Previous Section Index Home Page

3 May 2007 : Column 1846W—continued

NHS: Negligence

Mr. Baron: To ask the Secretary of State for Health how many claims for alleged clinical negligence against the NHS were closed in each year since 1995; what the cost was of such claims in each year in (a) nominal and (b) real terms; and how many and what proportion of such claims were successful in each year. [133524]

Andy Burnham [holding answer 23 April 2007]: Information on closed claims is presented within the following tables.

Table 1 shows how many clinical negligence claims have been closed by year since 1995, and includes what proportion of such claims were closed with damages (successful).

Table 2 shows the costs of closed clinical negligence claims by year since 1995 in nominal and real terms.


3 May 2007 : Column 1847W

The following points should be noted:


3 May 2007 : Column 1848W
Table 1: Number of clinical negligence claims closed by year of closure including category A claims
Number of claims
Year of closure Closed—nil damages Closed with damages Total closed % Closed with damages

1995-96

90

11

101

10.89

1996-97

175

60

235

25.53

1997-98

218

731

949

77.03

1998-99

1,713

2,344

4,057

57.78

1999-2000

2,794

3,771

6,565

57.44

2000-01

3,822

3,080

6,902

44.62

2001-02

4,995

3,761

8,756

42.95

2002-03

3,981

2,939

6,920

42.47

2003-04

4,043

3,140

7,183

43.71

2004-05

4,101

3,501

7,602

46.05

2005-06

3,146

3,333

6,479

51.44

2006-07

3,330

3,208

6,538

49.07

Grand total

32,408

29,879

62,287

47.97


Table 2: Value of clinical negligence claims closed by year of closure including category A claims
Payments
Year of closure Damages paid Defence costs paid Claimant costs paid Total paid Total paid in real terms with 2005-06 as reference year

1995-96

170,028

56,476

68,016

294,520

378,551

1996-97

1,063,160

363,379

342,282

1,768,821

2,199,451

1997-98

36,541,852

7,065,903

10,353,934

53,961,690

65,203,410

1998-99

75,560,281

21,541,336

26,922,960

124,024,578

146,146,822

1999-2000

285,740,566

42,490,778

64,751,113

392,982,457

453,900,434

2000-01

187,053,823

35,708,422

44,260,552

267,022,797

304,140,048

2001-02

374,545,865

56,642,017

72,446,479

503,634,360

560,340,855

2002-03

357,000,453

48,001,443

62,273,578

467,275,474

504,284,946

2003-04

279,212,845

43,286,729

58,283,364

380,782,938

399,076,610

2004-05

375,299,535

52,815,271

76,055,705

504,170,511

514,213,093

2005-06

372,820,500

49,598,018

83,232,436

505,650,954

505,650,954

2006-07

332,747,955

49,735,584

83,793,055

466,276,595

455,001,654

Grand total

2,677,756,865

407,305,356

582,783,474

3,667,845,695

3,910,536,828


Defence

Aircraft Carriers

Dr. Julian Lewis: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence for what reason the announcement of the order of the Future Aircraft Carriers has been delayed; and what his estimate is of the probable in-service date of (a) HMS Queen Elizabeth and (b) HMS Prince of Wales. [134728]

Mr. Ingram [holding answer 1 May 2007]: No date has been set for an announcement and there has, therefore, been no delay. However, as my noble Friend the Minister of State for Defence Equipment and Support, Lord Drayson, stated in another place on 18 January 2007, Official Report, column 776, we are looking to get a robust, affordable deal negotiated quickly to allow a main investment decision to be taken as soon as possible.

With regards to in-service dates, I refer the hon. Member to the reply I gave to the hon. Member for Shrewsbury and Atcham (Daniel Kawczynski) on 31 October 2006, Official Report, column 326W.

Armed Forces: Cadets

Mr. Harper: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence how many people were enrolled in (a) gap year commission and (b) the combined cadet force in each year since 1997. [131694]

Derek Twigg: On the subject of gap year commissions, I refer the hon. Member to the answer I gave to the hon. Member for Sutton Coldfield (Mr. Mitchell) on 5 February 2007, Official Report, column 687W.

Gap year commissions were introduced in 2000. Prior to 2000, personnel were granted a short service limited commission. Enrolments are interpreted to be those personnel on the strengths at each point shown.

The strength of untrained regular Army officers on a short service limited commission/gap year commission at 1 April each year is as follows:


3 May 2007 : Column 1849W
Strength

1997

20

1998

70

1999

50

2000

80

2001

50

2002

80

2003

80

2004

70

2005

30

2006

40

2007

(1)60

(1 )At 1 February 2007

The combined cadet force (CCF) is not a recruiting organisation. Although annual records of overall numbers in the CCF are held at 1 April each year since 1999, MOD does not keep account of yearly inflow and outflow numbers.

The annual numbers for the CCF, for years 1999 to 2006, are shown in the following table.

Officers Cadets Non-commissioned officers( 1) Total

1999

1,750

40,010

210

41,970

2000

1,780

40,550

220

42,540

2001

1,790

40,780

230

42,810

2002

1,780

40,970

220

42,980

2003

1,840

41,270

230

43,340

2004

1,890

41,910

240

44,040

2005

1,910

42,460

240

44,600

2006

1,910

42,030

250

44,190

(1) School staff instructors
Note:
Totals and components have been rounded separately to the nearest 10 (numbers ending in “5” have been rounded to the nearest 20 to prevent systematic bias) and so may not equal the sum of their rounded parts.

Next Section Index Home Page