Select Committee on Defence Written Evidence


Memorandum from Mrs J P Urquhart

  1.  The issue I would like to raise is the difficulty in getting a place at the school of your choice on return to the UK.

  2.  I have three children, two now at boarding school and one at an SCE school in Germany.

  3.  All three have been to SCE schools and all of their education had been abroad until we had a home posting three years ago. We were lucky as we managed to get the two younger ones into the school of our choice whilst the eldest was starting boarding school, however there were other people in the same "patch" who were unable to get a place at the same school for their children as the classes were full.

  4.  The problem is this:

    —    Many service families move in the summer holidays in order to change schools at the end of a year rather than part way through. We are generally given up to six months notice of posting and up to four months notice of a quarter address—however both these timings are often considerably shorter.

    —    Applications for school places generally close in October for secondary schools and January for Primary Schools and most schools require an address to consider your child for a place. If your posting date is in July or August, you often have no idea where you will be posted until after the closing date for applications for most schools! Thus when you apply for a place at your preferred school, if it is a good school, it is often oversubscribed before you have even applied.

    —    Because LEAs always have a place somewhere, there is always a school for your child, but it generally is not at the most popular schools as they are already full. This means that the element of parental choice often does not exist for service families and they are forced to accept places at schools which may well not be their local school and which are generally considered to be a "less good" school that the one they might have chosen in different circumstances. It can also mean complicated journeys involving different buses just to get there. This, on top of the disruption to their education that Service children inevitably suffer, makes it hard for service children to achieve their potential.

    —    The probability of being unable to get a place at a school of our choice in the UK is one of the main reasons we have taken the boarding school option for our children. Even with the generous allowances available, this is still a significant financial decision and one which many families cannot afford to take, so their children have no choice but to to take up the places at unpopular schools. Parental choice is not a reality for many service families.

3 April 2006





 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 6 September 2006