Previous Section Index Home Page


3 Jul 2003 : Column 469W—continued

Northern Ireland Police Board

David Burnside: To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what the cost is of retaining the consultants PriceWaterhouseCoopers by the Northern Ireland Police Board; and how many independent assessors have been appointed by PriceWaterhouseCoopers in their work for the Police Board in establishing District Police Partnerships. [123362]

Jane Kennedy: The sum to date paid to PriceWaterhouseCoopers for the recruitment exercise for District Policing Partnerships is £555,769.

PriceWaterhouseCoopers appointed 18 independent observers to assist in the appointment of the independent members of District Policing Partnerships.

Private Care Organisations

Mrs. Iris Robinson: To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what plans he has to simplify the process of negotiating contracts and funding for private care organisations involved in rehabilitation and management of debilitating illness. [116373]

Angela Smith: It is the responsibility of the health and social services boards and trusts at operational level to negotiate and agree contracts for the provision of residential and domiciliary care by the independent sector. To assist in this process, the four Board Chief Executives have established a regional group to make recommendations on the appropriate fee levels for care in residential and nursing homes. Recommendations on residential and nursing home fees are based on the level of need across each of the programmes of care. In each of the last three years, the recommendations of the regional group have been endorsed by the Department and accepted as the agreed regional rates by the four boards. Rates for domiciliary care provision are currently negotiated at board and trust level with independent sector providers.

Private Office Costs

Mr. Flight: To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what the running costs have been of Ministers' private offices in his Department in each year since 1997. [123109]

Mr. Paul Murphy: This question was put to all Northern Ireland Departments; however, we are replying only in relation to the Northern Ireland Office.

The Northern Ireland Office incurred the following running costs, in relation to Ministers' private offices:

£

Running costs
2003–04(28)128,164
2002–031,610,821
2001–021,127,731
2000–011,155,931
1999–20001,270,185
1998–991,294,715
1997–98974,242

(28) To end May 2003.


3 Jul 2003 : Column 470W

Real IRA

Mr. Dodds: To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what recent assessment has been undertaken of (a) the capacity of the Real IRA to manufacture bombs and (b) whether the Real IRA is receiving co-operation from the Provisional IRA. [122642]

Jane Kennedy: The bombs intercepted recently in Londonderry and the explosives find near Dundalk in the Republic of Ireland clearly demonstrates that dissidents have the capacity to manufacture bombs. While dissidents remain a threat to the peace process, the security forces on both sides of the border continue to disrupt, intercept or thwart their operations through good intelligence-led policing and covert operations. The Government's security advice is that PIRA remains on ceasefire and supports the peace process.

Saville Inquiry

Lady Hermon: To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if he will make a statement on the costs of the Saville Inquiry as of 30 June, broken down by legal fees paid to individual barristers acting for (a) the Ministry of Defence and (b) families of the victims. [123456]

Mr. Spellar: Up to end June 2003 the cash spend by the Northern Ireland Office on the Bloody Sunday Inquiry was a total of £89.2 million. Out of this amount £7.962 million has been spent on the payment of fees to counsel representing the families or the Northern Ireland Civil Rights Association. These figures are set out in the table and include VAT, where that is paid, and in most cases, expenses as well as fees.

The fees of Ministry of Defence counsel are a matter for my right hon. friend the Secretary of State for Defence.

Payments made (£)Period coveredFromTo
Senior counsel representing the families(29)
Lord Gifford553,062October 1998January 2003
Arthur Harvey767,362July 1998January 2003
Michael Lavery435,024November 2000December 2002
B. J. MacDonald(30)513,755September 1998September 2002
P. T. MacDonald(31)65,800April 1998June 1999
Michael Mansfield457,261March 1999November 2002
Elish McDermott105,309March 2000June 2001
Seamus Treacy(32)600,492March 1998December 2002
Eoin McGonigal82,446October 2000June 2002
Senior counsel representing NICRA
Sir Louis Blom-Cooper306,541December 2000October 2002
Junior counsel representing the families(33)
John Coyle272,473September 1999January 2003
Fiona Doherty193,824October 2000October 2002
Ciaran Harvey349,105December 2000December 2002
Richard Harvey331,733October 2000August 2002
Brian Kennedy546,694July 1999March 2003
Philip Magee(34)83,175June 1998September 2000
Kieran Mallon658,899March 1999May 2003
Brian McCartney640,261July 1998April 2003
Karen Quinlivan179,147March 1999December 2001
Patricia Smyth(35)328,719October 1998June 2002
Mary McHugh123,972February 2002October 2002
Michael Topolski(36)139,940November 2000June 2001
Junior counsel representing NICRA
Paddy O'Hanlon227,728November 2000October 2002

(29) In addition, the following senior counsel have represented/are representing some of the families but have yet to submit fee claims: Kevin Finnegan and Reg Weir.

(30) Left the case (as a junior) in September 2000 and rejoined the case (as a senior) July 2001.

(31) Left the case June 1999.

(32) Having started as a junior in March 1998, became a senior counsel in September 2000.

(33) In addition, the following junior counsel have represented/are representing some of the families but have yet to submit fee claims: Tom McCreanor and Declan Morgan.

(34) Left the case September 2000.

(35) Left the case June 2002.

(36) Left the case June 2001.


3 Jul 2003 : Column 471W

Senior Citizens

Mr. Peter Robinson: To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland how many senior citizens over the age of 65 in Northern Ireland have taken up the opportunity to hold concessionary travel passes, broken down by parliamentary constituency. [121083]

Mr. Spellar: The following table shows the take up of senior citizens Smartpasses by Northern Ireland parliamentary constituency as at October 2002. The total number of senior Smartpasses in circulation as of 23 June 2003 was 158,156. However, to disaggregate this figure by parliamentary constituency could be undertaken only at disproportionate cost.

ConstituencyEstimated number of Smartpasses
Belfast East10,947
Belfast North10,325
Belfast South9,389
Belfast West7,060
East Antrim8,247
East Londonderry6,741
Fermanagh and South Tyrone6,014
Foyle6,508
Lagan Valley9,164
Mid Ulster4,670
Newry and Armagh6,912
North Antrim7,811
North Down10,263
South Antrim8,011
South Down7,684
Strangford8,816
Upper Bann8,738
West Tyrone5,249
Total142,549

Targeted Benefits

Mr. Peter Robinson: To ask the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland what research has been commissioned

3 Jul 2003 : Column 472W

to ascertain the reasons for the variations in take-up of targeted benefits; and if he will make a statement on the findings. [122551]

Mr. Spellar: The Department for Social Development has commissioned no research to ascertain individuals' reasons for claiming or not claiming targeted benefits. It has, however, commissioned research to estimate the level of benefit take-up and to establish the extent to which there is variation in that level and to determine factors which appear to be contributing to such variations. The research commissioned was to estimate the take-up of income support and jobseeker's allowance (income based) in Northern Ireland, and the results of the research were published in May 2002.

The findings of the research published in 2002 indicated that:


In addition, the Social Security Agency has commissioned research to investigate the degree of variation in take-up of disability living allowance, both within Northern Ireland and between Northern Ireland and Great Britain. This work is in progress.


Next Section Index Home Page