Previous SectionIndexHome Page


Landfill Sites

14. Mrs. Patsy Calton (Cheadle) (LD): What steps are being taken to tackle the effects of pollution from landfill sites. [152877]

The Minister for Rural Affairs and Local Environmental Quality (Alun Michael): There are strict controls on landfill sites aimed at preventing or reducing any negative impact on the environment. In the spring, we will publish a review of the environmental and health effects of waste management, which brings together existing literature and evidence on the health and environmental effects of waste management, and will provide a valuable side-by-side comparison of different waste management options.

Mrs. Calton : I thank the Minister for his response. Will he consider keeping a register of all sites containing materials harmful to human health, and make it a criminal offence to withhold information, whatever the source, about the tipping of such materials, either now or in the past?

Alun Michael: I am not sure what examples the hon. Lady is pointing to that are not already covered by controls on tipping. As she will understand, we are doing our best both to get a proper fix on the health impact and reduce the UK's reliance on landfill. If she has specific examples that she would like to draw to my attention one of my ministerial colleagues or I would be happy to respond.

Norman Baker (Lewes) (LD): The Minister said that there are strict controls on landfill, but is he aware that in 2002 there were 285 major landfill pollution incidents? Only one in 200 incidents resulted in a fine for the operator, averaging just £6,000, which is a pittance to landfill operators. Is not the message from the Government that the polluter does not pay, and what is the Minister going to do about it?

Alun Michael: I have just suggested that we want a better informed understanding of the environmental effects of waste management and a reduction in the UK's reliance on landfill. The figures that the hon. Gentleman referred to are a matter of concern, and I can assure him that they are kept under review both by DEFRA and the Environment Agency.

5 Feb 2004 : Column 899

Operation Gangmaster

15. Mr. Peter Luff (Mid-Worcestershire) (Con): If she will make a statement on her Department's involvement in Operation Gangmaster. [152879]

The Minister for Rural Affairs and Local Environmental Quality (Alun Michael): DEFRA staff are involved when required in Operation Gangmaster activities, on which the Department for Work and Pensions takes the lead.

Mr. Luff: The Minister will know that there is concern that Operation Gangmaster is not an effective mechanism to deal with the activities of rogue gangmasters. Could he tell the House whether the Government intend to support the Gangmasters

5 Feb 2004 : Column 900

(Licensing) Bill, which is due for its Second Reading on Friday 27 February, or do they prefer more effective enforcement of the current regulatory regime? If it is the latter, they must put more effort into doing so.

Alun Michael: Results are coming out of the work. For example, the Department for Work and Pensions identified 235 overpayments and 1,023 adjustments to benefit worth £405,000, securing 138 sanctions and prosecutions. Figures show that the Inland Revenue's success in relation to unpaid tax and national insurance is worth £4.3 million. Steps are being taken that are producing results. However, I recognise hon. Members' interest in taking further measures to deal with gangmasters, and we are carefully considering, with colleagues in other Departments, the private Member's Bill to which the hon. Gentleman referred.

5 Feb 2004 : Column 901

Business of the House

12.30 pm

Mr. Oliver Heald (North-East Hertfordshire) (Con): Will the Leader of the House please give us the business for next week?

The Leader of the House of Commons (Mr. Peter Hain): The business for next week will be as follows:

Monday 9 February—Second Reading of the Scottish Parliament (Constituencies) Bill.

Tuesday 10 February—Opposition Day [4th Allotted Day]. There will be a debate entitled "The State of the Environment" followed by a debate on local taxation. Both debates arise on a motion in the name of the Liberal Democrats.

Wednesday 11 February—Motion to approve the Northern Ireland Arms Decommissioning Act 1997 (Amnesty Period) Order 2004 followed by Opposition half-day [5th Allotted Day] (1st Part). There will be half-day debate entitled "Confusion Over the Powers of the Proposed Elected Regional Assemblies" on an Opposition motion.

Thursday 12 February—Motion to approve a money resolution on the Sustainable and Secure Buildings Bill followed by a motion to take note of the outstanding reports of the Public Accounts Committee to which the Government have replied. Details will be given in the Official Report.

The provisional business for the week after the half term week will be:

Monday 23 February—Second Reading of a Bill.

Tuesday 24 February—Motions relating the Draft Social Security Benefits Up-Rating Order 2004 and the Draft Guaranteed Minimum Pensions Increase Order 2004 followed by Opposition half-day [5th Allotted Day] (2nd Part). There will be a half-day debate on an Opposition motion. Subject to be announced.

Wednesday 25 February—Debate on the Report from the Privy Counsellor Review Committee on the Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001.

Thursday 26 February—Motion to approve a money resolution on the Employment Relations Bill followed by a debate on Welsh affairs on a motion for the Adjournment of the House.

Friday 27 February—Private Members' Bills.

Following is the information:

PAC REPORTS 2002–03

Report No Title of ReportPublication Date
1stCollecting the Television Licence Fee18 Dec. 2002
2ndDealing with Pollution from Ships9 Jan. 2003
3rdTobacco Smuggling10 Jan. 2003
4thPrivate Finance Initiative: Redevelopment of MOD main Building30 Jan. 2003
5thThe 2001 Outbreak of Foot and Mouth Disease14 March 2003
6thMinistry of Defence: Exercise Saif Sareea II12 March 2003
7thExcess Votes 2001–0219 March 2003
8thExcess Votes (Northern Ireland) 2001–0219 March 2003
9thThe Office for National Statistics: Outsourcing the 2001 Census26 March 2003
10thIndividual Learning Accounts4 April 2003
11thFacing the Challenge: NHS Emergency Planning in England16 April 2003
12thTackling Pension Poverty: Encouraging Take-up of Entitlements9 April 2003
13thMinistry of Defence: Progress in Reducing Stocks11 April 2003
14thRoyal Mint Trading Fund 2001–02 Accounts17 April 2003
15thOPRA: Tackling the Risks to Pension Scheme Members2 May 2003
16thImproving Public Services through Innovation: The Invest to Save Budget9 May 2003
17thHelping victims and witnesses: the work of Victim Support8 May 2003
18thReaping the Rewards of Agricultural Research16 May 2003
19thThe PFI contract for the redevelopment of West Middlesex University Hospital6 June 2003
20thBetter public services through call centres5 June 2003
21stThe operations of HM Customs and Excise in 2001–0212 June 2003
22ndPFI refinancing update13 June 2003
23rdInnovation in the NHS—the acquisition of the Heart Hospital18 June 2003
24thCommunity Legal Service:The Introduction of Contracting20 June 2003
25thProtecting the Public from Waste25 June 2003
26thSafety, quality, efficacy: regulating medicines in the UK26 June 2003
27thThe management of substitution cover for teachers26 June 2003
28thDelivering better value for money from the Private Finance Initiative19 June 2003
29thInland Revenue: Tax Credits and tax debt management2 July 2003
30thDepartment for International Development: Maximising impact in the Water Sector3 July 2003
31stReport Tackling Benefit Fraud4 July 2003
32ndThe Highways Agency: Maintaining England's Motorways and trunk roads11 July 2003
33rdEnsuring the effective discharge of older patients from NHS acute hospitals17 Sept. 2003
34thThe Office of Fair Trading: progress in protecting consumers' interests9 July 2003
35thPFI Construction Performance16 July 2003
36thImproving service quality: Action in response to the Inherited SERFS problem17 July 2003
37thMinistry of Defence: The Construction of nuclear submarine facilities at Devonport10 Sept. 2003
38thDepartment of Trade and Industry: Regulation of weights and measures10 July 2003
39thA safer place to work: Protecting NHS hospital and ambulance staff from violence and aggression23 July 2003
40thImproving social housing through transfer24 July 2003
41stModernising procurement in the Prison Service18 Sept. 2003
42ndA safer work place to work: Improving the management of health and safety risks to staff in NHS Trusts15 Oct. 2003
43rdFisheries enforcement in England13 Nov. 2003
44thNew IT Systems for Magistrates Courts: The Libra project11 Nov. 2003
45thProtecting public health and consumer interests in relation to food: the Food Standards Agency27 Nov. 2003
46thMinistry of Defence: Building an air manoeuvre capability: the introduction of the Apache Helicopter18 Nov. 2003
47thFilm Council: Improving access to, and education about, the moving image through the British Film Institute4 Dec. 2003
48thThe Public Private Partnership for National Air Traffic Services Ltd9 Dec. 2003
49thThe operational performance of PFI prisons2 Dec. 2003

5 Feb 2004 : Column 903


Next Section

IndexHome Page