Select Committee on Procedure Third Report


ANNEX A

QUESTIONNAIRE SENT TO ALL MEMBERS OF THE HOUSE OF COMMONS

MEMBER'S NAME:

YEAR WHEN FIRST ENTERED HOUSE:

______________________________________________________________________________

PLEASE TICK THE BOXES WHERE APPLICABLE   

A.   GENERAL      

1.  Which aspects of the current system of parliamentary questions do you find most attractive?

Which aspects of the current system of parliamentary questions do you find least attractive?

If you could introduce a single reform to the system, what would it be?

2.  How effective do you think the system of oral and written questions is in bringing information into the public domain, contributing to political debate, and holding the Executive to account?

(a) oral questions    (b) written questions

3.  How often in an average week do you table oral questions?

How often in an average week do you table written questions?

How do you use the system of questions to assist you in your work as a Member?

B.   GOVERNMENT RESPONSIBILITIES AND CONTENT OF QUESTIONS/ANSWERS

4.  Could the Government do anything further to clarify areas of departmental responsibility to assist Members in their tabling of questions?

5.  Are you satisfied with the current system of transfers between departments?

YES ¨    NO ¨    If not, how might this be improved?

6.  In your view, are the current rules governing content of questions reasonable?

YES ¨    NO ¨    If you feel they are not, could you give specific examples?

How satisfied are you with the speed of answers to written questions?

Very ¨ Quite ¨ No opinion ¨ Dissatisfied ¨   Very Dissatisfied ¨

How satisfied are you with the quality of answers to written questions?

C.  TIMING AND TOPICALITY

7.  Should the current deadlines for tabling oral questions be reduced or abolished, in order to allow for more topical questioning?

YES ¨   NO ¨

The present rules require that, in order to be admissible, an oral question to a departmental Minister should be so worded as to indicate, within reasonably broad limits, a particular subject matter. Would you support a change to allow 'open' questions to departmental Ministers?

YES ¨   NO ¨

Should the timing and format of Question Time in the House be changed?

     YES ¨   NO ¨ If so, how?

8.  Would you support a change in the rules to allow questions to be answered during part of the summer recess?

YES ¨    NO ¨

9.  Is the current distinction between named day (formerly 'priority') written questions and ordinary written questions useful?

YES ¨   NO ¨   If not, why not?

D.   ELECTRONIC TABLING

10.  Would you support a system of tabling questions by e-mail?

YES ¨  NO ¨

Would you personally make use of such a facility?

    YES ¨  NO ¨     If so, how often?

How do you think technical issues such as verification of the identity of the Member tabling the question could be tackled?

11.  Should any system of electronic tabling be extended to cover Early Day Motions and other motions as well?

YES ¨  NO ¨

E.   MEMBERS' PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY FOR QUESTIONS

12.  Is the requirement that oral questions can only be tabled by a Member in person (or another Member acting on his or her behalf) justified?

YES ¨  NO ¨    If not, why not?

13.  How frequently do you receive requests from outside organisations or lobbying groups that you should table questions on their behalf?

Several times a week ¨ Once a week ¨ Once a month ¨ Occasionally ¨ Never ¨  

How often do you accede to such requests?

Several times a week ¨ Once a week ¨ Once a month ¨ Occasionally ¨ Never ¨  

How often do your receive similar requests from your own whips or party advisers?

Several times a week ¨ Once a week ¨ Once a month ¨ Occasionally ¨ Never ¨  

How often do you accede to such requests?

Several times a week ¨ Once a week ¨ Once a month ¨ Occasionally ¨ Never ¨  

14.  To what extent are your staff involved in preparing questions?

Would it be helpful for the House authorities to offer some form of training in the questions system for Members' staff?

YES ¨  NO ¨

F.   TABLE OFFICE SERVICES

15.  Are there any particular improvements you would like to see to the service offered by the TableOffice?

16.  Are you aware that it is possible to for the Table Office to communicate with you by pager?

   

YES ¨   NO ¨

Have you made any use of this opportunity?

YES ¨  NO ¨

Do you think this is a useful facility?

YES ¨  NO ¨

17.  Could the current question forms be redesigned to make them clearer and more helpful to Members?

YES ¨    NO ¨   If yes, please state how

G.   OTHER COMMENTS

18.  Are there any other comments you wish to make?


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2002
Prepared 26 June 2002