Select Committee on Procedure Second Report


ANNEX 1

Analysis of responses to the Chairman's questionnaire

The total number of responses received from Members of Parliament is 130 (19.7% of the total number of Members currently serving in the House).

comprising:
      Labour 65
      Conservative 48
      Liberal Democrats 5
      Independent 1
      Plaid Cymru 2
      UK Unionist 1
      Social Democratic and Labour Party 1
      Scottish National Party 2
      Anonymous 5
  
  
Number of MPs who favour a ballot system: 111 (85.4%)
comprising:
      Labour 54
      Conservative 40
      Liberal Democrats 4
      Independent 1
      Plaid Cymru 1
      UK Unionist 1
      Social Democratic and Labour Party 1
      Scottish National Party 2
      Anonymous 5
  
  
Number of MPs who do not favour a ballot system: 11 (8.5%)
comprising:
      Labour 5
      Conservative 6
  
 
Number of MPs who do not have a preference: 8 (6.1%)
comprising:
      Labour 6
      Conservative 1
      Liberal Democrats 1
  
  
Number of MPs who favour a secret ballot system: 82 (63%)
comprising:
      Labour 38
      Conservative 30
      Liberal Democrats 4
      Plaid Cymru 2
      UK Unionist 1
      Scottish National Party 2
      Anonymous 5
  
  
Number of MPs who favour an open ballot system: 31 (23.8%)
comprising:
      Labour 18
      Conservative 10
      Independent 1
      Social Democratic and Labour Party 1
      Anonymous 1
      Others 8
      Don't knows/no change: 5
  
  
Number of MPs who favour the alternative vote system: 46 (35.4%)
comprising:
      Labour 29
      Conservative 6
      Liberal Democrats 5
      Plaid Cymru 2
      Scottish National Party 1
      Social Democratic and Labour Party 1
      Anonymous 2
  
  
Number of MPs who favour a first past the post system: 39 (30%)
comprising:
      Labour 10
      Conservative 25
      Independent 1
      UKU 1
      Anonymous 3
      Don't knows/no change 26
      Others 17
  
  
78 Members (60%) favour each candidate to continue to require a mover and seconder.
  
47 Members (36%) favour each candidate requiring a mover and seconder and for all three to be entitled to address the House as at present.
  
41 Members (31.5%) are in favour of a written manifesto replacing or supplementing a mover and seconder.
  
44 Members (33.8%) favour a hustings meeting.
  
32 Members (24.6%) favour the requirement that candidates have the support of a minimum number of Members to be eligible to enter the contest.

18 January 2001



 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2001
Prepared 15 February 2001