Select Committee on Procedure First Report


4 Period between presentation and voting of Estimates

17. Under Standing Order No. 55, Estimates (other than Votes on Account and excess votes) may be voted under the "roll-up" procedures in winter and spring only if they have been presented "at least seven clear days previously", i.e. on or before the eighth day before the vote takes place. The Government's manual Government Accounting sets a target of fourteen days, and the Liaison Committee have recommended that this deadline should be put in the Standing Order: the Chief Secretary supports this proposal.[18]

18. One advantage of this change is that select committees will be assured of a reasonable amount of time to consider supplementary estimates and report to the House in time for a debate. To assist in this, departments have for some time undertaken to provide proofs of Estimates to the relevant committees in advance of presenting them to the House of Commons. It is also essential, if an Appropriation Bill is to be introduced following the spring "roll-up", that the Estimates are produced far enough in advance for the Bill to be drafted and checked.[19] A fourteen-day deadline is highly desirable for this purpose.

19. The deadline is expressed in days, not sitting days, and the Chairman of the Liaison Committee expresses the hope that, where a prorogation or adjournment of the House intervenes, the Government will present the Estimates earlier.[20]

20. We welcome the Government's agreement to amendments to Standing Order No. 55 to require fourteen days to elapse between the presentation and approval of Estimates at the winter and spring "roll-ups"; and we hope that where a prorogation or adjournment intervenes, the Estimates will be presented earlier.

21. The only deadline for the summer "roll-up" is that two days' notice is required of the relevant motions: it is not proposed to change this, as there may be occasions when it is not possible to give fourteen days' notice of Summer Supplementary Estimates. Nevertheless, we believe that Government guidance should make clear that a fourteen-day interval between presentation of Summer Supplementary Estimates and their approval should be met other than in exceptional circumstances.


18   Government Accounting 2000 (as amended in 2002), para 11.2.7; Appendix 1, Annex B, p 32. Back

19   Unlike other Government bills, Consolidated Fund and Appropriation Bills are drafted in the Public Bill Office at the House on the basis of the figures in the Estimates, and checked with the Treasury. Back

20   Appendix 4, p 57. Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2004
Prepared 3 March 2004