Select Committee on Environment, Transport and Regional Affairs Appendices to the Minutes of Evidence


Memorandum by Brian Palmer (RH 04)

  FACT 1: I have been connected with the haulage trade for well over 35 years.

  FACT 2: I have worked my way up from humble employee to an employer of 18 full time staff and three casual staff.

  FACT 3: In the last financial year I have paid in taxes, duties, rates, NI, licences, etc, over THREE QUARTERS of a MILLION pounds and received nothing in return.

  FACT 4: My company is facing imminent closure due to unfair foreign competition. The European hauliers we are up against have the following advantages.

  FACT 5: Their vehicles like their cars are 20 per cent cheaper. A big plus in any industry where capital input is high. Their trucks are cheaper still as they do not need to buy three axle units as we do because they are allowed to put 30 per cent more weight on their drive axles without incurring punitive taxes.

  FACT 6: Their road tax is ONE TENTH of our road fund licence, ours is £5,750 theirs is £500.

  FACT 7: They use our roads for free, if we visit their countries we pay day licences of up to £10 per day if not that then we pay their tolls, whichever way, we are funding them and it is not being reciprocated.

  FACT 8: The biggest advantage they have is the cost of their fuel, it is not unusual abroad to see fuel at 40p per litre (including their taxes and duties) as opposed to our cost of 77 pence per litre. At the eight miles to the gallon we reckon to average on our trucks this works out at the difference in costs of 43.7 pence per mile on our fuel to their 22.7 pence per mile on their prices. OURS IS DOUBLE!!!!!

  FACT 9: With the present favourable exchange rate and strong pound it is a fact that the Dutch can work over here at 25 per cent less than we do and make a good profit, we on the other hand are making a loss.

  FACT 10: One of my customers is using Dutch registered trucks with Estonian drivers to keep costs down even more. We have minimum wages, PAYE and NI to pay and we need to help drivers keep their standard of living up and we are up against cheap trucks with cheap tax and cheap fuel and now cheap labour. Any constructive hints on how I can compete will be gratefully received.

  FACT 11: Foreign trucks run on "dirty" high sulphur diesel, we run on "green" low sulphur fuel, we are penalised for helping with the environment, they are making a profit polluting our Country!!!

  FACT 12: According to Department of the Environment figures released in 1998 there had been a 50 per cent increase in foreign registered vehicles working in our country in the previous two years, that figure is still climbing rapidly, for latest figures you will need to consult with the DOE. I have not had any luck getting these figures but I am sure you will manage it.

  FACT 13: My vehicles regularly use 1,000 litres of fuel per week, this equates to £550 of fuel duty, on top of this there is VAT of over £110 and road tax of £110.50 per week. Without other taxes this comes to a regular income for the government of £770.50 per week, not bad eh!

  FACT 14: I know it is said that our high taxes and duties are balanced by the fact that we pay less in Corporation tax, I would love to pay Corporation tax unfortunately I need to make a profit to do this.

  FACT 15: I have not made a profit since last May when the price hike of the previous budget made itself felt, I am not confident or optimistic of being able to weather this storm, what a waste of 35 years.

  FACT 16: When my company folds and foreign competition takes my place which they surely must, then the exchequer will be paying out 18 lots of unemployment benefit or retraining or both.

  FACT 17: When my business fails the exchequer will lose £750,000 of taxes and duties that I pay at present, with the above fact 15 this amounts to a double whammy!! (how much does 18 lots of dole amount to over a year?)

  FACT 18: My company is not alone sharing these problems, in the village where I live we have lost six drivers jobs within the last two months and this is being repeated throughout the Country.

  FACT 19: The duty I am paying on fuel is a straight tax on productivity as opposed to a tax on profits and is strangling our industry even as we are attempting to make a living and a profit margin, any incentive to do any good is well and truly crushed before we have even started work.

  All of the above facts can be corroborated and I would be willing to furnish you with any financial information regarding my company if you think it may be useful. I would also be more than willing to meet with yourself or your committee if you think think this may be constructive, because as I have illustrated to you above the stakes are very high.

  I have enclosed for your perusal a fact sheet that was circulated by the East Anglian Hauliers Group on our lobby on the 26 January 2000, it contains much of what I have told you but in table form, I hope you will find it useful.

  When you have considered all the above facts you will notice that the playing field we shared with our continental neighbours is not so much on a gentle slope as on a cliff face.

  Please let the committee debate the points I have put to you, but please remember that the amount of time I have left in business is finite, I cannot hang on much longer. All I ask is parity with my competition and I will beat them and survive.

  You have myself and my family's future in your hands, please I beg you do not waste this opportunity to help me and my business instead of giving my livelihood to the Europeans who will pay the British Government nothing for it.

February 2000


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2000
Prepared 26 July 2000