Select Committee on Treasury Written Evidence


Memorandum submitted by Barclays

1.  EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

  1.1  Barclays is committed to promoting financial inclusion, ensuring a balance between both social and commercial objectives. Our starting point has been to promote access to banking and we continue to drive improvements to Barclays Basic Bank Account and its accessibility. 379,000 "Cash Card Accounts" (our Basic Bank Account offering) are open and 2004 customer research showed that 89% of our customers were satisfied with their accounts. Post Office Card Accounts continue to prove popular and should be researched further to develop a coherent future strategy on access to banking.

  1.2  Regarding affordable credit, we believe that a sustainable community finance sector is key to providing a viable alternative to high-cost lenders and Barclays financial inclusion strategy makes support of Credit Unions and Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs) a priority. Secondly, Barclays seeks to provide fair and non-discriminatory access to its credit products to consumers, subject to ability to repay. Data sharing is an essential element of this, and for this reason Barclaycard is a leading member of a recently launched initiative to improve data sharing levels ie via the sharing of "behavioural data", such as information about payments. Furthermore Barclays is currently the only bank to publicly disclose personal sector lending data in deprived areas.

  1.3  Regarding financial education and advice, Barclays approaches this in three ways: (i) by providing clear information on our products (see Barclays aide memoire sent to Treasury Select Committee in November 2005); (ii) working with organisations including the Money Advice Trust, Citizens Advice and through Barclaycard Horizons, a new consortium of bodies to help lone-parents; (iii) working with the FSA in its National Strategy for Financial Capability. HM Government should be responsible for the delivery of financial capability. The FSA has an important role to play as a co-ordinator of initiatives.

  1.4  Regarding incentives and barriers to savings, HM Government, industry and community finance organisations must work together to improve strategy and action planning in this area. Barclays fully supports the role that Credit Unions can play in mobilising savings among those on benefit and low income and recognises the importance of encouraging the savings habit amongst all our customers.

  1.5  To develop a consistent approach and maximise resources we believe that it is crucial for HM Government to develop a financial inclusion strategy across all relevant departments. The Financial Inclusion Taskforce may be able to play a role in this. The community finance sector will require long-term investment.

  1.6  Regarding financial inclusion measures, Barclays believes that it would be helpful to all stakeholders involved if HM Government was to develop a strategic framework for establishing future socio-economic measures and indicators on financial inclusion.

2.  INTRODUCTION

  2.1  Barclays PLC is a UK-based international financial services group engaged primarily in banking, investment banking and investment management. In terms of assets employed, Barclays is one of the largest financial services groups in the United Kingdom. Barclays has been involved in banking for over 300 years and operates in over 60 countries with more than 110,500 permanent employees, including 32,500 at Absa in South Africa. For more information about Barclays PLC, please visit www.barclays.com.

  2.2  Barclays is committed to promoting financial inclusion as a core element in our approach to corporate responsibility. For this reason, Barclays has had a dedicated Financial Inclusion Team for the last five years. We seek to have a measurable impact on financial exclusion, looking to balance both social and commercial objectives. This is done in part with our own products and services and also through supporting other organisations that provide fair and affordable options for those who cannot access mainstream financial services.

  2.3  A recent report[45] commissioned by ANZ Bank benchmarked their activities in the field of financial inclusion and financial literacy against the performance of other leading banks around the world. The report found that Barclays has done most to advance both thinking and action in the UK, and its efforts put it ahead of banks assessed worldwide. The report recognised Barclays leading position around deprived area data disclosure, our work with the New Economics Foundation (NEF),[46] praise from stakeholders including the Credit Union sector (highlighting PEARLS)[47] and support for the free money advice sector.

3.  ACCESS TO BANKING SERVICES

  3.1  Improving access to banking services is important to us. We believe we have a responsibility to provide access to Basic Bank Accounts and basic financial services where demand exists. We do this through our Cash Card Account, our Basic Bank Account offering. No potential customers are excluded from applying: we are able to open Cash Card Accounts for the majority of applicants,[48] including undischarged bankrupts—although this will not extend to those with a history of fraud, or instances where we suspect money laundering, for example.

  3.2  Barclays Cash Card Account provides an easy-to-use account for people who have not had a bank account before and for those who need an account with no credit facility.

    —  As at 31 December 2005, we had 379,000 Cash Card Accounts and we continue to open them at a rate of some 6,000 per month (net of account closures).

    —  We display leaflets/application forms in our branches.

    —  In order to make it easier to open a Cash Card Account, identification and address verification ("ID&V") can take place in a branch[49] and non-standard documents can be accepted as proof of address or identity.[50]

    —  We make a free helpline available to applicants to ensure that we can help those who have limited documentation.

    —  In 2004 we commissioned research among 500 Cash Card Account customers which showed that we were meeting the needs of the account's target customers,[51] 89% were satisfied with the account.

    —  Barclays is currently the only bank to publish data on the proportion of its customers—including Basic Bank Account holders—from deprived areas.[52]

    —  Our Cash Card Account customers are able to use any of our branches and any of our ATMs, free of charge. In fact, all our customers, including Cash Card Account customers, can withdraw cash free of charge at more than 30,000 ATMs in the LINK network throughout the UK.

  3.3  Our relationship with the Post Office means that all Barclays personal account holders—including Cash Card Account customers—can also use any of more than 12,000 Post Offices in England and Wales to make cash withdrawals free of charge.

  3.4  Barclays is also contributing £30 million over five years (2003-2008) towards the running costs of the Post Office Card Account (POCA) as part of an industry total of £182 million. However, there is no certainty that HM Government will continue to support the POCA when current contracts expire. This is despite the account proving to be a popular alternative to Basic Bank Accounts. As POCAs have proved to be popular[53] we have long argued that research be undertaken to see how well that product meets customers" needs. Without this demand-side research HM Government will be unable to build a coherent strategy for Basic Bank Accounts. Increasing the functionality of POCAs (eg to include direct debits) may be more attractive to many customers than migration to Basic Bank Accounts.

  3.5  The most effective way of reaching people on benefits and low incomes, who do not have bank accounts, is via the extensive network already established by HM Government and the charitable sector—in particular, Job Centre Plus and Citizens Advice outlets etc. Conventional forms of marketing have proved ineffective at reaching this group of people.

  3.6  In 2003, Barclays and the Association of British Credit Unions Limited (ABCUL) commissioned some research[54] analysing the target market for nine Credit Unions across England and Scotland. This provided a useful insight into the financial situation and perspectives of people living in disadvantaged communities. The research found that 38% of respondents relied on "word of mouth" to gain information on financial services—only 7% used personal experience, 16% relied on television, 12% on newspaper advertisements and 11% on direct mail. This highlights that the most effective methods of raising awareness and reaching the more disadvantaged communities are through organisations working within these communities which speak to people face-to-face, ie HM Government, councils, charities and community groups.

  3.7  As part of our commitment towards reaching the more vulnerable in society we are working with The Passage, a homeless shelter in London. Together we have developed a process to enable the opening of Cash Card Accounts for clients at the charity.

  3.8  We have also been working closely with housing associations, as it has been shown that 84% of households in the social housing sector are within the bottom quartile of general deprivation nationally.[55] The most notable project has been CHANGE, which is an innovative community finance organisation set up to work across 15 housing associations in London to provide financial services to their financially excluded tenants. We have supported CHANGE through involvement in their steering committee, support for their loan fund, and funding for a community placement.

4.  ACCESS TO AFFORDABLE CREDIT

  4.1  Barclays believes it has a responsibility to provide fair and non-discriminatory access to its credit products to consumers, provided we are satisfied that they can repay the borrowing. It is not in our or our customers' interests for us to lend them funds they cannot afford to repay. One way to achieve this is to improve the transparency and clarity of our products and our information, which has been a key focus of Barclays recently.

  4.2  It is not in our interests to lend customers money that they cannot afford to repay. We continue to look for ways to improve our decision-making. This can be through better analysis (an area of significant investment over the last 10 years); better quality data (for example, we are more likely to accept a customer's request for a new facility if we have updated information about income); and more information (by finding out about customers' borrowing from other financial institutions).

  4.3  Barclays believes that data sharing is an essential aspect of responsible lending. We have for some time shared both negative and positive data on our core cards and loans portfolios and we were pleased to see similar commitments being delivered across the industry from the end of last year. The Treasury Select Committee will be aware of the recently-announced initiative to share even more data amongst lenders. Barclaycard, Co-operative Bank, Egg and Abbey will share credit card "behavioural data", such as information about payments, card usage and cash advances, with the three credit reference agencies. Many other lenders, including Nationwide and MBNA, have expressed an interest in joining the initiative, which is open to all credit card lenders.

  4.4  The more data that can be shared about people's financial circumstances (subject, of course, to appropriate safeguards of privacy), the more positive lending decisions that can be made and the lower the risk of default (which is detrimental to both borrower and lender). The mainstream industry has made significant progress in recent years, but gaps remain for which we need HM Government support. For example, we would welcome moves to share student loan data, council tax and council rent arrears data. In addition, lenders do not currently share positive data on accounts for which they did not receive express consent to do so—so-called "historic data"—an issue which is particularly important for longstanding credit card accounts. We will be looking for this to be addressed by the DTI's consultation, which we expect to be announced shortly.

  4.5  Support for personal customers in deprived areas[56] of the UK:

    (i)  Barclays makes lending decisions based on a customer's ability to repay, not where they live.

    (ii)  Since 2000 we have disclosed personal sector lending data within deprived areas. We are currently the only bank to do this. To view this data, please visit: http://www.barclays.co.uk/corporateresponsibility/marketplace/productsandservices2.htm

    (iii)  In 2004, Barclays provided 733,500 current accounts in deprived areas, 6.9% of our total accounts. The number of Cash Card accounts provided to deprived areas was 45,500, 14.7% of total Cash Card Accounts.[57]

    (iv)  Unsecured lending to customers in deprived areas represented 6.4% of Barclays total loan book in 2004.

  4.6  We accept that there will be consumers to whom Barclays and others will be unable to offer mainstream finance, because it would not be economic to do so. Consequently our financial inclusion strategy includes support for the community finance sector, which can provide small amounts of affordable credit to some of these consumers. We provide local and national support to Credit Unions and CDFIs across the UK and we recognise the important role that they can play in tackling financial exclusion.

  4.7  In 2004 Barclays gave over £880,000 to community finance organisations via direct grants, community placements for ex-staff, and funding for research across the sector. One highly successful element of our direct funding has been the Barclays Financial Inclusion Fund launched in 2004. This is an annual fund which looks to support individual community organisations including Credit Unions and CDFIs which are developing innovative projects and strategies. In 2004-05 the fund spent almost £100,000 to support projects that looked at raising awareness and increasing customer numbers in these organisations. The 2005-06 fund of almost £130,000, themed "working together" is supporting 10 projects from across England and Wales.

  4.8  Barclays believes that well-managed, sustainable Credit Unions are a key element of a strong community finance sector, crucial if the UK is to tackle exclusion and provide an alternative to high-cost lenders. We have therefore committed £400,000 in funding to ABCUL for further development of PEARLS (See 2.3), a financial monitoring system specifically designed for Credit Unions. This makes Barclays the largest private sector supporter of ABCUL. "Barclays has played a unique role in facilitating many of the changes underway in the Credit Union movement. Their far-sighted sponsorship of the introduction of the PEARLS Credit Union Monitoring System in 2001 has been a key catalyst for change", Mark Lyonette, Chief Executive of ABCUL.

  4.9  Regarding the Social Fund, it is uneconomic for us to provide high volumes of low value loans to people on very low income or benefit. It is HM Government's responsibility to provide a safety net for people in this situation and we therefore support measures to improve the Social Fund to widen access to budgeting and crisis loans for those most in need.

  4.10  However, access to affordable credit is not always the solution for those people who are unable to access mainstream credit. For example, East Lancs Moneyline, a community finance organisation in Blackburn, tells us that around 40% of the people who approach them for finance actually need money or debt advice, even though they think they need a further loan or some form of consolidation. This suggests that although affordable credit is important, it is not always the right solution for all.

5.  FINANCIAL EDUCATION AND ACCESS TO FINANCIAL ADVICE

  5.1  Barclays has actively supported the FSA's National Strategy for Financial Capability and is represented on the Generic Financial Advice and Borrowing workstreams. We also have a secondee on the Families workstream.

  5.2  From a product perspective, our commitment is to provide clear and accurate information on our products, as a basic service to customers. We are continuing our work to improve transparency following the Treasury Select Committee's reports on credit card charges and marketing. Members of the Committee received an update on progress from Gary Hoffman—now Chairman, UK Banking and Chairman, Barclaycard—in November 2005.

  5.3  We believe that the primary responsibility for the delivery of financial capability should lie with HM Government, particularly through education in schools. We were encouraged by the announcement in the Pre-Budget Report that financial capability would be addressed both in the national curriculum, for children, and via Local Authorities for adults. We also welcome the commitment in the Pre-Budget Report 2005 that unclaimed assets are to be used partly for the delivery of financial education.

  5.4  We believe that the FSA has an important role to play in the delivery of financial capability but it should not have overall responsibility for it—this is a strategic role for HM Government. The FSA, however, could continue to perform a valuable function as a co-ordinator of financial capability initiatives.

  5.5  It is in our commercial interests to lend responsibly, as we bear the costs of defaulting customers. We are due to test a new approach to customers in financial difficulty in the first half of 2006. We will proactively contact a sample of customers whom we believe may require financial assistance, with the aim of avoiding this outcome. Separately, our leaflet, Worried about your finances? is now available in our branches.

  5.6  Barclays approach to the provision of money advice is to work with organisations including the Money Advice Trust (MAT), Citizens Advice and, through Barclaycard Horizons, a consortium of bodies to help lone-parents.

    —  In 2004 Barclays provided £2.55 million towards free independent money or debt advice. We were instrumental in the foundation of the Consumer Credit Counselling Service (CCCS) over 10 years ago, and we have supported it since.

    —  Horizons—your family, your future is a unique programme run in partnership with One Parent Families, Citizens Advice, Parentline Plus and the Family Welfare Association to help disadvantaged lone parents make the transition out of over indebtedness. Barclaycard is investing £1 million per year for three years in this programme.

    —  Separately in 2006 Barclays is planning to launch a new community investment initiative in this field. Barclays will be partnering with charities NCH and Help the Aged in a wide ranging programme of financial awareness, money management and debt advice projects around the UK. The £3 million programme, set to run over three years, will target young people, disadvantaged families and older people.

    —  Barclays is committed to communities and operates a number of schemes under which staff volunteer their time and talents. For example, one team in the Midlands worked with homeless people to give information about basic bank services and build confidence about "what happens when you walk through the doors of a bank".

  5.7  In 2005 we supported a Citizens Advice pilot investigating the delivery of generic financial advice to the financially disadvantaged, through the CAB network with the support of Independent Financial Advisers working pro bono. Following a successful evaluation, Citizens Advice is currently considering how this programme could be expanded.

  5.8  Financial capability for young people:

    —  Barclays is supporting Kikass, an innovative youth charity, which is working with young people, to discover ways in which solutions might be developed to meet their particular financial needs.

    —  For the second year, we are supporting Ker'ching which, with the help of Barclays volunteers, is bringing basic financial education to 9 and 10 year olds in over 75 primary schools in and around London.

    —  Barclays has also developed moneychoices and MoneySkills,[58] activity packs for youth leaders to help develop young people's financial awareness.

    —  We are supporting a three year Personal Financial Education Group (Pfeg) project to bring personal financial education to Pupil Referral Units.

  5.9  We look forward to working with HM Government—and the Department for Education and Skills in particular—the FSA, and the new Commission on Unclaimed Assets, in developing a more financially capable population. We also look forward to engaging our staff even more in the future. We are currently developing a financial toolkit for them to use when helping deliver financial capability initiatives in the community.

6.  INCENTIVES AND BARRIERS TO SAVING FOR PEOPLE ON BELOW AVERAGE INCOMES

  6.1  Barclays is an important player in the market for cash savings. We offer a comprehensive range of savings products designed to encourage saving which includes, for example, instant access accounts, longer term savings, accounts for children and tax-efficient savings via a Cash ISA.

  6.2  We recognise the importance of encouraging the savings habit amongst all our customers, not just those with substantial sums. We have recently reviewed our cash savings range and are introducing an improved return for balances from £1 upwards.

  6.3  Barclays remains supportive of the concept of a simplified method of delivering financial advice to customers, but we do not believe that the FSA's Basic Advice regime provides a workable solution. We continue to consider alternative options for simplifying the delivery of financial advice to customers.

  6.4  In the last decade, many additional safeguards and controls have been established in relation to advised sales of investment products, mostly deriving from regulatory requirements. The cost of these additional protections has influenced the cost to the consumer. While the effect will have been proportionately higher for lower income groups, it remains unclear as to how significantly these increased costs have impeded lower income consumers' access to investments compared with other factors such as avoidance of capital risk. The question of the value of the additional protections afforded versus the increased cost remains unresolved.

  6.5  Barclays trained over 250 Savings and Investment Specialists and placed them in our branches to provide a simplified financial selection route, utilising decision trees. This process was designed to provide customers with a fast, clear route to a selection of five potential savings vehicles, including a Cash ISA, a Child Trust Fund, a structured investment product, an income-producing unit trust and a balanced unit trust. Unfortunately the simplified process has not secured as great an increase in consumer engagement as we had sought.

  6.6  We fully support the role that Credit Unions can play in mobilising savings amongst those on benefit and low income. For example, Streetcred Credit Union in Rochdale has demonstrated that it is possible for people on benefit to save money through their "Benefits Direct Account". This enables customers to build assets—particularly for emergencies but also for events such as holidays or times of higher expenditure. Members are encouraged to transfer small value amounts to their savings account each time a payment is made to their account. Savings are often as low as a few pence per week or up to £4-£5 per week. Combined savings are now £63,000.

  6.7  We have supported HM Government's initiative by offering the Child Trust Fund (CTF). We have a large market share (around 10%) of the CTF market, captured through the provision of a market-leading product that combines capital protection with potential for stock market growth.

  6.8  Although we did not participate in the 2002 Savings Gateway pilot, we are aware of the expansion of the scheme in the revised Savings Gateway pilot which commenced in 2005 and will be interested in the findings from it, especially with regard to the effectiveness of matched funding in incentivising overall levels of new saving.

  6.9  We believe that it is a challenge for the Financial Services industry, as a whole, and HM Government, to find a way of explaining the importance of saving, regardless of income level. This only emphasises the need for increasing Financial Capability for which HM Government's initiatives will, in the long term, bear fruit.

7.  THE ROLE OF HM GOVERNMENT, THE FINANCIAL SERVICES AUTHORITY AND OTHER BODIES AND ORGANISATIONS IN PROMOTING FINANCIAL INCLUSION

  7.1  As mentioned in 5.1, Barclays has actively supported the FSA's National Strategy for Financial Capability and is represented on the Generic Financial Advice and Borrowing workstreams.

  7.2  Barclays also welcomes the establishment of both the Financial Inclusion Taskforce and the Financial Inclusion Fund. Barclays fully supports the recent decision to raise the maximum interest rate that Credit Unions can charge.[59] This will prove essential in developing a strong and sustainable Credit Union sector that can provide a credible alternative to high-cost lenders. This sector needs to become recognised by consumers as being an integral part of the financial services sector. We also agree with the HM Treasury's view—recently articulated in a speech by Ivan Lewis MP, Economic Secretary to HM Treasury—that Credit Unions are an important step towards financial inclusion—"they're great at connecting people with more mainstream opportunities."[60]

  7.3  Barclays has been active in the financial inclusion sector for a number of years and prior to the publication of the HM Treasury report, Promoting Financial Inclusion,[61] we were able to advise Treasury officials on the impact of key issues. We achieved this via a range of initiatives—for example, during 2003 and 2004 we hosted visits to community finance projects in Blackburn and Birmingham and held a one day financial inclusion workshop at our head office for HMT officials. We also chaired a round-table to explore the role that Credit Unions could play in tackling financial exclusion.[62]

  7.4  To develop a consistent approach and maximise resources we believe that it is crucial for HM Government to develop a financial inclusion strategy across all relevant departments. The Financial Inclusion Taskforce may be able to play a role in this.

  7.5  Barclays welcomes the establishment of a £120 million Financial Inclusion Fund. However, we believe that consideration should be given to the Financial Inclusion Fund being managed through one HM Government Department or body to maintain consistency. In addition, we believe that the community finance sector will require investment over the longer term as we believe it is unrealistic to expect it to become sustainable during the period of the Financial Inclusion Fund. The money advice sector, which can never be wholly self-sustaining, will require a level of permanent Government funding. In the short term we would recommend focus upon established community finance organisations who can deliver. It is important for the community finance sector to build brand awareness and trust and so provide a viable alternative to high-cost lenders. In the medium term resources could be used to plug geographic gaps subject to sustainable demand.

  7.6  The Post Office Card Account (POCA) has proved to be popular with, we believe, some 5 million accounts now open. Barclays is contributing £30 million over five years towards the running costs of the POCA and the industry a total of £182 million. We agreed to contribute the £30 million in the belief that the account was a first step towards financial inclusion. As suggested earlier (in paragraph 3.4), in view of the popularity of the product, we would urge that a piece of research is carried out to explore how well the product meets consumers" needs.

8.  THE BENEFITS OF FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND THE EXTENT TO WHICH FINANCIAL INCLUSION MEASURES CAN CONTRIBUTE TO COMBATING POVERTY AND REDUCING BARRIERS TO EMPLOYMENT

  8.1  The majority of jobs now require potential employees to have a bank account. Helping the financially excluded to obtain a bank account can therefore be the first step on the ladder towards regular, formalised employment. This benefits both the employee, whose rights in terms of pensions and national insurance, for example, become formalised, and HM Government, as it enables the employee to be taxed.

  8.2  As mentioned, Barclays is committed to promoting financial inclusion as a core element in our approach to corporate responsibility. For this reason, Barclays has had a dedicated Financial Inclusion Team for the last five years. In our work to date we have focused on areas where there are specific, measurable impacts to be made. We have recently begun to measure the wider social impacts of our financial inclusion work but at present this is at a very early stage.[63]

  8.3  We believe that it would be helpful if HM Government were to develop a strategic framework for establishing future socio-economic measures and indicators for financial inclusion. Assessing this complex area requires the contribution from a range of experts in addition to the commercial/private sector eg social academics and economists.

January 2006





45   The Corporate Citizenship Company and ANZ: ANZ Financial Literacy and Inclusion-Global Benchmarking Report, September 2005. This can be found at: http://www.anz.com/aus/aboutanz/Community/Programs/pdf/Global BenchmarkingSummary.pdf Back

46   NEF research: aim was to understand how information from Barclays Management Information systems could be applied to improve transparency and quality of decision-making data in communities with different deprivation profiles. Back

47   The PEARLS Monitoring system uses a set of financial ratios to monitor the financial stability of Credit Unions. These ratios provide essential tools for monitoring, planning, standardising, ranking and facilitating supervisory control in Credit Unions. Each letter in the word PEARLS measures the key areas of Credit Union operations: Protection, Effective financial structure, Asset quality, Rates of return and costs, and Liquidity and Signs of growth. Back

48   We reserve the right not to open bank accounts. Back

49   Until December 2005, Cash Card Account applicants sent their documentation to our account-opening centre in Glasgow. Back

50   Such as a Housing Association tenancy agreement and Home Office travel documents. Back

51   The research also found that 60% of Cash Card Account customers lived in households with total income of £20,000 or less and that 58% of customers lived in rented accommodation-indicating that the product is reaching its target market. For other key findings, please visit http://www.barclays.co.uk/corporateresponsibility/marketplace/productsandservices.htm Back

52   Please see our 2004 Corporate Responsibility Report online at: http://www.barclays.co.uk/corporateresponsibility/marketplace/productsandservices2.htm Back

53   James Plaskitt MP, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Work and Pensions, in a written response to a question in the House of Commons, gave the following answer on 4 July 2005: "As at 15 May 2005, 4,720,824 Post Office card accounts were open for the receipt of benefits, pensions and tax credits." Back

54   "Getting to know you-Raising awareness of credit unions", 2003. Back

55   Chartered Institute of Housing Report 2003 "Breaking Free-Financial Awareness and the role of Social Landlords". Back

56   "Deprived areas" are those areas defined as such by the Bank of England in its report "Finance for Small Businesses in Deprived Communities", November 2000. The term "small businesses" refers to businesses so defined by the British Bankers' Association. Back

57   http://www.barclays.co.uk/corporateresponsibility/marketplace/productsandservices2.htm Back

58   The packs can be found online at: www.barclays.com/financialinclusion Back

59   Pre-Budget report, December 2005. Back

60   Speech by Ivan Lewis MP, Economic Secretary to the Treasury, at the ABCUL conference, at Barclays headquarters at 1 Churchill Place, London, on 6 December 2005. Back

61   Published by HMT as part of Pre-Budget Report, December 2004. Full document and press release: http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/pre_budget_report/prebud_pbr04/assoc_docs/prebud_pbr04_adexclusion.cfm Back

62   1 October 2004. Back

63   For further information please see: http://www.barclays.co.uk/corporateresponsibility/marketplace/financialinclusion.htm Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 16 November 2006