Select Committee on Northern Ireland Affairs Sixth Report


8 QUALITY OF HOUSING

Decent Homes Standard

108. NIHE carried out its first comprehensive house condition survey in 1974. In that survey it found that 90,000 dwellings or 20% of the total housing stock was unfit, a rate three times higher than England. By 2001, this had been reduced to 4.9%. DSD considered that "the marked decline in unfitness" was a result of improving economic prosperity and confidence in the housing market which had stimulated new dwelling construction and higher levels of home improvement in the private sector assisted by grants expenditure "as well as the continued investment in social housing." It pointed out that " Levels of investment in housing in Northern Ireland have been consistently higher than in GB."[167]

109. The Government made a commitment in 2000 to bring all public sector homes in Great Britain up to the Decent Homes Standard by 2010, but failed to extend it to Northern Ireland. The reason appears to lie in the quality of housing stock in Northern Ireland which was generally regarded as higher than in England. In Professor Murie's estimation "Northern Ireland starts off from a better position with a more modern, better quality public sector housing stock, and without the same erosion of confidence in the sector that has been experienced in parts of England."[168]

110. NIHE carried out a house condition survey in 2001 using the Decent Homes Standard and found that almost one third of all dwellings failed to meet the standard, including one half of tenanted NIHE properties. Of the 58,000 tenanted NIHE dwellings that failed, virtually all (97%) failed on the thermal comfort criterion because of the presence of solid fuel or electric heating. Only 3% failed because of disrepair, and 2% because of the lack of modern facilities and services. 7% of housing association properties failed, and this small proportion may be due to the relatively new stock in this sector. We saw earlier there are concerns about standards in the private rented sector where 47% failed to meet the standard.[169]

111. In the course of this inquiry we heard many calls for the introduction of the Decent Homes Standard in Northern Ireland, particularly to protect vulnerable groups. For example, the Northern Ireland Tenants Action Project considered that the standard would "confirm that there needs to be significant and continued investment in the housing stock, across all tenures." and pointed out that "many of the most vulnerable groups in Northern Ireland are those which live in the worst housing conditions".[170] NIHE indicated that tackling fuel poverty is a priority and is being addressed through fuel switching:

"While the Department for Social Development's Fuel Poverty Strategy is at draft stage a range of policies and additional investment have been put into place in recognition of its importance. Fuel switching (from coal to oil/gas) was introduced in 2000; a strategy for switching NIHE stock was simultaneously introduced and in the private sector the Warm Homes scheme targets fuel switching for elderly households."[171]

112. Fuel poverty is recognised as a major problem in Northern Ireland. The high level of Northern Ireland Housing Executive homes that would have failed to meet the Decent Homes Standard on thermal comfort grounds is a cause for considerable concern. We welcome the development of a Fuel Poverty Strategy and the ongoing action being taken to tackle the issue through fuel switching.

113. NIHE has recognised an expectation from government that it is necessary to look beyond the Decent Homes Standard and incorporate issues like neighbourhood renewal, community safety, health and safety, as well as fuel and poverty. It has reviewed the position in other parts of the UK and looked at the cost of implementing a comprehensive Northern Ireland version of a housing quality standard. It pointed out that the final decision is a matter for government. NIHE stated that, should the current Decent Homes Standard be extended to Northern Ireland, they would be able to meet the target by 2010.[172]

114. We call on the Minister to develop and introduce as a matter of urgency a comprehensive and challenging housing quality standard for Northern Ireland with appropriate targets and funding.

Lifetime Homes Standard

115. The problems faced by people with disabilities gaining access to good quality housing were brought home to us starkly during a meeting with disability groups in a separate inquiry.[173] We heard that proposals to build specific accommodation for disabled people were frequently opposed, and individual disabled people frequently face opposition when attempting to purchase a house. However, NIHE appears aware of the problem and has reported that physical accessibility issues relating to age and disability have grown in recent years across all tenures. We were told that £30 million is spent annually adapting properties in Northern Ireland.[174]

116. Lifetime Homes, a design standard developed by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation in the 1990s, is intended to ensure that a new house or flat will fully meet the needs of most households throughout their lifetime, and reduces the need for costly adaptations after building is complete. It was adopted by DSD in 1997 for social housing, extended to all general needs housing association properties from April 2001, and has multiple benefits:

"The adoption of the Standard has resulted in fewer adaptations being required and where they are, the works have been easier due to house design… The additional cost of incorporating the Lifetime Homes standards across tenures has been estimated to range from £165-£545 per dwelling which could be recouped in 3-10 years. It has also been suggested that the Lifetime Homes Standard promotes social integration by reducing need for temporary residential care, has a role in accident prevention and associated savings in health costs. It has made the housing stock more accessible and as a consequence more sustainable." [175]

117. We heard several calls for the extension of the Lifetime Homes standard to the private sector. In particular, the Chartered Institute of Housing argued for an amendment to Part R of the building regulations requiring the private sector to use the design as a minimum standard. CIH considered that only compulsion would ensure that the private sector took the standard seriously.[176] The Minister said that he supported the extension of the Lifetime Homes standard to the private sector, but that it was a matter for the Department of Finance and Personnel with its responsibility for building regulations.[177]

118. We recognise the substantial benefits for people with disabilities in having all new dwellings built to Lifetime Homes standard as well as the potential longer term savings on the cost of adaptations. We call on Ian Pearson, the Minister with responsibility for Finance and Personnel, to introduce the Lifetime Homes standard as soon as possible by amending the relevant building regulations.

Sustainable Building

119. While there may be fewer unfit houses in Northern Ireland than in England and Wales, Professor Woolley, Queen's University Belfast told us that standards of sustainable housing in Northern Ireland are lower than in the rest of the UK.[178]

120. Professor Woolley, defined sustainability in the housing context as the environmental impact of new development, the opportunities to improve energy efficiency, the need to reduce damaging pollution, and improvements in the health of housing occupants.[179] He pointed out that current planning policy documents make no reference to the need to encourage sustainability and energy efficiency, and argued that greener standards are being largely ignored in Northern Ireland. He considered there is presently insufficient co-ordination between government and other agencies concerned with energy efficiency. In his view, the main priority for social housing was to make existing buildings more energy efficient, but the result of the present unsatisfactory position is that while programmes to introduce insulation do exist "Insufficient research has been done to evaluate the success and effectiveness of current insulation grants." [180]

121. Professor Woolley was concerned also that the way housing associations develop social housing may make a sustainable approach to construction difficult to follow "an increasing number of housing associations use Design and Build packages from developer builders as the main form of procurement of social and special needs housing and this makes the incorporation of environmental best practice extremely difficult." [181] The Northern Ireland Federation of Housing Associations (NIFHA) accepted that more could be done to incorporate greater energy efficiency and sustainability into new housing and said that housing associations would like to see more being done on this issue. NIFHA pointed out that there was considerable flexibility in the types of design and build contracts available.[182]

122. The Sustainable Buildings Task Group was set up in Great Britain in October 2003 to advise the Government on practical and cost effective measures to improve the sustainability of buildings in the short and long term. Reporting in May 2004 the Group concluded that "a significant uplift in quality is both possible and affordable" and that "an urgent change is needed in the way our buildings are constructed and maintained if we are to avoid the mistakes of the disastrous 1960s building boom".[183] Its report, Better Buildings - Better Lives, called on the Government and the building industry to adopt a single national Code for Sustainable Building.

123. The report was welcomed by the government, and GB departments and the industry are co-operating to develop a Code for Sustainable Building designed to set best practice standards of energy efficiency, flood resilience, water consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and waste production.[184] The Minister told us that these developments were being monitored and that it would be a matter for the Department of the Environment in Northern Ireland to implement such a code in consultation with other departments. However, he gave no indication of whether any consideration had been given to extending the Code to Northern Ireland.[185]

124. We welcome the assurance that the work of the Sustainable Buildings Task Force in Great Britain is being monitored. We urge Angela Smith, the Minister with responsibility for the Environment, in consultation with other Departments, to consider making a public commitment to extend the Code for Sustainable Building to Northern Ireland at the earliest opportunity.


167   HC 493-II Ev 68 Back

168   HC 493-II Ev 205 Back

169   Northern Ireland House Condition Survey 2001, NIHE, 2003 Back

170   HC 493-II Ev 101 Back

171   HC 493-II Ev 85 Back

172   HC 493-II Q199 Ev 94 Back

173   Northern Ireland Affairs Committee Inquiry, Hate Crime in Northern Ireland. Informal meeting with Disability Action and Mencap in Belfast, 14 June 2004 Back

174   HC 493-II Ev 85, 70 Back

175   HC 493-II Ev 70 Back

176   HC 493-II Q46 Ev 15 Back

177   HC 493-II Q431 Ev 181 Back

178   HC 493-II Ev 187 Back

179   HC 493-II Ev 184 Back

180   HC 493-II Ev 186 Back

181   HC 493-II Ev 186 Back

182   HC 493-II Q81 Ev 32 Back

183   Making today's buildings fit for tomorrow, Sustainable Buildings Task Group, News Release, 18 May 2004 Back

184   Better Buildings at the Heart of Sustainable Development, OPDM, DTI & DEFRA, News Release, 18 May 2004 Back

185   HC 493-II QQ429-430 Ev 181 Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2004
Prepared 25 October 2004