Select Committee on European Scrutiny Twelfth Report


DESIGNING TOMORROW'S EDUCATION - PROMOTING INNOVATION WITH NEW TECHNOLOGIES


(20967)
5800/00
COM(00) 23

Commission report on designing tomorrow's education
- promoting innovation with new technologies.
Legal base: — 
Document originated: 27 January 2000
Forwarded to the Council: 31 January 2000
Deposited in Parliament: 15 February 2000
Department: Education and Employment
Basis of consideration: EM of 28 February 2000
Previous Committee Report: None
To be discussed in Council: Date not set
Committee's assessment: Politically important
Committee's decision: Cleared

Background

  8.1  In May 1996, the Education Council adopted a resolution about multimedia software related to education and training.[36] This measure was followed in September 1997 by Council conclusions[37] on education, information and communication technology and teacher training for the future.

The document

  8.2  This report takes stock of the progress made in educational information and communication technology (ICT) since these earlier initiatives, and prepares the ground for a fresh stage of European co-operation. It is divided into three main parts. The first discusses "the problem of dovetailing technology with actual practice". It addresses various mismatches between the development of technology and its educational use. The second part identifies some conditions for a more harmonious development of practice and technologies: the growth (if gradual) of a market and its effects; action by public authorities at Community and Member State level; and the development of training and support services for teachers. The final part makes recommendations on how to bring about these favourable conditions. The annexes summarise the main initiatives in the Member States and at Community level, and contain statistical information. The report proposes that a Community-wide initiative should be launched in 2000.

The Government's view

  8.3  The Minister for Education and Employment (Baroness Blackstone) comments:

"The Commission recommends that better use is made of existing information and makes recommendations for better management and promotion of innovation at all levels. The Commission aims to launch a Community initiative in 2000, in conjunction with Member States, and on the basis of a broad consultation, in order to implement recommendations and achieve targets (both at national and Community level) for the year 2004. Policy implications arise to the extent that the Commission proposes greater sharing of experience and good practice between Member States than has previously occurred; the UK Government welcomes this development. However, the UK Government could not accept proposals for mandatory Europe-wide targets in this field, not least on levels and types of expenditure. The Commission have stated that they are aware of the subsidiarity issues. The draft recommendations will be subject to discussion and will lead to the development of a new Community Action Plan. Therefore, whilst this report in itself is not problematic, the resulting action plan might be.

"Another issue is the large variation in starting points for individual Member States. The Commission so far seems more interested in technology targets rather than in the quality and usage of the technology in teaching and learning. These issues will no doubt be debated further in the expert group at which both the DfEE and Scottish interests will be represented. The DfEE will consult other interested Government Departments and Assemblies."

Conclusion
8.4Despite the Minister's comment that the Commission seems more concerned with technology targets than with the quality of teaching and learning, the report makes some important points about the latter, and, generally, is a useful document.
8.5We note the markers that the Minister has laid down about the action plan which is expected to result from the report, and we shall bear her comments in mind for the future. Meanwhile, we clear this document.



36  OJ No. C 195 6.7.96, p.8. Back

37  OJ No. C 303 4.10.97, p.5. Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries

© Parliamentary copyright 2000
Prepared 24 March 2000