figures for eight years and the intake of women across the Services was the highest for eight years.

    —  In 1999-2000 the Armed Forces succeeded in enlisting almost 25,000 young, high calibre, motivated people, representing 96% of the recruitment target.

  2.4  This indicates that these differences are not insurmountable, and that the challenges are being successfully addressed. The challenge, variety and excitement of Service life, security of employment and the benefits package (including medical support) are valuable incentives. The comprehensive training and education packages further demonstrate the Armed Forces' commitment to supporting individuals who, unlike society in general, are required to place themselves in danger. They also show a commitment to the concept of life long training and development—the equal of the very best practice in civil life.

  2.5  Applicants for the Armed Forces are unequivocally advised at the outset that they will be entering a disciplined Service which may, at times, take priority over personal needs and require them to serve in any part of the world at any time of day or night, seven days a week. The Services require individuals who are prepared to accept danger and work often in stressful and poor conditions. This requires a high degree of self-discipline and frequently means laying aside certain individual rights and privileges when necessary for the good of the country and the success of the team. A disciplined, supportive organisation is needed to ensure that, in times of crisis/danger, individuals respond as members of a cohesive, responsive and professionally focused team.

  2.6  Armed Forces training is designed to develop in the individual recruit a sense of belonging. This training can sometimes be seen as going to stressful extremes by critical observers, but is essential if units, whether at sea, on the ground or in the air, are to be operationally effective in the face of hostile enemy action. The success of this training will ultimately serve to save the lives of the recruits and their comrades; a point amply demonstrated by the successes and international professional reputation of UK Armed Forces on operations.

3.  The Minister said in reply to a recent PQ that consolidation of the three Service Discipline Acts would be subsumed into the development of a tri-Service Act (HC Deb. 15 May 2000, c 15w). What are the key issues which need to be considered in drafting such legislation? What is the timescale?

  3.1  The existing legislation provides that, where members of more than one Service work together, the lead Service will exercise the prime responsibility for discipline over personnel of all Services. However, difficulties can arise in the increasing number of fully joint units and organisations where there is no lead Service. In such circumstances, the solution has been for each Service represented within such a joint organisation to appoint one of its officers to be responsible for discipline over its own personnel. This is unsatisfactory, in that it effectively splits the responsibility for administering discipline from that for command.

  3.2  The key issue in developing a tri-Service Act will therefore be to establish a structure which properly aligns command and responsibility for discipline in all circumstances. In doing so, it will be necessary to recognise that for the foreseeable future most members of the Armed Forces will continue to work in a single Service environment and to strike an appropriate balance between harmonising the Services' procedures and the retention of any essential distinctive features.

  3.3  Thinking on this is still at a fairly early stage. Substantive work on developing the new legislative structure will get underway after the passage of the quinquennial Armed Forces Bill, in 2001. As was stated in the Strategic Defence Review, this will "be a substantial and complex undertaking which will take some years to complete" . We would hope to find the Parliamentary time for a Bill introducing the tri-Service legislation as soon as possible after the necessary work has been completed.

4.  In what respects does ensuring compliance with the European Convention on Human Rights continue to present problems in drafting Service Discipline legislation? Will some of these issues be dealt with in the quinquennial Armed Forces Bill?

  4.1  The Armed Forces Discipline Act 2000 addressed the key areas where there have been concerns that aspects of the Service discipline Acts may not be compatible with the European Convention on Human Rights. We are reviewing the Service legislation to establish whether there are any outstanding Convention points. If there are, the quinquennial Armed Forces Bill would appear to be a natural vehicle for any amendments to the Service discipline Acts that may be necessary.

  4.2  Clearly, in developing any new legislative proposals for the armed forces, it will be the intention that they should be compatible with the Convention. Although the Armed Forces Act 1996 and the Armed Forces Discipline Act 2000 have both made important changes to the Services' procedures, to bring them into line with the Convention, these have not been so fundamental as to alter the nature of the discipline system. Any further changes that may be required to reflect the Convention are similarly unlikely to be unduly significant in their impact on the Services, because the approach will always be to find solutions that reconcile the requirements of both the Convention and operational effectiveness.

5.  What training is given at the various levels on command and staff courses on human rights issues and the relationship between the Armed Forces and wider society?

  5.1  The teaching of human rights and the Armed Forces in wider society occurs in a combination of specific teaching stages or as generic themes which recur in other related teaching activities. Both subjects are underpinning themes in a wide range of teaching activities, and not just discrete subject areas in their own right. Both aspects of training also underpin numerous exercises students undertake, culminating in the two week Theatre War Game for the Higher Command and Staff Course and the Advanced Command and Staff Course. Humanitarian issues, the application of international law, generation of rules of engagement and civil/military relations form an integral part of these exercises.

6.  Leadership skills are a key factor not only in operational effectiveness but also in retaining personnel and ensuring their job satisfaction. How much officer training is devoted to leadership skills and within that how much is devoted to practical leadership arid personnel management issues? What assessment has been made of the effects of good and bad leadership skills? Where weaknesses are detected, what is done to address them?

  6.1  Naval Service.All young officers joining Britannia Royal Naval College experience three one week leadership training modules; each building on the previous one. During these periods young officers spend approximately 70% of the time putting the skills into practice in an increasingly demanding practical environment. They also undertake a one week module of personnel management training to enable them to manage the career and pastoral care of up to 24 Junior Ratings, which is a requirement of all officers in their first job on the trained strength: this includes a one day counselling course. Augmenting this training are two weeks of communications skills in which research, analysis, briefing and presentation abilities are developed and tested.

  6.2  Beyond this a large proportion of Officer Cadets undertake tasks in which their leadership and management skills are tested. In particular, additional responsibility is given to most of the cadets over a further period of pre-specialisation training. Approximately 75 per cent of all young officers in their third term of training will undertake such secondary responsibilities under varying degrees of supervision.

  6.3  Young officers also undertake practical boatwork. As small boat coxswains in charge of small teams in a challenging water-borne environment their practical leadership abilities are honed and tested. Similarly, they partake in team sports with positions of management and administration being undertaken, providing another vehicle for leadership and assessment.

  6.4  A considerable period of time for debriefing is allotted to all formal leadership training, and all young officers are routinely debriefed in detail on their performance across all aspects of their training. They are also encouraged to debrief each other. There is additional training for those who show weaknesses in any areas. There is a five week remedial package, predominantly leadership orientated.

  6.5  After the leadership training given to young officers during their initial Naval General Training, various aspects of leadership and management are addressed during subsequent professional training courses and all officers attend the Royal Naval School of Leadership and Management for further training in the role of Divisional Officer.

  6.6  Army. In the Army, formal leadership training is delivered to all officer cadets on the year-long commissioning course at Royal Military Academy Sandhurst (RMAS). Leadership training is the main effort at RMAS and this is reflected in the substantial amount of time devoted to the subject. After graduating from RMAS, every officer attends a "special to arm" young officers' course, which will prepare him for the practical aspects of commanding in his particular Arm or Service. Leadership training is, however, an integral part of them all. The next formal training in leadership for all officers on regular commissions takes place on the Junior Command and Staff Course. The emphasis here is Human Resources Management (HRM). Practical leadership training is subsequently delivered to officers by their Arm or Service on sub unit commanders' courses.

  6.7  A selected number of officers will receive staff training at the Royal Military College of Science (RMCS) and the Joint Services Command and Staff College. HRM training takes place at RMCS. This varies according to the postgraduate course studied: ranging up to five weeks HRM training on the Master of Defence Administration course. Further leadership training takes place at the Staff College. Officers selected to command units attend a two-week briefing on the Commanding Officers' Designate Course.

  6.8  RAF. A significant amount of the RAF Initial Officer Training (IOT) syllabus concentrates on leadership. This is further developed during the subsequent specialist training, with particular emphasis on its application as an officers' core competency but also in the given specialist environment. The Junior Officer Command Course is the next residential stage of an officer's staff training. It is aimed at developing junior officers' effectiveness for early executive appointments and revisits earlier leadership training, developing its theory using students' practical experience. A similar approach is also taken for Squadron Leaders at the Intermediate Command Staff Course to prepare officers for command and staff appointments.

  6.9  A major review of leadership training within IOT was undertaken in 1998 with the primary aim of modernising the course. This review included seeking views from a range of commanders and took the opportunity to examine practices in industry and developments in the academic world. As a result of the Study, significant changes were made to leadership training, including: the introduction of a modernised leadership theory package to encompass a greater range of leadership styles; placing greater emphasis on cerebral leadership exercises; changes to Command and Staff training; the need to develop the potential of the individual to improve the effectiveness of the team; greater practical experience in the management of people.

  6.10  All three Services also provide leadership and management training for Non-Commissioned Officers. To use the RAF as an example, the Junior Management Leadership course prepares those selected for promotion to corporal. This is recognised as a major milestone for non-commissioned personnel and a step change in their exposure to the challenges of leadership. Subsequent promotion to sergeant and flight sergeant have corresponding management and leadership courses.

7.  Some steps have been taken towards making Service life less different from civilian working life, in areas such as working hours, annual leave entitlement and parental leave. What assessment has been made of whether further steps towards "normalising" Service life are desirable or feasible?

  7.1  Working hours, parental leave and regularised annual leave entitlements have all been introduced into the Services as a result of emergent employment legislation. Where possible, consistent with the over-riding need to maintain operational effectiveness, the Services try to reflect and endorse the full agenda of employment and social legislation that is aimed at the general working population. Where differences between Service and civilian life need to be recognised this is registered with the Government Department raising the legislation.

  7.2  Whenever draft legislation is circulated by other Government Departments (OGDs) for consultation or comment, the Armed Forces collectively scrutinise the proposals to gauge the effect on the Services. This is handled by an MoD body—the Standing Committee on the Impact of Legislation on the Armed Forces (SCILAF). The SCILAF meets regularly to ensure that any proposed legislation with a Service interest is considered and acted upon within a reasonable period, pertinent to the consultative time allowed for the legislative subject. All key Service personnel interests in the Department are represented, and discussions and actions emanating from the SCILAF subsequently inform a much wider Departmental constituency. The aim in SCILAF is to take a strategic approach to emerging legislation, with more detailed debate taking place between interested parties using normal Departmental machinery.

  7.3  Either collectively or individually, members of the SCILAF seek to protect Departmental and the Services' interests against legislation which may have a detrimental effect on the operational effectiveness of the Services. The Department aims, where possible, to apply emerging legislation fully to the Services whenever it is sensible to do so, whilst seeking derogations or exemptions where risks to operational effectiveness are clear and demonstrable. This approach maintains the necessary balance required between individual rights and the needs of the Armed Forces, and assists the Services to draw nearer to a more "normal" civilian working life culture where this is possible.

  7.4  Retention of trained Service personnel is a major factor moving the Armed Forces towards "normalising" Service life where practicable. Emergent European and domestic employment and social legislation is characterised by a "Family Friendly" agenda. For Service personnel, however, operational commitments cause separation between families. A wide range of measures has been implemented to improve retention including seeking to reduce the amount of separation suffered by individuals by spreading the burden of detachments more equitably. Improved living conditions for Service personnel detached are being progressed. Examples in this area are: the upgrade programme for Service Families Accommodation, the modernisation of Junior Ranks/Rates Single Living Accommodation, and a move away from communal mess decks in next generation frigates.

  7.5  Key components of the recently introduced Armed Forces Overarching Personnel Strategy (AFOPS) are also attempting to mirror Service life with civilian life where possible. Better representation of women and ethnic minorities throughout the Services will reflect much more closely the make up of society. The implementation of the Learning Forces initiative will enable the Armed Forces to benefit from the wider Government priority of education and lifelong learning, through increased funds for the personal development of Service personnel at all levels from recruits upwards.

  7.6  Finally, the new Armed Forces Code of Social Conduct is less prescriptive of the personal behaviour of Service personnel than in the past. It respects the rights and the private life of an individual, whilst providing an objective measure for commanding officers to gauge whether the conduct of Service personnel is appropriate or has impacted on the efficiency or operational effectiveness of the Armed Forces. It will not restrict personal standards of behaviour beyond those already required in the special circumstances of the Services.

8.  What assessment has been made of the importance of maintaining the visible presence of the Armed Forces in national life? To what extent have such developments as the closure of recruiting offices, the reduction in the Army's "national footprint" and the draw down of the TA reduced this visibility? What measures are being taken to increase the military presence in society?

  8.1  The then Secretary of State for Defence announced a more open approach to wearing uniform in public in October 1998. Guidelines allow Service personnel to wear uniform as they go about their normal business in our cities, towns and villages, subject to the local security situation. This change has been welcomed by the Services. More widely it should enhance the public's awareness of the Armed Forces, especially in communities with traditional Service links.

  8.2  While the biggest single contributor to public awareness is undoubtedly national advertising, the Services' presence in the form of high street recruiting/careers offices, attendance at public events, school support and the impact of single Service's open days plays a highly significant part in maintaining public awareness.

  8.3  The closure of a number of recruiting offices in the early to mid 1990s, and the transfer of their responsibilities to Department for Education and Employment (DfEE) "Jobcentres", reduced the visibility of the Services and did affect the numbers of recruits applying to join the Armed Forces. Though "Jobcentres' still advertise Armed Forces vacancies (and provide up to 5% of recruits), the principal role of recruiting has returned to the recruiting office. All three Services, acknowledging the effect on recruiting that the reduction in the number of careers offices had, embarked on a continuous programme of high profile media and recruitment campaigns. Contact between the Services and the public, in particular the young, has been enhanced through support to schools and youth organisations. The Services' contact with schools has benefited further through MoD's partnership with the DfEE Careers Service.

  8.4  A number of initiatives are in hand to keep the Services in the public eye. A "Meet Your Navy" UK deployment is currently taking place from 25 May to 10 July whereby around 20 ships, including an aircraft carrier, are visiting a large number of ports and cities to promote the image of the Services and to help recruiting. The Royal Navy Reserve is expanding its visibility in the community by creating sub-units in cities that have not had a Naval presence for some years. By the end of 2000-01, six such units will have been formed. There are also a range of open days, air shows and ceremonial events, most notably the Royal Military Tattoo 2000.

  8.5  Internet. In order to exploit the opportunities offered by modern technology, all three Services now have a careers website on the Internet. These websites have proved very popular. For example:

    —  Current use of the Internet in recruiting, particularly in the Naval Service, is focussed on marketing careers, and as a powerful communication medium. In 1999-2000, the Royal Navy careers website received 2,488 officer and 5,710 rating/Royal Marine other rank requests for information.

    —  The Army has found that the Internet has become the largest single medium attracting requests for further information from both potential soldiers and potential officers. The Army website has been voted one of the top 300 websites in the world; it hosts 4,000 visitors a day of which 800 go on to the careers section. The Army also launched its "on-line" recruiting office on 24 May 2000. This allows users (including parents and other adult users, as well as potential applicants) to have a one-to-one dialogue online with a Recruiter about life in the Army. The site has over 4,000 pages, but this is due to expand, and is seen as a central plank in the recruiting orientated communications strategy.

    —  The RAF careers website continues to be improved. It was recently measured as the fourth most visited aviation website in the world, having received 1.5 million visits in the period October 1999 to April 2000. It won the silver medal in the "Other Media" category as part of the Creative Circle Honours 2000. RAF officer applications from the Internet have been accepted since October 1999.

  8.6  Internet access has helped to ensure that any negative effect from recruitment office closures is minimised. It is too early to measure whether the number of enquiries and applications to the Armed Forces has increased as a result of the Services' websites. Nevertheless, the Services expect electronic media to represent a significant growth opportunity and to be a method of ensuring that the footprint is maintained in recruitment terms.

  8.7  Activities with Youth. There are four Cadet Forces, together involving around 130,000 young people aged between 12 and 22, supported by over 23,000 adult volunteers. They are the Combined Cadet Force—based in 240 schools (independent and state), the Sea Cadet Corps, the Army Cadet Force and the Air Training Corps.

  8.8  The Cadets are all voluntary youth organisations, sponsored and funded by the MoD, as part of the Department's contribution to society and the community. They are not recruiting organisations. Rather, by using military themes, based upon the culture and ethos of the single Services, they foster an interest in the Armed Forces. The aim of the cadet forces is to help the personal and social development of young people. Cadet forces offer a wide range of sporting, adventurous, military and community training activities. All cadet forces strongly support the Duke of Edinburgh's Award Scheme, and adventurous and expedition training. In addition, many units participate in community initiatives sponsored by the Home Office.

  8.9  From the next school year, the Department will also be piloting a new "Youth Initiative" in schools in Newcastle and Norfolk. Participants—in Years 10 and 11 (15 and 16 year-olds)—are those who will have been disapplied the National Curriculum. They will have around one day's contact per week over a two-year period with their military instructors. The US model, upon which our scheme has been based, sees around 40% of participants go on to adult military service of some sort. A second phase of the Youth Initiative (Thinking Skills Challenge) will be developed over the next 12 months.

  8.10  The MoD is developing a formal arrangement with the Prince's Trust Volunteers, whereby Team Leaders and soldiers are provided for their Team Challenge. Military personnel will use their skills to help increase self confidence and self reliance in those most in need of this. It is hoped that this will allow for development of closer links with the community and particularly to make use of the Prince's Trust's excellent relationship with ethnic minorities.

  8.11  Territorial Army. In 1998, the then Secretary of State set out the new role of the Territorial Army (TA) in the post-SDR era in Modern Forces for the Modern World: A Territorial Army for the Future. This acknowledged that the TA makes a significant contribution to defence in the wider community and, in many areas of the country, it has been the reserves rather than the regulars who provide the visible Armed Forces' presence. This helps to build links with, and informs the wider community of the role of the Armed Forces, to promote their values and support recruiting. This role of the TA was very much at the forefront of the planners' minds as they developed the new structure of the TA. Throughout this planning, they sought to establish a widely spread representation of the Army across the regions. As a consequence, although the overall numbers within the TA reduced, the so-called "footprint" of the TA was maintained as far as possible in the circumstances.


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2000
Prepared 9 November 2000