Select Committee on European Scrutiny Eighteenth Report


MAXIMUM LENGTH OF BUSES AND COACHES


(21168)
7577/00
COM(00) 137

Draft Directive amending Directive 96/53/EC laying down for certain
road vehicles circulating within the Community the maximum
authorised dimensions in national and international traffic and the
maximum authorised weights in international traffic.
Legal base: Article 71 EC; co-decision; qualified majority voting
Document originated: 23 March 2000
Forwarded to the Council: 12 April 2000
Deposited in Parliament: 24 April 2000
Department: Environment, Transport and the Regions
Basis of consideration: EM of 11 May 2000
Previous Committee Report: None but see paragraph 14.1 below
To be discussed in Council: Late 2000
Committee's assessment: Politically important
Committee's decision: Cleared

Background

  14.1  As a result of inability to agree on a harmonised maximum length of 12 metres for all rigid motor vehicles, Directive 96/53/EC provided that rigid buses[21] up to 12 metres in length and articulated buses up to 18 metres could circulate freely within the Community when undertaking international transport. Some Member States allow rigid buses in excess of 12 metres and some up to 15 metres. Others, like the UK, have a 12 metre limit. This discourages inter-state bus travel and cabotage arrangements in particular. On 8 July 1988 we reported[22] on a Commission report on the use of buses up to 15 metres. That report looked at commercial, technical, safety, environmental and infrastructure considerations and put forward options for consultation.

The document

  14.2  In response to a Council request for legislative action, the Commission has now proposed the adoption of a maximum length of 15 metres for rigid buses and 18.75 metres for buses and trailers. Buses longer than 12 metres will need to have three or more axles so as to reduce any infrastructure damage and assist safety. 15 metre buses will have to meet existing technical requirements for turning applicable to 12 metre buses and the outswing requirements for 18 metre articulated buses. Transitional periods are proposed to allow the operation on their own national territory of buses which do not meet the new requirements, but to operate freely within the Community the requirements of the Directive would have to be met.

The Government's view

  14.3  In his Explanatory Memorandum of 11 May 2000, the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions (Lord Whitty) supports the proposal. He says that there should be little effect on road infrastructure or on the safety of other road users, and that there will be environmental benefits by using fewer vehicles to transport similar numbers of passengers to those carried on existing vehicles.

  14.4  He says that the Commission expects 15 metre buses to be a niche market rather than the norm. Harmonisation will particularly benefit those who already make or operate 15 metre buses because it creates a genuine single market for them. He notes that the bus operators and manufacturers welcome the proposals and all thought that this would pose no problems for small operators or manufacturers. He says that there may be a requirement for a small number of extra restrictions on the use of longer vehicles but it is not possible to quantify any costs from this. Local freedoms, for example to restrict vehicles by size on certain roads, will not be affected.

Conclusion

  14.5  We note the Government's support for this proposal and we see the case for harmonisation in this area. We believe the Commission may be proved mistaken in assuming the 15 metre buses will be a niche market rather than the norm. However, in the light of the Government's assurances about safety, the environment and the infrastructure, we are content to clear the document and have no questions to ask.


21  We use the term 'bus' in this report to include coaches. This is in line with existing EC legislation which defines a coach as a bus that does not provide for standing passengers. Back

22  (19187) 9122/98; see HC 155-xxxiii (1997-98), paragraph 7 (8 July 1998). Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2000
Prepared 30 May 2000