Select Committee on European Scrutiny Eighth Report


Annex

Meetings and subjects discussed during the Committee's overseas visits

Strasbourg and Luxembourg, 10-13 March 2003

Strasbourg, 10 March

UK MEPs belonging to the Convention: processes within the Convention; absence of voting in the Convention and role of the Convention's Praesidium; advantages and disadvantages of having a Convention; the Convention's likely outcome; likely impact of Convention proposals on national parliaments; reform of COSAC and MEPs' attitude towards it; how to increase public interest in the European Parliament and elections to it.

Strasbourg, 11 March

Judges and officials of the European Court of Human Rights: coherence of human rights protection across Europe and desirability of the EU institutions being bound by the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR); relationship between European Court of Human Rights and the European Court of Justice if the EU acceded; impact on the Court of accession of central and eastern European countries and arrival of judges from them; EU incorporation of Charter of Fundamental Rights and possibility of divergent interpretations; standing of individuals under the ECHR and Charter; backlog of ECHR cases and possible remedies.

Chris Krüger, former Deputy Secretary-General of the Council of Europe: possibility of conflict between the ECHR and Charter; role of the European Court of Human Rights if the EU acceded to the ECHR; increase in the Court's workload and possible remedies.

Luxembourg, 11 March

Judge Edward of the European Court of Justice (ECJ): general introduction to the ECJ; budget, especially for translation and interpretation; changing workload and efforts to clear backlog of cases; time taken for cases, especially the impact of translation; increased translation problem following enlargement; possibility of fast-tracking cases.

Luxembourg, 12 March

Judges Vesterdorp, Edward and Forwood and Advocate General Jacobs of the European Court of Justice: proposed extension of the jurisdiction of the Court of First Instance (COFI); delays in COFI; changes in COFI's workload; rules for allocation of cases to judges/courts; enforcement of ECJ judgments; Charter of Fundamental Rights and remedies under it; possible EU accession to the ECHR; jurisdiction of the ECJ, e.g. in Third Pillar matters; need for accelerated procedure if jurisdiction extended to criminal matters and child custody; translation and budget problems.

Members of the European Court of Auditors (ECA): organisation of the ECA and possible changes; language problems and delays; balance between audit for integrity and audit for value for money; whistleblowers and the case of Mrs Andreasen; impact of EU enlargement; effectiveness of OLAF; problems over Structural Funds; problems over European Development Funds.

Foreign Minister of Luxembourg (Mrs Lydie Polfer): importance of the EU, NATO and the UN to Luxembourg's security; policy on disarmament of Iraq; impact of the Iraq crisis on the CFSP and ESDP; the Convention and the relationship of large and small countries; number of Commissioners; proposed Council Presidency; prospects for the Convention.

ROME AND VALLETTA, 9-12 JUNE 2003

Rome, 9 June

Productive Activities Minister (Antonio Marzano): Presidency priorities, especially the Lisbon Agenda and competitiveness; intellectual property; entrepreneurship and SMEs; sectoral policies; energy; consumer policy; impact of EU enlargement; transport; relationship of technology, relocation and jobs; Italian productivity.

Interior Junior Minister (Antonio d'Ali): Presidency priorities; border controls; illegal immigration; racism and xenophobia; common asylum policy.

Rome, 10 June

EU Minister (Rocco Buttiglione): importance of national identities in the EU; foreign policy, especially relations with the US; the Convention's proposals; QMV; the IGC and its timing; common defence policy; defence procurement; the euro; Russia and the EU; EU's role in the Middle East.

Chairman of the Chamber of Deputies' EU Policies Committee (Giacomo Stucchi): Parliament's contribution to the Presidency priorities; the Convention and the Chamber's monitoring of it; role of national parliaments; reform of COSAC; reform of the EU Policies Committee.

Junior Minister of Justice (Jole Santelli) and officials: Presidency priorities; racism and xenophobia; delays in litigation; harmonisation of criminal law and procedure; European Public Prosecutor.

Deputy Prime Minister (Gianfranco Fini): the Convention and IGC; Charter of Fundamental Rights; subsidiarity; number of Commissioners; election of the Commission President; a longer-term Council President; EU Foreign Minister; QMV, especially in foreign policy; role of the IGC; the Atlantic relationship.

Valletta, 11 June

High Commission briefing.

Malta Environment and Planning Authority: MEPA's role and activities; raising environmental awareness; protection of birds; waste management; water; CAP reform and Malta; Maltese views on the EU; environmental legislation; transport.

Minister for Justice and Home Affairs (Dr Tonio Borg): asylum and immigration; visa policy; Europol; money laundering; terrorism; judicial training; implementation of EU law; harmonisation of criminal law and procedure; European Public Prosecutor.

Valletta, 12 June

Members of Parliament likely to be on Malta's European Affairs Committee: the work of the European Scrutiny Committee and its relevance to the Maltese Parliament following accession, including the scale of the task, the resources needed, the relationship with citizens, the scrutiny reserve resolution, the mechanics of the Committee's work, debates, the process of taking evidence, and the impact on government policy.

Minister for Foreign Affairs (Dr Joe Borg) and officials: preparation for Malta's accession, including possible new structures; involvement of civil society in this; parliamentary scrutiny of EU matters, and the shortage of Members and resources for this; the Convention's proposals; number of Commissioners; election of Commission President.

PARIS, 4 NOVEMBER 2003

Délégation de l'Assemblée Nationale pour l'Union Européenne: CFSP and ESDP; structured cooperation on defence and criteria for participation in it; objectives of ESDP; relationship between European defence cooperation and NATO; the Atlantic relationship generally; defence cooperation between France, the UK and Germany; proposed EU Foreign Minister; possibility of a multi-speed Europe; funding of the EU and the UK's budget rebate; the Convention's proposals; QMV; subsidiarity early-warning mechanism; role of national parliaments; number of Commissioners; proposed Legislative Council; Lisbon Agenda; French policy on energy liberalisation; role of European Central Bank; Franco-British co-operation on shipbuilding; referendums; whether public attitudes in the UK towards the EU and France ressemble those in the press.

DUBLIN, 9-11 DECEMBER 2003

9 December

Embassy briefing.

10 December

Minister of Finance (Charlie McCreevy): Presidency priorities; next Financial Perspective; Lisbon Agenda; Financial Services Action Plan; tax harmonisation and tax competition; Growth and Stability Pact; Irish experience of the euro; International Finance Facility.

Minister for Europe (Dick Roche) and Special Adviser to the Taoiseach (Una Claffey): prospects for the IGC; tax competition; role of national parliaments; criminal law provisions in the draft treaty; reference to Christianity in the draft treaty; impact of problems over the Stability and Growth Pact; Presidency priorities; referendum on draft treaty; bridging the gap between citizens and the EU.

Assistant Secretary, Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Seamus O'Morain): failure of WTO meeting at Cancun and future plans; plans in respect of the Lisbon Agenda.

Junior Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform (Willie O'Dea): Convention's criminal justice proposals; European Public Prosecutor; Charter of Fundamental Rights; asylum problems and policy in Ireland; discrimination and employment law.

11 December

Secretary General (Niall Callan) and other officials of the Department of Environment and Local Government: meetings during the Presidency and Presidency plans; chemicals legislation; Kyoto agreement; waste; wind farms; sustainable development strategy.

Members of the Oireachtas European Affairs Committee: role, activities and resources of the Committee; relationship between the Committee and the public; public attitudes to the EU and the Irish Presidency.

Counsellor (Frank Sheridan) and other officials of the Development Co-operation Division, Department of Foreign Affairs: Presidency plans; relationship between development assistance and the CFSP; budgetisation of the European Development Funds; International Finance Facility; preventing misuse of development assistance; the Irish development assistance model; Cancun; planned HIV-AIDS Conference.


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2004
Prepared 3 February 2004