Select Committee on Education and Skills Minutes of Evidence


Annex B

12 October 2006

EVERY CHILD MATTERS AND SCHOOL STANDARDS

Dear Colleague

  You will have seen the letter which Alan Johnson wrote to Council Leaders last week setting out developments and priorities for Every Child Matters and school standards. We wanted to follow that letter up and share our own thoughts about the way we should work together in this next important period of change.

  You may be aware of the work that we undertook over the summer looking at how well we are making the links between school standards and Every Child Matters. This was an important piece of work designed to answer two questions. The first was how far have the actions that the Government set out in the original Every Child Matters Green Paper three years ago been delivered. The second question was how effectively are we implementing ECM alongside the drive on school standards.

  The answers to the first question are encouraging. ECM set out a long-term reform and there is still a substantial programme to manage closely together. But we have delivered many of the commitments already and we are on track to deliver the vast majority of the remaining commitments in this Parliament. Some of these commitments are high profile and will have an increasing impact in communities up and down the country over the next year—for example as we roll out Sure Start Children's Centres, with over 1,000 already in place and with more than one a day opening over the next two years.

  It is too early to find hard research evidence on outcomes of these changes but we are beginning to see qualitative evidence from those local authorities which have been early adopters, of an improvement in customer service to children and parents where you have joined up the different professionals who are there to support children. There are case studies which show this better service leading through to some of the changes we all want to see such as improved behaviour, better school attendance and reductions in referrals to the child protection register.

  The second question—how well aligned are ECM and standards—led to an analysis of whether schools are being distracted from the drive on standards. There is clear evidence that there is no distraction amongst schools that have been early adopters of extended schools—they have continued to drive up standards as fast as anyone at the very time they have been going through the set up stage in their own school. And this finding is backed up by Ofsted's analysis of their first term's inspections on the new inspection framework.

  But there are some risks as we move forward which we must manage closely. The first is that it is clear from the fieldwork that we have delivery chains that are not adequately aligned—some talk about standards, some about ECM and there is not enough connection. This inevitably means that messages are not joined up as they should be and there is not yet enough focus on the contribution that ECM can make to standards and vice versa.

  We are quite clear that the message for the next phase of reform is simple. It is "no school standards without Every Child Matters and no ECM without school standards". To underpin this, we will:

    —  Increase the focus on helping schools not just to improve classroom teaching and learning, but also to create "personalised strategies" for children who are not yet achieving expected standards. Schools should focus more on the needs of the bottom quartile of children at KS2 and KS3—those who are not achieving the standards we want. To make this work, we need to embed a data driven approach in schools and this should increasingly drive both the ECM and standards work at school level.

    —  Clarify for schools what is expected of them in "delivering standards and ECM". We are at the threshold of a major drive on extended schools, as we move from a successful roll out among early adopters with around 10% of schools covered towards the target for all schools to have an extended offer by 2010. The approach in this roll out phase must be consistent with schools as self-governing units with their own clear accountabilities, but it must also, chart a path to better access to services in the local community. The core message for schools is that they must provide a safe environment for all their children and should then focus on achievement. But they also have a wider role to play in contributing to other outcomes for children. The wider role will vary according to local circumstances and the needs of their pupils.

    —  Vigorously pursue the outcomes from ECM and clarify the importance of continuing to press on standards while integrating and expanding children's services. We need to step up a gear on PSA targets and see a systematic return on the reform programme in terms of better standards and outcomes. The Government Offices have a key role to play here, and we are looking for the forthcoming Priorities Meetings with you to cement a shared understanding of national and local priorities and the central support you can expect in driving change, with a clear link to robust targets and clear action in your Children and Young People's Plans. The Education Bill also sets out clear responsibilities—and new powers—for local authorities to intervene quickly where standards are not good enough. We expect you to use these new powers to develop choice and diversity in the system, within the context of your plans for ECM.

    —  Establish a strong performance focus which quickly identifies emerging and effective practice as well as any delivery issues/problems in ECM and standards. We need in particular to make sure there is a real focus on standards in all parts of the delivery system and make sure that our delivery chains are aligned. We want in this next phase to develop arrangements to share best practice and increasingly help local authorities to learn from each other, as well as from expert consultants in the field forces. The field forces are increasingly being managed or coordinated through Government Offices, to ensure that their messages are fully joined up, synergies exploited and there is a sensible orchestration of their activities to reflect the priorities agreed at the autumn priorities meetings. We also have a review of all our field forces under way, due to report around the end of this calendar year and we will involve you in the emerging thinking and share the conclusions with you.

    —  Improve the connection of local and national partners to the Every Child Matters agenda. You are leading the way in your own areas in building the effectiveness of collaboration through children's trusts. We recognise the need to improve joint working in DfES, particularly between our own Directorates and reflecting our recent Capability Review. At the same time we need to improve alignment across Government, working with other Departments, especially the Department of Health and Home Office to visibly support improved outcomes for children and young people.

  In summary, we have undertaken to communicate better to schools their crucial role in safeguarding and in supporting integrated children's services, while keeping their special focus on achievement. We plan to tighten up our programme delivery by coordinating activities better here, and by better briefing to government offices so that they can support you locally. We will strengthen our monitoring of local authority performance, so that we can—together with you—target support more effectively and step up a gear in pursuing measurable outcomes.

  We look forward to debating this agenda with you—and will have the opportunity to do that with some of you at next week's National Children and Adults Conference in Brighton. Do tell us if you think we should be doing more or different things—or if you think we need to do more to deliver on the commitments we are making.

  We look forward to working with you to improve outcomes for children and young people.

Tom Jeffery and Ralph Tabberer





 
previous page contents

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2007
Prepared 28 March 2007