Select Committee on Health Minutes of Evidence


Annex B

THE MEDICINES AND HEALTHCARE PRODUCTS REGULATORY AGENCY (MHRA) BREACH OF ADVERTISING REGULATIONS

  The MHRA website states:

  The MHRA website states: (still referring to its former name, the MCA):

        "5.6  Breach of Advertising Regulations

        Where the assessment of advertising material identified under paragraphs 2, 3 or 4 above indicates a potential breach of the Advertising Regulations, the person responsible for the advertisement will be advised that the MCA considers that the advertisement is potentially in breach of the Advertising Regulations.

        Although the Regulations clearly set out the powers available to the MCA, the Agency is not intending to extend its role. It is expected that, in the majority of cases, companies will work with the MCA to issue acceptable advertising without the need to resort to the formal procedures laid down under the Schedule to the Monitoring Regulations. However, once the formal procedures have been invoked they will continue until the matter is resolved.

        In the small minority of cases where we are unable to reach a satisfactory result by negotiation the advertiser may be issued with a notice under paragraph 3 of the Schedule to the Monitoring Regulations advising him that:

        the MCA is "minded to" determine that the advertisement, if published, would be in breach of the Advertising Regulations and the reasons why they are minded to make such a determination; if such a determination is made, that person may be required to refrain from publishing that advertisement by a notice served under paragraph 5 of the Schedule; and the person on whom the notice is served has 21 days from the date of the notice in which to make written representations that the proposed determination should not be made.

        The notice may require that person to refrain from publishing the advertisement until the notice has been withdrawn by Health Ministers. In deciding whether to include such a requirement, the MCA will take into account all the interests involved and, in particular, the public interest.

        If the advertiser agrees that the advertising material may be in breach and agrees to amend the material before issue, or withdraw material already in issue, any revised material should be submitted for assessment before it is issued.

        If the advertiser considers that the advertising is not in breach of the Advertising Regulations, he may submit a written representation that the proposed determination should not be made. The representation will be passed to an Independent Review Panel for advice before a final decision is made by the Licensing Authority. Full details of the operation of the Review Panel are available from the MCA.

        5.7  Issue of decisions and determinations

        If an advertiser has provided written representations in response to a notice under paragraph 3 of the Schedule to the Monitoring Regulations, the advertisements in question will be reconsidered in the light of that representation. The MCA will refer the advertisement and written representation to an Independent Review Panel for advice before making a final determination. If, following consideration of that advice, the MCA decides that the advertisement would not be in breach of the Regulations, a notice under paragraph 4 of the Schedule will be issued informing the advertiser of that decision and withdrawing the notice served under paragraph 3.

        Alternatively, the MCA may, in the light of advice received from the Independent Review Panel, make a determination that the advertisement, if published, would be in breach of the Advertising Regulations. In this case, a notice under paragraph 5 of the Schedule will be issued stating the reasons for the determination, withdrawing the notice served under paragraph 3 and which may require the advertiser to refrain from publishing the advertisement.

        Where the publication of an advertisement has been prohibited under paragraph 5, and that advertisement has previously been published, the person may be required to publish the reasons for the determination (as notified to him by the notice under paragraph 5a in full or in part) and a corrective statement within a specified time and in an appropriate form (paragraph 6 of the Schedule refers).

        Once the Licensing Authority's final decision has been given, any further disagreement must be settled in the Courts. A company which is unhappy about the decision will continue to have the opportunity to request a judicial review of the Authority's executive decision.

        5.8  Sanctions

        Paragraph 7 of the Schedule creates offences where the addressees of notices under paragraphs 1, 3 or 5 of the Schedule fail to comply with the requirements imposed. Paragraph 8 makes it an offence for a person to fail to comply with any requirement imposed on him under paragraph 6 of the Schedule. The provisions of the Monitoring Regulations make it an offence to fail to comply with the MCA's determination of the matter and the MCA will consider enforcement action where any breach of the Regulations has taken place and where the legislation makes that breach a criminal offence. In addition, the MCA is entitled to seek an injunction in the courts as part of its investigation of a complaint or of its own motion."


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2005
Prepared 26 April 2005