Select Committee on Health Written Evidence


Memorandum by Dr Amolak Bansal (AL 60)

INTRODUCTION

  I work as a Clinical Immunolgist and Allergist within the Department of Immunology at the St Helier Hospital in Carshalton, Surrey, which is part of the Epsom and St Helier University Hospitals NTIS Trust. I run the immunology and allergy service within this Trust and also at the Kingston Hospital, Kingston, Surrey and the allergy service at the St George's Hospital in Tooting. The catchment area for our allergy referrals is extremely large and includes much of South West Thames, Surrey borders and parts of Middlesex. At the St Helier Hospital I am joined by one further consultant in immunology and allergy. We also employ two nurses both of whom divide their work between immune deficiency and allergy. There are no supporting personnel at Kingston Hospital or at St George's Hospital.

  1.  While the allergy service at the St Helier Hospital offers a comprehensive range of diagnostic and therapeutic strategies, it is lacking in nursing personnel who are entirely devoted to the management of patients with allergic disease. Additionally, there are no in-patient facilities for the investigation and management of those patients with severe allergic disease or those who suffer anaphylaxis. Investigation of suspected drug allergy is also woefully inadequate, mainly because each of the senior staff do not have sufficient time to devote to the very lengthy and complicated investigations that these patients require. Desensitisation therapy is offered only at the St Helier Hospital and here too there are insufficient staff to cope with the increasing demand. The lack of facilities for desensitisation therapy makes it virtually impossible for those patients living far away from St Helier to comply with the demands of this therapy. This, of course, excludes desensitisation therapy on the basis of the patient's post code.

  2.  In order to improve the provision of allergy services there is an urgent need to increase the number of trained allergists and also nurses specialising in this field. In particular, the number pf paediatric allergists certainly needs to be increased as there are less than a handful around the country. For the Epsom and St Helier University Hospitals NITS Trust that includes the Queen Mary's Children's Hospital, this is the area that requires most attention. Here my waiting list appears to be increasing very rapidly despite numerous attempts to bring this down. For the adult clinics, there is again a need for at least one fully funded nurse specialising in allergic disease. The same is also true for the allergy clinics I run at St George's and Kingston Hospitals. Only in this way can the ever increasing number of patients with allergic disease be seen, investigated and managed within a clinically acceptable time frame.

  3.  For the Kingston Hospital clinic, the local PCT's have withdrawn their support and referrals are vetted by the PCT with those that require treatment being sent to my St Helier Hospital clinic. This obviously presents many problems for patients in this area, especially the young and the elderly who have considerable distances to travel. I therefore believe that PCT's should be encouraged to support allergy services at their local hospital even though PCT leaders may feel that patients with cardiac disease or cancer deserve the greater attention. For the future, practice nurses within GP surgeries should be encouraged to perform skin prick testing and educational programmes of the sort that I hope to organise at St Helier Hospital, need support.

June 2004





 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2004
Prepared 2 November 2004