Select Committee on Treasury Minutes of Evidence


Examination of Witnesses (Questions 300 - 303)

WEDNESDAY 25 JANUARY 2006

MR IAN LAWRENCE AND MS LYNNE WALLACE

  Q300  Jim Cousins: So it is a political view?

  Mr Lawrence: Yes.

  Q301  Ms Keeble: Apparently the Pre-Budget Report said that, starting early in 2007, HMRC would contact key groups of tax credit recipients to collect up-to-date income information before the start of the new tax year. Do you think that is feasible and, in addition, how would your members feel about contacting people before some of the issues around overpayments and such have been resolved and the new system is properly bedded down?

  Mr Lawrence: There are already pilot schemes going on on things like overpayment recovery. Whilst, again, we have not had official feedback on these, we do know the feedback is mixed and if you do not try the pilot you do not get to understand what is needed. Again, as a concept we very much welcome HMRC engaging with user groups, claimants' groups and the like but, of course, I very much welcome the idea of them consulting with us too as our members have a stake in all this. I think good time would be spent if we had the high level discourse with TCO management that we are looking for and I think that needs to be done.

  Q302  Ms Keeble: Do your members understand those forms that come out?

  Mr Lawrence: The award notices? No, not to a level that I think they would want to.

  Ms Keeble: That is reassuring. Thank you.

  Q303  Chairman: You very kindly offered us some further information. We are coming to the end of our inquiry so if you were able to do that reasonably quickly we would be grateful.

  Mr Lawrence: I hope colleagues have made a note of all the promises I have made.

  Chairman: Our Clerk can help you on that. If you were able to supply us with any more information we could, of course, take that into account before we come to framing our recommendations. In the meantime, on behalf of the Select Committee, I would like to thank you and your assistant for coming here today and helping us.





 
previous page contents

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 6 June 2006