Select Committee on Environmental Audit Minutes of Evidence


Annex 6

QUOTES

"There has been a huge improvement in water supplies as a result of DWI"

"There seems to be a presumption that a company is on the fiddle rather than the presumption that a company is playing with a straight bat"

  "So much of what we have had to do over the last 12 months has had nothing to do with what comes out of customers' taps"

    "Company performances have improved beyond all recognition so why prosecute now?"
    "The inspection was very thorough and professional"
    "In our experience DWI's consultants are very competent people but they can't get issues resolved"
    "Relationship has definitely shifted in the last 12 months from partnership to policing"
    "Prosecution brings a different relationship"
    "The Liaison Inspector has an excellent level of professional knowledge and expertise and that's very important to us"
    "Tendency to be awfully formal in an exchange of letters rather than sitting down around a table"
    "The reorganisation of the Inspectorate was not a bad idea but it has had little effect on us so far"
    "The Inspector did an excellent job of carrying out the incident investigation"
    "We hope we don't see the mentality develop of issuing x parking tickets per day"
    "Some at DWI believe that a big stick must be taken to companies or they will get around everything"
    "When we queried the lack of an audit report we were told that DWI didn't want to burden the companies with too much"
    "We would have welcomed a meeting to discuss the draft report"
    "With Crypto DWI has moved from a respected regulator to disinterested enforcer taking a `never mind what the problem is' approach"
    "Not always clear what information is needed but it is usually resolved in one (long) phone call"
    "DWI has done a lot of good work to raise standards"
    "The draft Cryptosporidium regulations are saying to the companies `we don't trust you.' But the companies are trusted to analyse for arsenic and cyanide"
    "The Inspector was very thorough and tough and didn't miss a thing but also had an excellent manner in dealing with people"
    "DWI inspectors don't like to be challenged"
    "In carrying out the inspection the Inspector was heavy handed, nitpicking and inconsistent"
    "I regard DWI Inspectors as valuable consultants . . . and they come free!"
    "DWI start from the premise that they [the company] are doing it wrong whereas consultants start from the premise that they are doing it right"
    "Where are DWI trying to get to with their present policies?"
    "Danger of getting locked into a prosecution orientated relationship . . . not a very adult relationship . . . but accept that DWI were feeling frustrated at company inactivity"
    "Would prefer more meetings to resolve issues—could be less demanding of resources in the long-term"
    "The current solution to the Crypto issue comes from the water quality/laboratory background of the Inspectors"
    "DWI has perfect hindsight"
    "DWI is more concerned about prosecution for Crypto than ensuring that it doesn't appear in water supplies"
    "Too much emphasis on labs and AQC . . ."
    "All the recommendations could be implemented without improving water quality at all"
    "Three months is a long time to be hanging on a hook"
    "Consultants vary enormously and have a longer learning period"
    "DWI is generally good for the industry"


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2000
Prepared 14 November 2000