Select Committee on Office of the Deputy Prime Minister: Housing, Planning, Local Government and the Regions Written Evidence


Memorandum by Mr Courtney Williams (RG 06)

1.  DEVOLUTION

  When devolution was granted to Scotland it was granted to a country and not to a region.

  When a lesser devolution was applied to Wales it was granted to a country and not to a region.

2.  THE WEST LOTHIAN QUESTION

  An anomaly then occurred whereby an MPs representing, in particular a Scottish constituency could vote upon English matters but an MP representing an English constituency could not vote upon Scottish matters.

This is often called the West Lothian question and has yet to be answered.

3.  THE NORTH EAST PROJECT

  The government then, in accordance with democratic principals, piloted the concept of dividing England into regions. The area chosen was the North East. The people of the North East rejected the idea.

4.  ABANDONMENT OF DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPALS

  To revisit the concept of regions for England would be to ignore the decision by the people of the northeast. A decision gained through democratic process and principals. If this government introduces regionalisation it will defy the people of the North East and abandon the principals of a true democracy.

5.  THE WAY FORWARD

  England must be treated with the same respect as all the countries in the United Kingdom. They must be granted the right to an English parliament. MP's of various political persuasions may view this as a disadvantage to their own political ends, but this is a true democracy and those principals must be given priority. Currently the peoples of England are being discriminated against. That cannot be allowed to continue and any other institution other than an English Parliament would be to further that discrimination.





 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 15 March 2006