Select Committee on Transport Eighth Report


2  Piracy - a growing problem

5. In 2004, the National Union of Marine, Aviation and Shipping Transport Officers (Numast) launched a campaign against piracy.[3] Our evidence shows why Numast, and other organisations, are right to be concerned.

6. Piracy is a particular problem in Indonesia and the Malacca Straits, the Gulf of Guinea and Somalia. In November 2005, there was a violent attack by pirates on the Seabourn Spirit, a cruise ship with UK citizens, off the coast of Somalia.[4] That attack failed, but there were many other attacks in Somali waters in 2005, some of which succeeded.[5]

7. The increase in piracy near Somalia was mirrored elsewhere. Two years earlier, press reports indicated that piracy had reached 'record levels' and extended to Indonesia, Bangladesh, India, the South China Sea, and Malaysia, in addition to Somalia.[6] Two of the attacks reported in 2003 were on UK-flagged ships, and three were on UK-controlled or managed vessels. In another incident, British officers on board an Isle of Man-registered supply ship were seized at gunpoint off the coast of Nigeria. They were held hostage and manhandled and had their personal possessions stolen before a ransom was paid.[7]

8. The largest number of incidents in 2005, more than one third of the total number, occurred in the South China Sea which has seen the largest number of incidents in each year for the last decade.[8] The Indian Ocean and East Africa had the next largest number of incidents at around 50 each. Location of incidents and attempted and actual piracy and armed robbery against ships in 2005


9. The total of 266 reported incidents in 2005 may have been the lowest for six years,[9] but these figures cannot conceal what is a clear, sharp upwards trend in piracy worldwide throughout the period 1993 to 2005.[10] The chart below shows that the 2005 total was well above the annual totals from the first half of this period. The International Maritime Organization puts the number of incidents at less than 50 a year in the late 1980s, surging to between 50 and 100 a year in the early 1990s.[11]Incidents of actual and attempted piracy and armed robbery against ships

Incidences of piracy involving the United Kingdom

10. There were thirty-two incidents of piracy or armed robbery involving United Kingdom flagged ships between 1993 and 2004, seven of which occurred in 2004 (4%).[12] According to the Department for Transport, since 1992 there has been one UK seafarer killed at the hands of pirates.[13] Other UK seafarers have since suffered injuries at the hands of pirates. One of the most serious incidents occurred in 1998 on the Isomeria at Santos in Brazil, when two British seafarers who had been taken hostage were injured after the pirates opened fire during a police rescue attempt.[14]

11. Two attacks on ships occurred within United Kingdom waters between 1993 and 2004.[15] Both were on ships berthed in Goole in July 2002 and goods were stolen on both occasions. Since then, we have been told that 'security at every port facility which serves ships engaged on international voyages, including Goole, has been considerably strengthened.'[16]

12. Piracy has dire consequences for its victims. Fifty six per cent of the attacks that happened in 2004 occurred while the ship was berthed or anchored; 30 crew members were killed, the highest number since 2000, and a further 71 were injured, 148 taken hostage and 86 kidnapped.[17] Among incidents where the types of arms used was specified, 48% involved attacks by pirates with knives and 44% pirates with guns.[18] This mayhem has continued in 2005 when 152 crew members were injured, and 652 were taken hostage or kidnapped. Eleven of these remain missing.[19]

13. The growth in piracy over the past decade represents an appalling amount of violence against the maritime community. It is completely unacceptable. We must be clear about what piracy involves: kidnapping, theft, assault, rape, wounding, murder. There is nothing remotely 'romantic' about the perpetrators of these appalling crimes, or their detestable activity. The Government needs to take the upward trend of violent attacks seriously, and to take action to reverse it.


3   Available from: http://www.numast.org/docimages/1516.pdf  Back

4   'Somali "mother ship" directs attacks by pirates', The Independent, 12 November 2005. See also: 'Eighteen Britons on cruise ship attacked by pirates', Sunday Express, 6 November 2005; 'Crew had no guns aboard to fight back', Sunday Express, 6 November 2005; '£55-a-night cruise ship fires 'sonic weapon' to foil pirates', Mail on Sunday, 6 November 2005; 'Pirate Terror of cruise Brits' Sunday Mirror, 6 November 2005; 'Pirate attack coast is a war zone, say crews', Metro, 7 November 2005; 'Seamen call for UN piracy taskforce', The Guardian, 7 November 2005; 'Pirates SOS Call', The Sun, 7 November 2005; BBC News on-line, 5 and 5 November 2005  Back

5   'Somali pirates 'demand $1 m for ship', BBC News on-line, 12 August 2002; 'Somalia's dangerous waters', BBC News on-line, 26 September 2005 Back

6   'High seas piracy hits record level', BBC News on-line, 1 June 2003.  Back

7   'Send warships to fight pirates', The Guardian, 23 June 2003 Back

8   Reports on acts of piracy and armed robbery against ships. Annual Report - 2005 Back

9   IMO, Reports on acts of piracy and armed robbery against ships Issued monthly, Annual Report 2005  Back

10   Figures are from 1993 as it was the first operational year of the IMB Piracy Reporting Centre Back

11   IMO, Reports on acts of piracy and armed robbery against ships, Annual Report 2004 Back

12   See Annex 1 for the 'flag' system. Department for Transport, The UK Government's strategy for tackling piracy and armed robbery at sea, 4 March 2005, paragraph 1: http://www.dft.gov.uk/stellent/groups/dft_transsec/documents/pdf/dft_transsec_pdf_039633.pdf  Back

13   Captain John Bashforth, a British National, and his Filipino Chief Officer, died from gunshot wounds on board the 'MV Baltimar Zephyr' while sailing 60NM from the coast in Indonesian waters on 11 December 1992. The Indonesian Government concluded that the case was one of mutiny, however the MPS investigated and based on all of the evidence available, decided beyond any reasonable doubt that the Captain and Chief Officer had been murdered by boarders intent on theft (piracy). Ev 23 Back

14   Ev 23  Back

15   Department for Transport, The UK Government's strategy for tackling piracy and armed robbery at sea, 4 March 2005, paragraph 1: http://www.dft.gov.uk/stellent/groups/dft_transsec/documents/pdf/dft_transsec_pdf_039633.pdf Back

16   Ev 23 Back

17   'Ships' crews at mercy of pirates on deadly seas', The Times, 7 November 2005 Back

18   Piracy and armed robbery against ships, Annual Report 1 January - 31 December 2005 Back

19   IMO, 2005 Annual Report - Report on acts of piracy and armed robbery against ships, May 2006, para 6: http://www.imo.org/includes/blastDataOnly.asp/data_id%3D14323/81-colour.pdf  Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 6 July 2006