Select Committee on Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Minutes of Evidence


Examination of Witnesses (Questions 140-142)

20 APRIL 2004

MR ANDY CLEMENTS AND MR TOM TEW

  Q140 Paddy Tipping: And you think that if you have got that you can make environmental savings of between three and four million pounds?

  Mr Clements: The figures in our evidence demonstrate that, if you get the right regulation base, even at a conservative estimate (and we are somewhere in the middle of that spectrum of no effective regulation to the most perfect regulation) we would end up with three or four million pounds' savings.

  Q141 Paddy Tipping: But how are you going to take that forward with the Moorland Association?

  Mr Clements: We will continue to do as we are doing now. I do not believe it is the right thing either to characterise our relationship with the Moorland Association as a wholly adversarial one.

  Q142 Paddy Tipping: I did not say that. I said it was a spat.

  Mr Clements: I did not mean to suggest that you said that. Others might. A spat is what it is and what you do with a spat is sit down and talk around it and sort things out and I do believe that is what is happening with the Moorland Association. I would say that English Nature is recognising as well that we have not always done things in the best way possible as far as moorland owners are concerned in the past and we are being very careful to review, for example, our own consenting mechanisms, the fact that when owners want to burn sites they have to ask us about that and we consent that. We are reviewing that as our side of the bargain about doing something positive towards achieving a better relationship with owners.

  Paddy Tipping: That is very helpful.

  Chairman: Gentlemen, thank you very much for answering our questions this afternoon. You have already offered us some additional information which we have gratefully received and if there is anything else which on reflection you wish you had said then please do write to us and we will look at that with interest as well. Thank you very much.





 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2004
Prepared 15 July 2004