Select Committee on Environment, Transport and Regional Affairs Appendices to the Minutes of Evidence


Supplementary memorandum by the Railway Development Society (RH 06A)

  Increase in Lorry Weights (40 tonne on five axles, 41 tonne on six axles).

  The benefit of 44 tonne lorries to intermodal traffic will be eroded by the general increase in weights proposed in the Government White Paper. Even the 44 tonne intermodal lorry previously allowed never did anything for lighter cargoes which grossed 38 tonne or less on road. This must be redressed. A simple increase of weight for intermodal traffic would be less productive as less cargoes would be able to make use of this concession and it would encourage the road haulage industry to use this as the next stepping stone in their constant striving for increased weights. A simpler mechanism is available which would not only benefit maximum weight shipments but would also assist all intermodal cargoes, even the lightest.

  All prime movers and drawbar combination units used EXCLUSIVELY for intermodal traffic should be given a status akin to that of a WORKS TRUCK. This would allow them to pay a much reduced road fund licence and use gas oil fuel. The resultant savings in cost would benefit not only maximum weight shipments but also lighter groupage traffic etc. Obviously, this proposal would need the strictest policing if it were not to be abused and several safeguards are recommended.

    (a)  All such vehicles should be clearly marked as such. It is suggested that a distinctive immovable badge is applied front, rear and on the sides clearly stating the vehicles status and home depot. This should be clearly legible to police patrols etc so that any abuse is easily detected.

    (b)  The radius of operation for such vehicles needs to be tightly restricted, perhaps to 50-80 kilometres. At present it is not unusual for 44 tonne intermodal units to have a road leg within the UK of200-300 miles. This is clearly against the spirit of the existing concession.

  (A calculation sheet which demonstrates the rationale behind the WORKS TRUCK idea is appended below.)

EXISTING DEFINITION OF WORKS TRUCK

  A motor vehicle (other than a straddle carrier) or trailer designed for use in private premises and used on a road only for delivering goods from or to such premises or to or from a vehicle on a road in the immediate neighbourhood or in passing from one part of the premises to another or to other private premises in the immediate neighbourhood or in connection with road works whilst used at or in the immediate neighbourhood of the site.

  Excise licence "SPECIAL VEHICLE"—Rate £160 (July 1998).

CALCUATION OF TAX BENEFIT OF "WORKS TRUCK" STATUS TO COMBINED TRANSPORT LORRY

  Excise Licence six axles 44 tonne—£1,280

    Works Truck—£160

    Benefit—£1,120

  Based on six day working week = £3.59p per day.

  Approximate fuel consumption of 44 tonne lorry = 1.25 miles per litre.

  Fuel duty per litre = 44p.

  Therefore 44 tonne lorry would save 33p per mile using fully rebated fuel.

  Single container/swap body lift = £20 approximately.

  Extra cost to combined transport of transhipment = one life on + one lift off = £40.

  Assuming one movement per lorry per day extra cost = £40.

    Less Excise licence reduction—£3.59p.

    Net additional cost = £36.41.

  At 33p per mile benefit from reduced fuel cost = 110 miles.

  Therefore maximum operating radius for such a lorry to avoid abuse by a haulier is 55 miles. For working purposes this has been rounded down to 80 kilometres hence that figure appears as a maximum in the recommendations to Government.


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2000
Prepared 26 July 2000