Select Committee on Public Accounts Nineteenth Report


1  Access to specialist care and diagnosis

1. Whilst the speed with which patients were seen by a specialist following referral had improved since 2000, too many patients still experienced delay between referral and consultation in 2004. Overall, whilst 99% of patients referred urgently by their GP saw a specialist within two weeks, approximately 40% of people ultimately diagnosed with cancer were not referred urgently and were not seen by a specialist within two weeks of referral, and one fifth waited for one month or more (Figure 2). 70% of patients with breast cancer were seen within two weeks, but only 32% of prostate cancer patients.[3] The Department saw the target for all patients to be seen by a specialist within a maximum 18 weeks from referral as a key driver for service improvement.[4]

Figure 2: Waiting times between referral by GP and being seen by a specialist had improved since 2000 but some patients still waited more than two weeks

Source: National Audit Office

2. Around a third of cancer patients did not find doctors' explanations of their condition, treatment or tests very easy to understand. Given the complexities of most types of cancer, and the range of tests and treatments available, clinicians needed good communication skills to break bad news with appropriate sensitivity and care. New guidance published by the National Institute for Clinical Excellence in March 2004[5] recommended that patients should be offered a record of significant matters discussed with consultants and clinicians. At the time of the NAO survey of cancer patients, just 10% of patients received a written or audio record of their diagnosis,[6] though a randomised control trial in Australia had shown that writing to the patient was beneficial. Whilst a tangible record in the form of a letter may be appropriate for some patients, other types of record, such as a recording of the interview, should be considered for those with poor literacy and language skills.[7]

3. Patients with bowel cancer, although generally satisfied with the care that they received, frequently expressed dissatisfaction with the delay between being referred by their GP and seeing a specialist. Difficulties in correctly identifying the symptoms of bowel cancer delay prompt access to specialist care for patients with the disease, undermining patient confidence and causing anxiety. More than a quarter of patients diagnosed by their GP as possibly suffering from bowel cancer waited more than one month to be seen by a specialist and in 2004 30% of bowel cancer patients reported a deterioration in their condition while waiting, compared to 16% for other cancers.[8] Research commissioned by the Department should assist GPs to correctly identify symptoms suggestive of bowel cancer.[9]

4. With the phased roll-out of bowel cancer screening from April 2006, the Department is seeking to raise awareness through working with cancer charities and individual Primary Care Trusts. The Department also plans to roll out pilots with the Healthy Communities Collaborative, designed to raise the profile of cancer and banish any stigma associated with bowel cancer through community-led initiatives.[10]


3   C&AG's Report, Figure 5 Back

4   Qq 1-2 Back

5   Improving supportive and palliative care for adults, National Institute for Clinical Excellence (2004) Back

6   C&AG's Report, para 1.13 Back

7   Q 28 Back

8   C&AG's Report, para 1.7, Figure 6 Back

9   C&AG's Report, para 1.2 Back

10   Q 58 Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 12 January 2006