Select Committee on Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Appendices to the Minutes of Evidence


APPENDIX 4

Memorandum submitted by Staffordshire Local Education Authority (T4)

STANDARDS FUND 509 THE SMALL SCHOOL FUND

BACKGROUND

  1.  Following a review of education provision and organisation, a major school closure programme took place in the 1980's. Staffordshire's remaining rural schools are considered essential to their community.

  2.  Staffordshire's policy is to review schools with less than 25 pupils. There are no proposals to close small rural schools. The LEA is currently undertaking a phased review of education provision and organisation in each District.

LEA FINANCE AND SUPPORT FOR SMALL SCHOOLS

  3.  The LEA's funding formula provides significant additional finance for small schools with less than 50 pupils.

  4.  The LEA's own small school fund replaces the 1986 DfE Grant to support small school collaboration. The fund, now £76,000, continues to sustain and extend collaborative arrangements and cluster activities. The fund currently supports 66 schools with less than 100 pupils, organised in 17 clusters.

  5.  Clusters are allocated funds through an agreed formula consisting of a base budget and a banding system, weighted in favour of the smaller schools, as follows:

      Cluster base budget—£504

      Under 50 pupils—£688

      50 to 70 pupils—£516

      70 to 90 pupils—£344

      90 to100 pupils—£258

  6.  Clusters nominate co-ordinators to manage cluster budgets and co-ordinate cluster activities. Co-ordinators meet each term. The LEA Inspector or Adviser for Small Schools chairs meetings. A separate committee organises the annual conference.

  7.  Cluster Development plans focus on leadership and management; curriculum and staff development; pupils shared and enrichment activities; governors, parents and the community.

  8.  The fund also supports development projects, pilot initiatives and attendance at the LEA Primary and Small School Conferences.

  TSF 33/36—2000-01 and SF 509 The Small School Fund—2000-02 and 2002-03

  9.  Extracts from 2001-02 Standards Fund Document

    "The Secretary of State intends to use the Standards Fund to support small schools, both to provide extra funding from which they can meet proportionally higher administrative and other costs, and also to encourage the development of innovative approaches to collaboration to raise standards and reduce burdens. The two predecessor grants, (TSF 33 and TSF 36), will be merged in a new schools fund which will enable both objectives to be met, and allowing greater flexibility at local level (including in the definition of thresholds for flexibility). LEAs and schools will be encouraged to develop consortium approaches with schools in neighbouring LEAs where relevant, and to share successful ideas via the website." Paragraph 26 (Page 8)

    "This fund, which merges the two predecessor Standard Fund grants supporting small schools, will be allocated to LEAs by a formula based on the number of schools with no more than 200 pupils on roll (primary and secondary) or 600 pupils (secondary), and an allowance for nursery school and PRUs. LEAs may retain up to 2.5% (subject to a maximum of £15,000) to fund their own costs in developing innovative projects and evaluating and disseminating good practice. The balance should be devolved to schools in two parts. The first (at least 75% of devolved funds) is to support the proportionately higher cost to small schools of administrative staff, supply cover and other support for teachers. The second is intended to enable LEAs to develop with their small schools a programme of innovative approaches to joint working targeted at improving educational standards and improving efficiency of management and administration". Paragraph 10 (Page 25)

  10.  The LEA regards innovation, collaboration and networking as essential to achieving sustainable, lasting change. Encouraging clusters of schools and groups of headteachers and teachers to work and learn together towards shared goals, effectively improves provision for all pupils and raises overall standards.

  11.  In the financial year 2000-01 the LEA elected to further support small schools by participating in the matched funding arrangements of TSF Grants 33 and 36 and subsequently SF 509 the Small School Fund.

  12.  Current matched funding for administrative support and collaborative initiatives is £1,640,000.

  13.  Funds are devolved within the prescribed criteria. Establishments include Pupil

Referral Units, Special, First, Primary and Middle Schools. The administrative element, £1,219,000, is distributed equally, with the exception of PRU's. The element for collaborative initiatives, £406,020, is distributed through a banded formula weighted in favour of the smaller schools, as follows:

      Under 50 pupils—£3,350

      Under 100 pupils—£2,260

      Under 200 pupils—£1,720

  14.  The LEA retains £14,700, permitted within the criteria.

  15.  Retained funding enables the LEA to sustain two very significant initiatives. The first is the appointment of an experienced small school headteacher as Small School Adviser. The second is the release of £36,000 from the LEA's small school fund to finance a wide range of developments. These include pilot initiatives, networking, CPD activities, the Small School Conference and part funding of the appointment of the Adviser for Small Schools.

PERFORMANCE INDICATORS

  16.  The following performance indicators were included within the LEA's Education Development Plan to support small schools.

  Collaborative activities:

    —  the LEA continues to provide additional funding for small schools;

    —  the LEA appoints a seconded headteacher as Adviser for Small Schools;

    —  schools are aware of opportunities and good practice within collaboration;

    —  support for small school clusters continues;

    —  cluster budgets are agreed through consultation;

    —  cluster co-ordinators administer cluster budgets, co-ordinate cluster activity and submit development plans;

    —  collaborative activities support leadership and management, joint planning, curriculum support, extension and enrichment activities and new initiatives;

    —  termly meetings of cluster co-ordinators are well attended;

    —  minutes and cluster reports are distributed;

    —  activities and expenditure are monitored; and

    —  SATs data indicates pupil attainment in small schools compares favourably with all schools.

  Conferences:

    —  headteachers are consulted;

    —  a conference working group is established;

    —  conference objectives support management and attainment in small schools;

    —  conference is well attended; and

    —  evaluations are analysed, inform contributors and future planning.

  17.  The above, together with examples of activities and initiatives contained within the following sections, relate to the role of the adviser for small schools, pilot projects, networking and conferences. Together with the summary, these reflect both the range of LEA support, and good practice.

THE ROLE OF THE SMALL SCHOOLS ADVISER

  18.  The post of full-time Small School Adviser was established in January 2001. The Adviser is based within the LEA's CPD team.

  19.  The role is to support and extend collaborative and innovative practice within existing small school clusters, and to share, encourage and develop good practice within the 194 schools receiving matched funding through the Standards Fund.

  The developing role of the small school adviser includes:

    —  termly meetings with the Cluster Co-ordinators of 17 small school clusters;

    —  monitoring and evaluating Cluster Development plans and SF 509 Action plans;

    —  regular school visits for support and development activities;

    —  initiation of innovative pilot projects;

    —  providing opportunities for county and country-wide networking;

    —  developing closer links with LEA "statistical neighbours" and input at conferences;

    —  involvement in National College for School Leadership initiatives for small schools;

    —  establishment of the Staffordshire small school web site;

    —  planning the annual Staffordshire Small School Conference;

    —  ensuring local and national initiatives are offered appropriately to small school headteachers; and

    —  offering key ideas, values, vision for the future which can make effective impact on small school provision.

SUPPORT FOR SMALL SCHOOL CLUSTERS

  20.  For the smallest schools, with less than 100 pupils, SF 509 funding is essential for effective collaboration. Only in exceptional circumstances do these schools vire funding to balance their budgets. For example, to maintain staffing.

  21.  SF 509 has enabled more funding to be directed towards strategic developments focussing on the quality of leadership and management, and teaching and learning.

  22.  Opportunities for pupils to extend and enrich their learning remain a strong element in cluster collaboration.

  23.  The most successful initiatives are those where small school clusters have combined LEA and SF 509 funding. Initiatives include joint appointments of specialist teachers in ICT and art, and supply teachers to release co-ordinators to fulfil their roles within a cluster.

PILOT PROJECTS

  24.  Pilot projects are funded through the LEA's small school fund. The current allocation is £14,000 for specific innovative, collaborative projects including:

    —  appointment of a joint bursar for a cluster to seek out and bid for grants and sponsorship to offer an enhanced curriculum and lighten the workload;

    —  appointment of a joint PDC for a cluster to build professional development into the Cluster development plan as a natural part of the self review and performance management cycle;

    —  development of common mixed age planning formats, linked to a Beacon School project, and available through the small school web site;

    —  planning and providing professional development for aspiring acting headteachers in small schools;

    —  planning and providing subject leadership training for a group of small schools;

    —  developing projects with First and Middle schools to support pupil transfer;

    —  facilitating a new arts curriculum project for the small feeder schools of a High School with Specialist Arts Status;

    —  developing cluster activities for Gifted and Talented pupils;

    —  strengthening aspects of "confederation" within clusters;

    —  advising and supporting the successful bid for the "Network Learning Community" by ten small schools in two clusters from the north and south of the Staffordshire. This national project, using ICT as a vehicle, aims to initiate effective, innovative, creative leadership at all levels, and to raise standards and enhance learning opportunities by working and learning together. The project attracts £50,000 for three years. Funding is matched by the schools.

NETWORKING

  25.  The LEA small school fund provides £4,000 to fully fund networking opportunities offered to small school staff. Networking enables the sharing of best practice and informs cluster and individual school future developments. Staff are invited to attend specific networking sessions in nominated schools across Staffordshire. Each term the Networking Officer designs a programme.

  26.  One example is the opportunity provided for teachers to observe the use of an interactive whiteboard in a Beacon School. The Beacon School supported a small school to purchase and install a whiteboard. This will be used to support teacher development within and beyond the cluster, enabling others in small schools to recognise the latest ICT developments and the financial implications.

  27.  Networking is effectively established with the East Midlands Advisory Small School Group and the LEA's statistical neighbours. Regular meetings and conferences have allowed innovation to be shared much more widely. Networking and collaboration between schools across the Counties is also developing.

THE PRIMARY AND SMALL SCHOOL CONFERENCES

  27.  The LEA's small school fund provides £8,000 to support Primary and Small School Conferences.

  28.  The fund finances the organisation of the Small School Conference and the attendance Headteachers of schools with fewer than 100 pupils. The conference is now extended to all schools under 200 pupils receiving SF 509. All delegates pay a conference fee.

  29.  Each small school cluster attending the residential Primary Conference funds a representative Headteacher.

SUMMARY

  31.  The LEA has combined its own small school fund with the SF 509 Small School Fund. This has enabled the LEA to:

    —  appoint an Adviser for Small Schools;

    —  sustain and develop established small school cluster activity;

    —  establish new clusters;

    —  share good practice through collaboration and conferences;

    —  establish and finance development groups and pilot initiatives; and

    —  extend networking between LEA schools and other LEAs including statistical neighbours.

  32.  Monitoring of SF 509 indicates that out of 194 schools, 150, (78%), have action plans for collaborative activities.

  33.  Section 10 Ofsted Inspection Reports confirm effective collaborative activity.

  34.  Data analysis indicates small school KS1 and KS2 SATs results compare favourably with LEA schools.

  35.  Headteachers recognise the valuable impact and opportunity provided through the combination of LEA funding and SF 509 matched funding. Funding is seen as a key element.

  36.  Effective and creative leadership is vital to the success of innovative collaborative initiatives. The role of the Small School Adviser is essential to sustaining, developing, and extending good practice.

13 January 2003


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2003
Prepared 5 June 2003