Select Committee on Culture, Media and Sport Written Evidence


Memorandum submitted by Harry Smith, Team Manager, Crosfields Under-11s "A" Team

  I am the Team Manager of Crosfields Under-11s "A" football team based in Warrington. At this moment in time my squad consists of 14 players, 12 male and two female. Up until the close of this season the sex of the individual players in my team was never an issue. The players respect for each other was based purely on ability. One of my female players, Addi Campbell, is a very capable player who more than holds her own against opposition players, even though the majority of the time our opponents are 100% of the male gender. My other female player is Hannah Dale. Hannah has been our "Player of the Season" for the past three years and I would consider her an outstanding prospect. It will come as no shock to me if she eventually represents our national side.

  From a personal point of view, I have always supported any of my players and given them the utmost encouragement when they have been given the opportunity to play at a higher level. A total of five boys who played for me at Crosfields are now playing "Academy" football at Manchester United, Liverpool, Everton, Blackburn Rovers and Bolton Wanderers. I keep in touch with these players, and Crosfields will be there for these boys should they ever be released. When these players left Crosfields, it had a devastating effect on the team. We went from winning the League and, in my opinion, being the best team in the local area to being relegated the following season. I did not complain and decided we had to keep the players' heads up and develop the players in future years.

  Since then I and my fellow coaches have worked very hard to stabilise the team, improve the players' ability and prepare them to compete at the highest levels they can attain. We feel we now have a team which is capable of winning our League next season. Hannah Dale is very much an integral part of that team.

  When we first lost players to the "Academies", our remaining players accepted the fact that these lads were going onto a higher level and understood the reasoning behind this. Today they cannot understand the reasoning behind why Hannah and Addi cannot play next season. They are all bitterly upset at what they feel is an injustice. Our male players have worked so hard to become a good team once again and just when they feel they are ready to push for honours once more, they see the heart being ripped out the team.

  I can fully understand their frustrations. This will be the second time due to FA rules (Academy players must leave their clubs) our team will suffer. Our squad comprises of 14 players, finding two players with similar ability to replace the girls will be almost impossible. Any half decent player is already signed up by a club.

  I have heard all the arguments reference why girls cannot play football against boys from under 12, and I have to say they are outdated based on ignorance and bias. The two female players who play for me are physically strong and mentally tough. They know when they walk onto the pitch they will get no favours and don't expect them. They also know like all of our male players if their performances are not good enough, I will have no hesitation in dropping them. Both girls have adapted brilliantly to 11-a-side football, surely not even the ignorant or biased will claim it is a progressive step to move them back into seven-a-side next season. I know for a fact every team we played against last season would love to have Hannah Dale in their squad for next season. It is fairly obvious to me that people who know and truly understand football at grassroots (ie. ourselves and the opposition managers and coaches) who witness these games every week, cannot see why these girls are not allowed to play next season.

  I can understand and tend to agree with the fact the average male player is better than the average female player. Hannah Dale is no average player. She should be allowed to compete at the highest level her ability takes her. At this moment in time that is against male players.

  The Germans and Americans have the best female teams in the world. Ask yourself why? They have been allowed to compete at the highest level their abilities took them and that included competing against male players well over the age of 12.

  All I ask the FA to do is allow these girls to play at their true level, for the sake of the boys in our team, but most of all Hannah and Addi themselves.

  The FA have done a wonderful job with girls football, but in my opinion girls football is being held back with this outdated rule. The sky should be the limit, unfortunately the German and American girls have wings on their boots and our girls lead weights.

22 June 2006



 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 25 July 2006