Select Committee on Health Minutes of Evidence


Examination of Witnesses (Questions 80-83)

THURSDAY 6 MARCH 2003

PROFESSOR LESLEY REGAN, MS LYNNE PACANOWSKI, MS CATHERINE ECCLES, MS BETTY LARKIN, MS KAY BARBER, MS SELENE DALY AND MS CATHY ROGERS

Andy Burnham

  80. I suspect breastfeeding rates vary quite a lot across the country. In Warrington it is the exception rather than the norm, the majority were not breastfeeding. What do you think is the biggest driver of changing behaviour? I think the fact that it is cheaper and more convenient, but I do not think that people are getting that message. They seem to fixate on the negatives.
  (Ms Pacanowski) I think the message starts when they are nine and 10 years old, maybe even earlier. It is what they are used to, what they are exposed to and what is normal for them. By the time they become teenagers they have probably made up their minds what they are going to do.

  81. Is that right? Do you not think it is something they decide during pregnancy?
  (Ms Pacanowski) Then there are three big areas which will change their minds about it. One is during the antenatal period when it is addressed all the time. Then on the labour ward where they have that skin to skin contact for a certain period. Then having the support postnatally. If you are really strapped for staff you cannot give that time.

  82. They get frustrated and give up.
  (Ms Daly) We do get literature nowadays but it is often the case that people do not read it. That is true in any walk of life. I saw that there was a huge backing of breastfeeding. It is very openly mentioned and you are made fully aware of it. It is very well supported by the midwives. Sometimes it is just verbal praise, telling the mother about the baby being better protected because of the antibodies. That is far better than a leaflet. Word of mouth is much stronger and that is endorsed by the midwives in this particular unit. I think that is one of the reasons why more of the women do it.
  (Ms Larkin) I agree with everything that has been said but I would like to say that we do not provide milk for the babies. A lot of units do. We do not have milk on the premises. They have to bring the milk in with them if they want to use it.

  83. Do some units give birth packs out from a chemist that have formula milk. I am pretty sure we had one of those once.
  (Ms Pacanowski) I would say that has been outlawed everywhere.
  (Ms Rogers) My final point relates to the comment that was made something like at the birth centre we

had so many midwives and it seemed a bit much. I have to say, when we look at the ratio of midwives to women it was based on the recommendation of the Audit Commission of 1:34.

  Chairman: Can I thank you all. You have given us a very good start to this inquiry. We will obviously be bringing this all together in a report which I hope will improve maternity services across the country. Thank you very much.





 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2003
Prepared 18 June 2003