Select Committee on International Development Minutes of Evidence


Examination of Witness (Numbers 520 - 524)

TUESDAY 6 JULY 1999

MR R FOWLER

  520. There is golden rule in politics: never say never.
  (Mr Fowler) That is right, that was what I was trying to get to. That clearly applies particularly at the UN. I think it is well understood. The other reality of course is that sanctions—and I am now dealing geopolitically—however difficult they are to agree, are easier to enforce than to stop. There is a great deal of talk at the UN about sunsetting or sunset clauses generally and that we should give more thought to ending things. I do not think anybody has ever dared add up the number of issues with which the Security Council is seized, but we end virtually every resolution that we pass with the paragraph that the UN Security Council shall remain seized of this issue. It is a very thick file.

  521. You are seized by many issues.
  (Mr Fowler) Exactly.

  522. Do you think that the effectiveness of UN sanctions regimes actually results from the political compromises which you described which have to go on to get it through the Council?
  (Mr Fowler) I do.

  523. They do limit the effectiveness.
  (Mr Fowler) Yes; but that is reality. That is what you can get through and that is the way we designed this organisation called the United Nations and I certainly do not see any ground swell of views which suggest they want some other kind of organisation.

  524. Do you think there are points which we might have overlooked in the course of our questions which you would like to address?
  (Mr Fowler) I shamelessly inserted the things I wanted to say in questions as they occurred, so I think I have covered most things. I guess, just to end, a comment I made earlier to the effect that I am fairly optimistic about this task within the constraints I mentioned as to what success is. We talked about the Mr Fowler) Yes; correct.

  Chairman: Thank you very much indeed for spending this morning with us. It has brought to life the difficulties you are facing but without being gloomy about it. Thank you very much indeed.





 
previous page contents

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries

© Parliamentary copyright 2000
Prepared 10 February 2000