Select Committee on Culture, Media and Sport Written Evidence


Memorandum submitted by the British Pensioners & Trade Union Action Association

  1.  The BPUAA believes the Government should pay the full cost of the conversion to Digital TV, including the cost of replacement video recorders for all pensioner' households.

  The reasons for this are:

    (a)   When Channel 5 started broadcasting they paid the costs of converting/upgrading televisions and video recorders.

    (b)   In the two Welsh villages of Ferryside and Llanstaffen all households got free digital television conversion.

    (c)   Since the Government is expected to make around £3 billion from the sell off of the vacant analogue channels the BPTUAA believes there is sufficient money available to pay for free up grades to all pensioner' households.

  2.  The statement published in the "Ofcom Report" that a decision of principle about financial support for access to TV has already been taken by Parliament is untrue.

    (a)   The statement refereed to which says "that people over 75 are eligible to receive free TV licences and people under 75 who are registered blind are eligible to receive a 50% reduction" was never taken by Parliament in a debate on digital TV.

    (b)   The BPTUAA would welcome a parliamentary debate on the question of the cost of digital upgrade for pensioner' households, particularly as the "Ofcom Report" also says that "In terms of `fairness' this decision is itself debatable".

  3.  The BPTUAA believes that the Government is seriously under estimating the problems of conversion to digital TV. Digital TV requires excellent reception conditions, unlike analogue it cannot cope with poor reception areas and experts believe it will never ever be able to reach all the households that currently enjoy analogue signals.

  4. Our survey shows that many pensioner' households are quite content with watching BBC1, BBC2, ITV1, Channel Four and Channel 5 and do not wish to spend their meagre savings on having extra digital TV channels which they may never watch.

  5.  The BPTUAA seriously questions the Government's right to switch off analogue TV signals thus effectively taking away the ability to watch television unless you pay for an upgrade.

  6.  Finally the BPTUAA believes there should be no question of switching off analogue signals until all these questions have been satisfactorily resolved.


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 29 March 2006