House of Commons
Session 2001- 02|
Publications on the internet
Other Bills before Parliament
Arrangement of Clauses (Contents)
These notes refer to the Education Bill
1. These explanatory notes relate to the Education Bill as introduced in the House of Commons on 22 November 2001. They have been prepared by the Department for Education and Skills (DfES) in order to assist the reader of the Bill and help inform debate on it. They do not form part of the Bill and have not been endorsed by Parliament.
2. The notes need to be read in conjunction with the Bill. They are not, and are not meant to be, a comprehensive description of the Bill. So where a clause or part of a clause does not seem to require any explanation or comment, none is given.
3. Abbreviations have been used where appropriate and are explained in the glossary at the end of the notes.
SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND
4. The Education Bill implements proposals set out in the White Paper "Schools - achieving success" (Cm 5230) published on 5 September 2001, in five related consultation papers published on the same day ("The Way Forward - a Modernised Framework for School Governance", "Consultation on School Admissions", "Consultation on Exclusion Appeals Panels", "Changes to the Registration and Monitoring of Independent Schools", "Better beginnings - Improving Quality and Increasing Provision in Early Years Education and Childcare") and in a consultation paper issued on 21 September ("16-19 Organisation and Inspection: a Consultation Document"). Implementation in Wales will be guided by the principles set out in the National Assembly for Wales' (NAW) consultation document "The Learning Country" ("Y wlad sy'n Dysgu"), published on 5 September 2001.
5. Except for sections 183 and Schedule 18, which amend provisions in the Education Act 1997 (EA 97) which extend to Northern Ireland as well as England and
Wales, the Bill will extend to England and Wales only. In the main, the provisions relate both to England and Wales, although there are some variations in the precise provisions for England and in Wales. A number of provisions relate to England only and a few to Wales only.
Part 1: Provision for New Legal Frameworks
6. This Part makes provision for new legal frameworks in order to support innovation and new forms of service delivery.
Chapter 1 of Part 1: Powers to facilitate innovation
7. This Chapter introduces a new power for the Secretary of State, or the NAW in Wales, to respond to an application by a qualifying body by issuing an order suspending or modifying legislation for a period of up to 3 years. The power is intended to enable innovative pilot projects to take place and may by order be either extended in time, provided that in total no such project lasts for more than 6 years or terminated. The powers set out in this Chapter will last for 4 years.
Chapter 2 of Part 1: Exemptions related to school performance
8. These provisions will allow, subject to regulations, greater autonomy for governing bodies of successful schools over certain elements of teachers' pay and conditions and the national curriculum, and, potentially, other areas which will be subject to application to the Secretary of State, or the NAW. The qualifying criteria to define successful schools, and the specific areas where greater flexibility will be permitted, will be set out in regulations.
Chapter 3 of Part 1: Powers to form companies etc.
9. This Chapter enables the implementation of proposals outlined in the policy paper "The Role of the Local Education Authority in School Education" for new models of service delivery. It provides that a school may become a member of a company for the purposes of providing services for schools and to exercise functions of an LEA, where the LEA chooses to contract them out pursuant to an order under the Deregulation and Contracting Out Act 1994. It also enables the Secretary of State to form or participate in forming companies for purposes connected with her functions relating to education.
Part 2: Financial Assistance for Education and Childcare
10. This Part makes arrangements for enabling the Secretary of State, or the NAW, to give financial assistance for education and childcare.
11. At present, the Secretary of State, or the NAW, has a wide variety of powers for making available funding or other forms of financial assistance for purposes connected with education or childcare. This Part repeals many of these powers and replaces them with a single broad power to fund education, childcare and related activities. The assistance may be given through grants, loans, guarantees and incurring expenditure for the benefit of the person assisted. The power to fund excludes higher education (HE), but includes all other forms of education.
Part 3: Maintained schools
12. Part 3 makes provisions with respect to the government and financing of maintained schools, and admissions, exclusions and attendance.
Chapter 1 of Part 3: Government of Maintained Schools
13. This Chapter implements the Government's consultation paper on school governance: "The Way Forward - A Modernised Framework for School Governance".
14. The Chapter provides that every maintained school shall have a governing body responsible for the conduct of the school with, in accordance with the regulations, an established membership and instrument of government. Regulations will make provisions concerning the control and occupation of school premises by governing bodies. The Chapter introduces measures to enable more than one school to federate under a single governing body, if they so choose, and provided that they comply with prescribed procedures and conditions. In addition, the Secretary of State, or the NAW, may make regulations providing for governing bodies to discharge functions jointly either through whole governing bodies or through joint committees.
15. Provision is made to enable governing bodies to provide community facilities or services for the benefit of their pupils, their pupils' families and the wider community. It also provides for limits to be imposed on those powers. The Chapter also introduces measures requiring governors to produce an annual report; hold an annual parents' meeting; and establish complaints procedures. This Chapter also provides for the staffing of maintained schools, repealing current arrangements and empowering the Secretary of State, or the NAW, to make regulations about the appointment, discipline, suspension and dismissal of staff.
16. The Chapter also provides that maintained nursery schools are to have governing bodies.
Chapter 2 of Part 3: Financing of Maintained Schools
17. This Chapter introduces components of a new system for funding LEAs and schools. It introduces new definitions of the 'LEA budget' for central functions and the 'schools budget' for expenditure on pupils. It requires LEAs to establish a schools forum in accordance with regulations, to represent the views of schools with respect to the funding of schools in the area. It also provides a power for the Secretary of State, or the NAW, to set a minimum level for the schools budget.
18. In addition, the Chapter provides that the governing body of a maintained school may be required to keep prescribed accounts and records, prepare prescribed financial statements, comply with prescribed audit conditions and to send copies of accounts and financial statements to the Secretary of State or NAW. Financial statements must also be prepared in relation to private funds.
Chapter 3 of Part 3: Admissions, Exclusions and Attendance
19. The Chapter makes a number of amendments to the provisions for admission to maintained schools. It requires LEAs to establish an admission forum to advise on local admissions issues. It repeals the requirement for schools to have a standard number. It provides for the Secretary of State, or the NAW, to make regulations requiring LEAs to take action to secure an agreement between admission authorities in the area for co-ordinating admission arrangements. It introduces a power to make regulations with respect to admission appeals.
20. The Chapter further provides for the exclusion of a pupil from a maintained school, and for regulations to be made in relation to such exclusions, including the procedures to be followed, the arrangements for review of exclusions and appeals against decisions not to reinstate the pupil and adding pupil referral units (PRU) and nursery schools. Provision is also made for the Secretary of State, or the NAW, to require governing bodies to set school-level targets for authorised as well as unauthorised absence.
Part 4: Powers of Intervention
21. This Part extends the powers through which the Secretary of State, or NAW, and LEAs may intervene in schools with serious weaknesses or requiring special measures. It introduces a new power to appoint an interim executive board (IEB); and a power for the Secretary of State or NAW to involve an external partner in turning round a school in special measures or having serious weaknesses.
22. The Part also extends the powers of the Secretary of State, or NAW, to intervene in weak LEAs.
Part 5: School Organisation
23. This Part makes provision about the setting up of new schools and the alteration and discontinuance of existing schools. The first group of clauses provides for the amendment of current legislation relating to city academies and city colleges. The second group of clauses makes provision about how schools, chiefly maintained schools, can be established, altered or discontinued. There are changes in who can make proposals for alterations and in the procedures for dealing with proposals.
Part 6: The Curriculum in England
24. This Part makes provision for a National Curriculum in England, replacing sections 350 to 357 and 362 to 367 of the Education Act 1996 (EA 96), in England. It also re-enacts sections 351 and 352 but with amendments to reflect the incorporation of the foundation stage within the National Curriculum in England.
25. The Part introduces and provides for the areas of learning within the Foundation Stage. It also separates the first, second and third key stages in England from the fourth key stage and sets out that the National Curriculum shall comprise the attainment targets, programmes of study and assessment arrangements in relation to each key stage. It provides that in relation to the fourth key stage, the Secretary of State may amend the subjects or abolish the Key Stage by order, and re-enacts the special cases provisions of the EA 96.
Part 7: The Curriculum in Wales
26. This Part separates out the National Curriculum for Wales from that for England. It closely mirrors Part 6, except that it provides for the period and content of the foundation stage to be set out in an order of the NAW and includes the Welsh language in the curriculum.
Part 8: Teachers
27. This Part makes provision for teachers' pay and conditions, appraisal, qualifications and provision about misconduct. It repeals the School Teachers' Pay and Conditions Act 1991 (STPCA) and replaces its provisions with a modernised framework, but continuing with the main outlines of the existing machinery. It replaces existing requirements for appraisal, and puts in place a new requirement. It provides for teacher and headteacher qualifications in schools and lecturer and principal qualifications in further education (FE) colleges.
Part 9: Childcare and Nursery Education
28. This Part deals with childcare and nursery education. In particular it makes provision about the role of LEAs in childcare and nursery education and amends the inspection and registration regimes for childminding and day care and nursery education.
Part 10: Independent Schools
29. This Part introduces a new regulatory regime, under which independent schools will have to comply with prescribed standards before registration and at all times afterwards. There is also provision about children with special educational needs (SEN) at independent schools.
Part 11: Miscellaneous and General
30. This Part contains provisions relating to education outside schools for 14-16 year olds. It also extends the definition of 'secondary education' in the EA 96 to include certain forms of training and makes provision about allowances relating to education or training for persons over 16 and inspections.
31. Provision is made to enable the Secretary of State to repay the student loans of those defined by regulations as being eligible.
32. A number of minor amendments are made to Education Action Zones (EAZs), including an extension to the range of schools eligible to participate and a broadening of the objects of the Zones.
33. Amendments to inspection provisions include a broadening of the duties of inspectors to report on the management and leadership of schools and a power to enable a member of the Inspectorate to carry out inspections currently only deliverable by a registered inspector.
34. The powers of the Qualifications and Curriculum Authority (QCA) and the Qualifications, Curriculum and Assessment Authority for Wales (ACCAC) are extended. The powers of LEAs to award qualifications are clarified.
35. Provision is made to enable regional provision to be made in Wales in respect of children with special educational needs (SEN). A Special Educational Needs Tribunal for Wales is established.
36. The NAW is given powers to require publication of certain information by schools and LEAs, and to make regulations requiring LEAs in Wales to enter into partnership agreements with schools maintained by them. Provision is also made for the NAW to require the governing bodies of primary and secondary schools to draw up plans together to facilitate the transition of pupils from one to the other.
37. Amendments are made to the provisions for transport for persons over compulsory school age, to ensure that LEAs develop, publish and implement policies meeting certain criteria. Changes are made to the provisions concerning school meals and milk, to ensure that children not yet of school age receiving funded nursery education may be eligible for free school meals and milk and that regulations can restrict entitlement to free school meals to children in attendance over the lunch period.
38. Provision is made making it an offence to create or permit nuisance or disturbance on the premises of a non-maintained special school, an independent school or certain LEA-maintained facilities.
39. The role of the Secretary of State in settling recoupment disputes is ended (although it is retained for the NAW). A power is introduced for the Secretary of State to make payment to the chairmen of local learning and skills councils.
40. The Bill is divided into 11 Parts and has 211 clauses and 22 Schedules.
41. Part 1 introduces new legal frameworks, including powers to promote innovation.
42. Part 2 makes provision for financial assistance, and will repeal a significant number of powers to fund education, replacing it with a single general one.
43. Part 3 makes provision for the governance of maintained schools, replacing Chapter 3 of Part 2 of the School Standards and Framework Act 1998 (SSFA); for the financing of maintained schools, amending Chapter 4 of Part 2 of the SSFA; for the staffing of maintained schools, amending Chapter 5 of Part 2 of the SSFA; for admissions to maintained schools, amending Chapter 1 of Part 3 of the SSFA; and for exclusion of pupils.
44. Part 4 makes provision for intervention in schools causing concern and LEAs.
45. Part 5 introduces 'Academies', making changes to the EA 96 and to the Learning and Skills Act 2000 (LSA); and makes changes to provisions for the establishment, alteration and discontinuance of schools in Chapter 2 of Part 2 of the SSFA.
46. Part 6 replaces for England curriculum provisions in Part 5 of the EA 96.
47. Part 7 replaces for Wales curriculum provisions in Part 5 of the EA 96.
48. Part 8 makes provision with respect to teachers, repealing the STPCA and making provision for teachers' pay and conditions, repealing section 218 of the Education Reform Act 1988 (ERA), and making new provision for teachers' qualifications.
49. Part 9 makes adjustments to provision with respect to nursery education and childcare in the Children Act 1989 (CA) and the SSFA.
50. Part 10 makes provision with respect to independent schools, and replaces Chapter 2 of Part 7 of the EA 96.
51. Part 11 makes miscellaneous and general provisions.
COMMENTARY ON CLAUSES AND SCHEDULES
PART 1 - PROVISION FOR NEW LEGAL FRAMEWORKS
Chapter 1 - Powers to facilitate innovation
Clauses 1 to 4
Clauses 1-4: Powers to facilitate innovation
52. These clauses describe the purpose of this Chapter of the Bill which is to facilitate experimental pilot projects in the education system, where the Secretary of State, or NAW, believes innovation is likely to lead to improvement in educational standards.
53. The clauses allow the Secretary of State, or NAW, to suspend legislative requirements and, if necessary, modify legislation or confer new powers. The power is limited to education legislation (both primary and secondary). The lifetime of the power is also limited. The power to make entirely new orders will be exercisable only for four years, after which time it is expected that the utility of the power will be reviewed and lessons learnt can be evaluated and disseminated.
54. The duration of any particular suspension or modification is restricted to three years in the first instance. This provides time for most innovative practices to be implemented and evaluated, while ensuring that pilots remain time limited.
55. The clauses allow orders made under the power to be extended either in scope (both of bodies and functions) or time (subject to a maximum period of six years). It also enables the Secretary of State, or NAW, to terminate any suspension or modification of legislation. This is to ensure that if it became clear that a specific innovative proposal was not going to deliver the anticipated benefits, the Secretary of State, or NAW, would be able to reinstate the original legislation.
56. If any experiment under this power proves worthwhile and the Government is of the view that it should be made permanent, then it would need to consider amending the relevant statutory provisions. It could do so either by way of a Bill to amend the relevant legislation or by way of a Regulatory Reform Order under the Regulatory Reform Act 2001 (c.6).
57. The clauses provide that the effect of a temporary order under the new power may be disregarded for the purposes of section 1(4)(b) of the Regulatory Reform Act 2001 (which prevents the amendment, repeal or replacement of primary legislation through Regulatory Reform Orders within two years of substantive amendment of the relevant provisions). So the restriction in section 1(4)(b) of that Act will not prevent the making of permanent legislative provision in place of the temporary order.
58. The clauses also enable the Secretary of State, or NAW, to determine the application procedure, and specifically require the body seeking an order under the power to consult with other appropriate bodies. It also allows the Secretary of State, or NAW, to change - with the consent of the applicant - the content of the application.
Chapter 2 - Exemptions related to school performance
Clauses 5 to 9
Clauses 5 to 9: Exemptions related to school performance
59. These clauses enable any community, foundation, voluntary or special school that is of a prescribed description and satisfies prescribed criteria to apply for exemption from certain aspects of legislation covering the national curriculum and teachers' pay and conditions.
60. They explain that the Secretary of State, or NAW, will make regulations specifying the qualifying criteria that a school will be required to meet to be eligible to apply. The application will be to the Secretary of State, or NAW, for an order to confirm the exemption. Some elements of the pay and conditions and curriculum requirements will be subject to exemption by right, whereas others will be subject to the Secretary of State's, or NAW's, discretion. The areas in which exemption may apply by right and those in which it will only be available at the discretion of the Secretary of State, or NAW, will also be set out in regulations.
61. The governing body of an eligible school will need to consult with appropriate parties, including staff within the school and parents, on whether and how to apply. The exemption will apply until such time as the order is revoked or varied.
62. Revocation or variation can be by order without application if the school has ceased to be a qualifying school.
Chapter 3 - Powers to form companies etc.
Clauses 10 to 12
Clause 10: Powers of governing bodies to form or invest in companies to provide services etc.
63. The clauses provide new enabling powers so that the governing body of a school can form, or take part in forming, companies to provide services. Such a company could provide, or help with the provision of, facilities or services for schools. It could, for example, provide, or arrange the provision of, the financial, technical and legal advice that schools would normally have to arrange elsewhere, and it could also procure suppliers through the use of standard specifications and contracts.
64. In addition, maintained schools may form companies to deliver services to any schools on behalf of an LEA, pursuant to a 'contracting out' order under the Deregulation and Contracting Out Act 1994, and/or to provide traded services to schools.
Clause 11: Limits on powers conferred by section10
65. This clause requires maintained schools wishing to form or join companies established for the purposes of clause 10 to obtain the consent of their LEA. Regulations will set out the basis on which an LEA may refuse consent. Only schools with a delegated budget will be able to belong to such a company.
66. Regulations may require that the companies are registered under the Companies Act 1985 as companies limited by guarantee. The clause provides for regulations to deal with such matters as the constitution of the company and the effect of the delegated budget being withdrawn from a member school. Companies may not borrow money without consent.
67. Regulations will put in place arrangements for the financial monitoring of these companies and powers to address any financial mismanagement of the company.
Clause 12: General powers of Secretary of State in relation to companies
68. This clause provides for the Secretary of State to form, take part in forming, or invest in a company for purposes connected with her education functions.
PART 2 - FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE FOR EDUCATION AND CHILDCARE
Clauses 13 to 17
Clauses 13 to 17: Financial assistance for education and childcare
69. Clause 13 enables the Secretary of State or the NAW to give financial assistance for a number of educational or education-related purposes. These purposes are broadly defined and include, among many other objects, childcare, the use of educational buildings for different purposes and the support of teachers. Funds may be directed to schools, LEAs, individuals and companies. Education will include pre-school, school and FE, but not HE (apart from teacher-training).
70. The power allows the Secretary of State, or NAW, to attach conditions, at her or its discretion, to the provision of assistance. In particular, as well as providing financial assistance directly, clause 16 allows financial assistance to be provided via third parties. For example grants might be made available to an LEA, on condition that the LEA passes the grant on to its schools.
PART 3 - MAINTAINED SCHOOLS
Chapter 1 - Government of maintained schools
Clauses 18 to 38
Clause 18 and Schedule 1: Governing Bodies
71. The clause provides for each maintained school to have a governing body which is a body corporate, the constitution and membership of which will be established in accordance with regulations. Currently the SSFA prescribes the membership of governing bodies for different categories of schools.
72. In relation to England, regulations will establish the principles by which schools will be able to set the membership of their governing bodies from certain stakeholder categories and will set proportions to be drawn from them rather than absolute numbers as at present.
73. The regulations will also establish a single staff governor category to replace separate teacher and non-teacher staff categories and will also establish that within that category one place should be reserved for a teacher.
74. In relation to Wales the NAW will make the regulations and will consult interested bodies before establishing the requirements for membership and procedures of governing bodies.
75. Regulations under this clause will also make provision for other matters relating to the constitution and procedures of governing bodies, including how governors are to be elected or appointed, eligibility, resignation, removal and how governing body meetings should be conducted.
76. This clause and the new Schedule 1 replace section 36 of, and Schedules 9, 10 and 11 to, the SSFA. Paragraph 1 of Schedule 10 to the SSFA, which provided for the continuance of governing bodies on the introduction of the new school categories, does not require re-enactment. Schedule 1 re-enacts the rest of that Schedule, with changes that reflect the transfer of functions to the NAW and also the new powers conferred on governing bodies under clause 25 to provide community facilities.
|© Parliamentary copyright 2001||Prepared: 26 November 2001|