Select Committee on Culture, Media and Sport Second Report


APPENDIX A

HM Treasury guidelines on PSA targets[74]

Each measure should be…

Relevant

Does the measure attempt to capture success in one of the organisation's objectives?
 
What does the measure tell you about how the organisation is performing?

Able to avoid perverse incentives

Does the measure encourage any unwanted behaviour? (For example not reporting mistakes)

 
Could you improve performance against the measure without improving performance in real life?

 
Does the measure allow innovation? For example, does the measure discourage changing the way a service is delivered?

Attributable

Can the measure be influenced by the organisation's actions?
 
Is it clear where accountability for the measure lies?

 
Is there an estimate of the degree to which the organisation affects the measure?

 
Could a SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Timed) target be set against the measure?


Well-defined

Can the measure be expressed clearly, so that it is easy to understand?
Does the measure have an unambiguous definition, so it can be collected consistently?

Timely

Does the measure provide information in time for action to be taken?
 
What's the lag between the event and information becoming available?
 
Does the measure provide information frequently enough to track changes and take actions?

Reliable

Is the performance measure accurate enough for its use?

 
Has the measure been checked by appropriate specialists? (for example statisticians, social researchers, accountants or scientists)
 
Is the measure responsive to change? Will it show significant changes in performance? Will the measure change because of random 'noise' rather than actual performance?


Comparable

Does the measure allow comparison with past performance?
 
Does the measure allow comparison with other organisations delivering a similar service?


Verifiable

Given the documentation could an objective outsider come up with the same results?

 
Does documentation exist so that the process behind the measure can be validated?




74   http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2004
Prepared 2 March 2004