House of Commons portcullis
House of Commons
Session 2002 - 03
Internet Publications
Other Bills before Parliament

Finance Bill


Finance Bill
Schedule 32 — Tonnage tax: restrictions on capital allowances for lessors of ships

    371

 

          (5)      After that paragraph insert—

“Quantitative restrictions not to apply to ordinary charters

          89A                 (1)                  Paragraph 94 to 102, and paragraph 89(1) so far as relating to those

paragraphs, do not apply in the following cases.

                           (2)                  The first case is where the ship is chartered out by a person who is

5

responsible—

                      (a)                     for the operation of the ship, including the appointment of

the master and those members of the crew engaged in

navigation, throughout the period of the charter, and

                      (b)                     for defraying all expenses in connection with the ship

10

throughout that period, or substantially all such expenses

other than those directly incidental to a particular voyage

or to the employment of the ship during that period.

                                             For the purposes of this sub-paragraph a person is “responsible” if

he is responsible as principal or if he appoints another person,

15

other than the lessee or a person connected with the lessee, to be

responsible in his place.

                           (3)                  The second case is where—

                      (a)                     the ship is chartered out by a person acting in the course of

a trade that consists of, or to a significant extent includes,

20

operating ships, and

                      (b)                     the conditions in sub-paragraph (4) are met.

                           (4)                  Those conditions are—

                      (a)                     that the period of the charter does not exceed seven years,

and there is no provision or agreement under which it

25

could be extended beyond seven years;

                      (b)                     that the period of the charter, together with any other

periods in the same ten years during which the ship is

chartered out to the lessee or a person connected with him,

does not exceed seven years in total;

30

                      (c)                     that there are no arrangements under which the lessee or a

person connected with him may acquire the ship, whether

directly or indirectly, from the lessor.

                            In paragraph (b) “the same ten years” means any period of ten

years that includes the period of the charter mentioned in that

35

paragraph.

                           (5)                  References in this paragraph to the period of a charter are to the

term specified in the lease or, if longer, the actual period during

which the ship is chartered.

                           (6)                  Section 839 of the Taxes Act 1988 (connected persons) applies for

40

the purposes of this paragraph.”.

Consequential amendments

  2       (1)      In paragraph 41(4) of that Schedule (the requirement not to enter into tax

avoidance arrangement: exemption for finance leases)—

              (a)             in the first sentence omit “finance”;

45

 

 

Finance Bill
Schedule 32 — Tonnage tax: restrictions on capital allowances for lessors of ships

    372

 

              (b)             for the second sentence substitute—

                                                                “In this sub-paragraph “lease”, and “lessor” in relation to a

lease, have the meaning given by paragraph 89(2).”.

          (2)      In paragraph 147 (index of defined expressions)—

              (a)             omit the entry for “finance lease (and lessor and lessee) (in Part X)”;

5

              (b)             insert at the appropriate place—

                                  “lease (and lessor and lessee) (in Part X)             paragraph 89(2)”.

Commencement and temporary provision

  3       (1)      Subject to paragraph 4(2), the amendments made by paragraphs 1 and 2

apply in relation to any lease entered into on or after 19th December 2002.

10

          (2)      In sub-paragraph (4)(b) of the paragraph 89A inserted by paragraph 1(5)

above, the reference to any other periods during which the ship is chartered

out does not include any period during which it is chartered out under a

lease entered into before 19th December 2002.

  4       (1)      This paragraph applies in relation to any lease entered into on or after 19th

15

December 2002 and before 16 April 2003.

          (2)      Part 10 of the Schedule 22 to the Finance Act 2000 (c. 17) has effect as if,

instead of the paragraph inserted after paragraph 89 by paragraph 1(5)

above, the following paragraph were inserted—

“Exception for ordinary charters

20

          89A                 (1)                  Paragraph 89(1), and the provisions of this Part of this Schedule

listed there, do not apply in the following cases.

                           (2)                  The first case is where the ship is chartered out by a person who is

responsible—

                      (a)                     for the operation of the ship, including the appointment of

25

the master and those members of the crew engaged in

navigation, throughout the period of the charter, and

                      (b)                     for defraying all expenses in connection with the ship

throughout that period, or substantially all such expenses

other than those directly incidental to a particular voyage

30

or to the employment of the ship during that period.

                                             For the purposes of this sub-paragraph a person is “responsible” if

he is responsible as principal or if he appoints another person,

other than the lessee or a person connected with the lessee, to be

responsible in his place.

35

                           (3)                  The second case is where—

                      (a)                     the ship is chartered out to another person (“the charterer”)

because of short-term over-capacity,

                      (b)                     the person chartering out the ship does so in the course of

a trade that consists of or includes operating ships, and

40

                      (c)                     the conditions in sub-paragraph (4) are met.

                           (4)                  Those conditions are—

                      (a)                     that the period of the charter does not exceed three years,

and there is no provision or agreement under which it

could be extended beyond three years;

45

 

 

Finance Bill
Schedule 33 — Insurance companies

    373

 

                      (b)                     that the period of the charter, together with any other

periods in the same five years during which the ship is

chartered out to the charterer or a person connected with

him, does not exceed three years in total;

                      (c)                     that neither the charterer nor any person connected with

5

him has an option to purchase the ship.

                           (5)                  In sub-paragraph (4)(b)—

                      (a)                     the reference to any other periods during which the ship is

chartered out does not include any period during which it

is chartered out under a lease entered into before 19th

10

December 2002;

                      (b)                     “the same five years” means any period of five years that

includes the period of the charter mentioned in that sub-

paragraph.

                           (6)                  References in this paragraph to the period of a charter are to the

15

term specified in the lease or, if longer, the actual period during

which the ship is chartered.

                           (7)                  Section 839 of the Taxes Act 1988 (connected persons) applies for

the purposes of this paragraph.”.

          (3)      Paragraph 93(1) of that Schedule (certificates required to support claim by

20

lessor) has effect as if after paragraph (a) there were inserted—

                      “(aa)                        that the lease is such that, by virtue of paragraph 89A

(exception for ordinary charters), paragraph 89(1) does not

apply, or”.

  5        In paragraphs 3 and 4 “lease” means any arrangements that provide for a

25

ship to be leased or otherwise made available by one person to another.

Schedule 33

Section 169

 

Insurance companies

Case I profits

  1       (1)      For section 82 of the Finance Act 1989 (c. 26) (calculation of profits of

30

insurance company in respect of life assurance business when computed in

accordance with provisions applicable to Case I of Schedule D) substitute—

       “82            Calculation of profits: bonuses etc

              (1)             This section and sections 82A and 82B below have effect where the

profits of an insurance company in respect of its life assurance

35

business are, for the purposes of the Taxes Act 1988, computed in

accordance with the provisions of that Act applicable to Case I of

Schedule D.

              (2)             Any amounts which are allocated to policy holders or annuitants in

respect of a period of account are allowed as a deduction in

40

calculating the profits for the period of account.

              (3)             For the purposes of subsection (2) above, an amount is allocated to

policy holders or annuitants if (but only if)—

 

 

Finance Bill
Schedule 33 — Insurance companies

    374

 

                    (a)                   bonus payments are made to them,

                    (b)                   reversionary bonuses are declared in their favour, or

                    (c)                   a reduction is made in the premiums payable by them.

              (4)             Where an amount is allocated to policy holders or annuitants for the

purposes of subsection (2) above, the amount of the allocation is—

5

                    (a)                   in the case of bonus payments, the amount of the payments,

                    (b)                   in the case of declared reversionary bonuses, the amount of

the liabilities assumed by the company in consequence of the

declaration, and

                    (c)                   in the case of a reduction in premiums, the amount of the

10

liabilities assumed by the company in consequence of the

reduction.

       82A            Calculation of profits: policy holders’ tax

              (1)             Tax expended on behalf of policy holders or annuitants is allowed as

a deduction in calculating the profits to the extent (but only to the

15

extent) that regulations made by the Treasury so provide.

              (2)             The regulations may include provision for tax so expended to be so

allowed even if it is not brought into account.

              (3)             The regulations—

                    (a)                   may make different provision for different cases, and

20

                    (b)                   may include provision having effect in relation to periods of

account during which they are made.

       82B            Unappropriated surplus on valuation

              (1)             This section applies in relation to a period of account of an insurance

company (“the period of account in question”) where—

25

                    (a)                   at the end of the period of account in question the company

has an unappropriated surplus on valuation as shown in the

return deposited with the Financial Services Authority under

section 9.6 of the Prudential Sourcebook (Insurers) (an

“unappropriated surplus”), and

30

                    (b)                   the company has not made an election in accordance with

Rule 4.1(6) of the Prudential Sourcebook (Insurers) covering

the period of account in question.

              (2)             Where the company did not have an unappropriated surplus at the

end of the period of account immediately preceding the period of

35

account in question, so much of the unappropriated surplus at the

end of the period of account in question as is required to meet the

duty of fairness is allowed as a deduction in calculating the profits

for the period of account in question.

              (3)             Where the company did have an unappropriated surplus at the end

40

of that immediately preceding period of account—

                    (a)                   if so much of the unappropriated surplus at the end of the

period of account in question as is required to meet the duty

of fairness exceeds so much of the unappropriated surplus at

the end of that immediately preceding period of account as

45

was required to meet that duty, the excess is allowed as a

 

 

Finance Bill
Schedule 33 — Insurance companies

    375

 

deduction in calculating the profits for the period of account

in question, but

                    (b)                   if so much of the unappropriated surplus at the end of that

immediately preceding period of account as was required to

meet the duty of fairness exceeds so much of the

5

unappropriated surplus at the end of the period of account in

question as is required to meet that duty, the excess is to be

taken into account as a receipt of the period of account in

question.

              (4)             In arriving for the purposes of this section at the amount of the

10

unappropriated surplus which is or was required to meet the duty of

fairness there is to be deducted the aggregate of amounts which—

                    (a)                   for periods of account ending before 14th March 1989 (and

the first notional period of account, within the meaning of

section 82 above as originally enacted) have been excluded,

15

by virtue of section 433 of the Taxes Act 1988, as being

reserved for policy holders or annuitants, and

                    (b)                   have not before that date either been allocated to or expended

on behalf of policy holders or annuitants or been treated as

profits of an accounting period on ceasing to be so reserved.

20

              (5)             References in this section to the company’s duty of fairness are to the

company’s duty to treat its policy holders and annuitants fairly with

regard to terminal bonuses.”.

          (2)      In section 83A(1) of the Finance Act 1989 (c. 26) (meaning of “brought into

account”), for “83” substitute “82A”.

25

          (3)      In section 436(3)(a) of the Taxes Act 1988 (pension business: separate charge

on profits)—

              (a)             for “82 and 83” substitute “82 and 82B to 83AB”, and

              (b)             omit the words after “modifications”.

          (4)      In sections 439B(3)(a) and 441(4)(a) of the Taxes Act 1988 (life reinsurance

30

business and overseas life insurance business: separate charge on profits)—

              (a)             for “82(1), (2) and (4) and 83” substitute “82 and 82B to 83AB”, and

              (b)             omit “and in particular with the omission of the words “and any

amounts of tax which are expended on behalf of” in section 82(1)(a)”.

          (5)      This paragraph has effect for periods of account beginning on or after 1st

35

January 2003.

          (6)      In relation to the first period of account of an insurance company beginning

on or after that date, section 82B of the Finance Act 1989 (inserted by sub-

paragraph (1)) applies as if the references in it to so much of the

unappropriated surplus at the end of the immediately preceding period of

40

account as was required to meet the company’s duty of fairness were to any

amount included in the closing liabilities of the period of account by virtue

of section 82(1)(b) of that Act as originally enacted.

  2       (1)      Section 83 of the Finance Act 1989 (receipts etc to be taken into account in

Case I computations) is amended as follows.

45

 

 

Finance Bill
Schedule 33 — Insurance companies

    376

 

          (2)      For subsection (2) substitute—

              “(2)                There shall be taken into account as receipts of a period of account

amounts (so far as referable to that business) brought into account for

the period of account as—

                    (a)                   investment income receivable before deduction of tax,

5

                    (b)                   an increase in the value of non-linked assets,

                    (c)                   an increase in the value of linked assets, or

                    (d)                   other income;

                              and if amounts (so far as so referable) are brought into account for a

period of account as a decrease in the value of non-linked assets or a

10

decrease in the value of linked assets they shall be taken into account

as an expense of the period of account.

              (2A)                But subsection (2) above does not require to be taken into account as

receipts of a period of account so much of the amounts brought into

account as mentioned paragraphs (a) to (d) of that subsection for the

15

period of account as—

                    (a)                   is entirely notional because an amount corresponding to it

would fall to be brought into account as an expense (for that

or any other period of account),

                    (b)                   is exempted by section 444AC(2) of the Taxes Act 1988

20

(transfers of business), or

                    (c)                   consists of interest paid under section 826 of the Taxes Act

1988 (interest on tax overpaid) in respect of a repayment or

payment relating to an accounting period of the company

ending before 1st July 1999;

25

                              but, subject to that, the whole of the amounts so brought into account

for a period of account shall be taken into account as receipts of the

period of account.

              (2B)                If any assets of the company’s long-term insurance fund are

transferred by the company in a period of account so that they cease

30

to be assets of that fund, but the transfer is not brought into account

as part of total expenditure for the period of account, the fair value

of the assets at the time of the transfer shall be deemed to be brought

into account for the period of account as an increase in the value of

the assets of that fund unless the assets are excluded from this

35

subsection by—

                    (a)                   subsection (2C) or (2D) below, or

                    (b)                   section 444AD of the Taxes Act 1988 (transfers of business).

              (2C)                Assets transferred to discharge liabilities in respect of deposits

received from reinsurers or arising out of insurance operations,

40

debenture loans or amounts borrowed from credit institutions are

included in subsection (2B) above only if the deposits, loans or

amounts borrowed—

                    (a)                   were brought into account for the period of account, but

                    (b)                   were not taken into account as receipts of the period of

45

account under subsection (2) above.

              (2D)                Assets are excluded from subsection (2B) above if they are

transferred for at least their fair value and the consideration for their

 

 

Finance Bill
Schedule 33 — Insurance companies

    377

 

transfer, when received, forms part of the company’s long-term

insurance fund.”.

          (3)      In subsection (3)—

              (a)             for “that business in a case where an amount is” substitute “its life

assurance business in a case where assets are”,

5

              (b)             after “taken into account” insert “under subsection (2) above”, and

              (c)             for “that fund within subsection (2)(b) above” substitute “the long-

term insurance fund”.

          (4)      In subsection (4), for paragraph (c) substitute—

                    “(c)                      represents so much of the proceeds of the disposal of an asset

10

of the long-term insurance fund as does not exceed its fair

value or an asset acquired for at least its fair value which is

added to that fund.”.

          (5)      In subsection (5), omit paragraph (b) and the word “but” before it.

          (6)      In subsection (6)(c), omit “unless the reinsurer under the contract falls within

15

section 439A of the Taxes Act 1988 (pure reinsurance)”.

          (7)      Subsection (8) is amended as follows.

          (8)      After the definition of “demutualisation” insert—

               ““fair value”, in relation to assets, means the amount which would be

obtained from an independent person purchasing them or, if the

20

assets are money, its amount;”.

          (9)      In the definition of “total reinsurance”, omit “before the making of the

contract of reinsurance (or, in a case where there are two or more contracts

of reinsurance, the last of them)”.

          (10)     In the sidenote, for “brought” substitute “taken”.

25

          (11)              Sub-paragraph (6) has effect in relation to contracts of reinsurance made on

or after 9th April 2003; and sub-paragraph (9) has effect in relation to

reinsurance effected by a single contract made on or after that date or by two

or more contracts each of which is made on or after that day.

          (12)     But, subject to that, this paragraph has effect for periods of account

30

beginning on or after 1st January 2003.

  3       (1)      In the Finance Act 1989 (c. 26), after section 83 insert—

       “83ZA Contingent loans

              (1)             For the purposes of this section a contingent loan is made to an

insurance company if—

35

                    (a)                   a deposit is received by the company from a reinsurer or

arises out of insurance operations of the company,

                    (b)                   a debenture loan is made to the company, or

                    (c)                   an amount is borrowed by the company from a credit

institution,

40

                              and the deposit, debenture loan or amount borrowed is taken into

account as a receipt of the company under section 83(2) above.

              (2)             For the purposes of this section the time when a contingent loan is

made to an insurance company is the time when the assets

constituting the deposit, debenture loan or amount borrowed are

45

received by the company.

 

 

 
previous section contents continue
 
House of Commons home page Houses of Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries

© Parliamentary copyright 2003
Revised 16 April 2003