Select Committee on Transport Written Evidence


APPENDIX 21

Memorandum submitted by Mr Bill Urmenyi

ACCOUNTABILITY

  Council officials, parking attendants and sub-contractors are effectively immune to the laws of the land and there is no accountability, which actually functions. For example, I have had occasion to complain to the council that one of their officers has blatantly lied to the independent adjudicator. The council responded by refusing to look into it on the grounds that it was a matter for the adjudicator. I complained to the council ombudsman. The council then lied to the ombudsman who ignored the lie and proceeded to inform me that he was not able to consider the case as it was a legal matter being dealt with by the adjudicator. The adjudicator can not act against the council for lying as it is not in their remit. These people are now free to lie to whomever they please without any fear of consequences.

SIGNS

  The road signs do not give the restriction times laid down in the TMOs. The motorist has to park first, go to the meter and read what it says. The problem with this is that most people assume that public and bank holidays are free and park on single yellow lines. They never have sight of any sign to the contrary as there is no need to read the meter. The councils are well aware of this and use it to hand out penalty charges to the unsuspecting motorists.

TMOS

  There is no way of questioning them. They are laid down as the law and that is that. They are used, however, to scam the motoring public. There is no means of arguing their reasonableness.

PUBLIC HOLIDAYS

  The vast majority of motorists are not aware of the difference between a public holiday and a bank holiday. Domestic calendars do not specify which days are bank holidays if those days are named days. For example, New Years day is never marked as a bank holiday whether it is or is not. How are the motorists supposed to know? The council use this to scam the motorists. This is legalised fraud on a massive scale. There are very few location where the distinction between public and bank holidays needs to be made. Sutton Council however have decided to use the fact that motorist do not know the difference in order to hand out penalty charges to unsuspecting motorists. If the council wishes to differentiate between public and bank holidays, it should say so on its signs so that the motorists are warned. They will still be in difficulty as they have no reasonable means of knowing. How many motorists know that they need to contact the DTI if they want to know which days are bank holidays. This situation has led to hundreds of penalty charges being handed out on Boxing Day and New Years Day. This is clearly not in the public interest and has absolutely nothing to do with the proper control of traffic and parking but everything to do with fraud. This is another case for being able to question the reasonableness of TMOs. Sutton told me that "there is no difference between New Years Day and any other Saturday". These criminals are free to scam motorists.

15 August 2005



 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 22 June 2006