Select Committee on European Scrutiny Ninth Report


30 Access to gas transmission networks

(25196)

16260/03

COM(03)741

Draft Regulation on conditions for access to the gas transmission networks

Legal baseArticle 95 EC; co-decision; QMV
Document originated10 December 2003
Deposited in Parliament22 December 2003
DepartmentTrade and Industry
Basis of considerationEM of 13 January 2004
Previous Committee ReportNone
To be discussed in CouncilNo date set
Committee's assessmentPolitically important
Committee's decisionCleared

Background

30.1 We reported in January on a Commission Communication dealing with the measures on security of supply and infrastructure needed to develop the Community's internal energy market in ways which also help to meet its environmental and sustainable development commitments.[64] In particular, the Communication noted that the Commission had previously brought forward legislative proposals setting out common rules for the internal market in electricity and natural gas, and for the conditions governing access to the network for cross-border exchanges in electricity. It also noted that the further proposals which the Commission intended to bring forward in this area included one for a Regulation on cross-border trade in gas, similar to that already adopted for electricity in June 2003,[65] which would give legal backing to the voluntary Guidelines for Good Practice which had been agreed by the European Gas Regulatory Forum (EGRF) in September 2003.[66] The proposal in question is set out in the current document.

The current document

30.2 In its introduction, the Commission recalls that the Directive (2003/55/EC[67]) setting out common rules for the internal market in natural gas provides for:

  • the right for all non-household gas customers to freely choose their supplier no later than 1 July 2004, with all customers being given this right by 1 July 2007;
  • third-party access to transmission and distribution networks on the basis of published and regulated tariffs;
  • the establishment of a regulatory authority, with a common minimum set of responsibilities, in each Member State;
  • the legal unbundling of transmission and large and medium-sized distribution companies;
  • access to storage facilities either on a negotiated or regulated basis.

It says that these steps will provide the basic structural reforms necessary to develop the internal market for gas, but that the Community's objectives of achieving a level playing field for all participants in this area are unlikely to be met, unless additional legislative measures — similar to those already adopted under Regulation (EC) 1228/2003 — are taken regarding the manner in which transmissions systems are operated.

30.3 Accordingly, the proposal would spell out the underlying principles governing:

  • charges for access to networks;
  • third-party access services;
  • capacity allocation mechanisms and congestion management procedures;
  • transparency requirements;
  • balancing and imbalance charges;
  • secondary markets.

Within this broad framework, more detailed guidelines would be set out in annexes, and there would be provision for these to be amended by a Regulatory Committee, which would be obliged to consult the EGRF and (via the new European Energy Regulatory Group) national regulatory authorities.

The Government's view

30.4 In his Explanatory Memorandum of 13 January 2004, the Minister for Energy, e-Commerce and Postal Services at the Department of Trade and Industry (Mr Stephen Timms) says simply that the Government agrees that there is a need for a mechanism for agreeing effective and enforceable cross-border trading rules, and that the proposed Regulation — to which his Department and the industry regulator made a significant input at the drafting stage — is a means of providing this. He also says that the European gas industry has been closely involved in the drawing up of the proposal, and that the Government is currently in close touch with the UK industry about these issues. On the substance of the proposal, the Minister suggests that the proposal would require minimal adjustment to the existing regime within Great Britain, and will also have a negligible effect on the operation of businesses. Similarly, he says that the limited development of the gas market in Northern Ireland means that the proposal will not have a significant impact there.

Conclusion

30.5 Although this proposal is seen as an important means of under-pinning the voluntary guidelines agreed last year by the European Gas Regulatory Forum, it does not of itself appear to break new ground. In this connection, we note the Government's view that minimal adjustments would be required to the existing regime within Great Britain, and that there will be a negligible impact on businesses. Consequently, although we think it right to draw the proposal to the attention of the House, we see no need to withhold clearance.


64   (25198) 16262/03; see HC 42-vii (2003-04), para 8 (21 January 2004). Back

65   Regulation (EC) No. 1228/2003. OJ No. L 176, 15.7.03, p.1. Back

66   This is a body which comprises national regulatory authorities, associations representing network operators and users, and consumers. Back

67   OJ No. L 176, 15.7.03, p.57. Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2004
Prepared 19 February 2004