Select Committee on Education and Skills Minutes of Evidence


Supplementary memorandum submitted by the Anti-Bullying Alliance (ABA)

BULLYING AND HOW IT AFFECTS CHILDREN WITH SEN

  1.  There is evidence from children that bullying occurs both in Special Schools and in Mainstream, which suggests that they are not safe simply because they are in a Special School. There is apparently a hierarchy of difficulties and those who are more able and articulate can bully weaker ones. The major difficulty children report is coping with those who have behavioural and emotional difficulties. On the other hand they found it easier to help and understand those with physical disabilities.

  2.  We have a report on this evidence with SEN children and their siblings containing their views on what they'd like to see and what works or doesn't.

  3.  They insist that sometimes the support worker can over protect the person who should try and join the dinner queue and other similar situations—they get respected more.

EXCLUSION

  This is seen by young people as a poor response.

  1.  They have told me many times that the excluded perpetrator "gets a holiday" while I have to go to school.

   2.  The perpetrator may be at home with the difficult family problems that are causing the bullying in the first place. ("Bullying in Britain" by Katz, A. Buchanan, A. and Bream, V. Young Voice, shows links with violence and harsh punitive parenting styles).

  3.  It does not work with the bully to change their behaviour.

  4.  Bullies have been known to lie in wait for the victim after school or go to their home and trash laundry or damage windows.

  5.  The whole class is not learning something as a result and no reparation is being made to the victim.

  6.  There is no evidence that the victim is in fact safer. Retaliation may follow out of sight of the school.

  7.  If used it should be coupled with other steps to change the behaviour and protect the victim.

LONG-TERM EFFECTS OF BULLYING

  1.  There are a very few people who triumph over it and say they are stronger as a result.

  2.  A larger group become depressed and withdrawn. They may leave school earlier than planned (especially common among those bullied for being thought to be Gay). They may feel their school years were blighted and take part in fewer activities as a result. Their right to education may be compromised. There are demonstrable links with bullying and suicidal thoughts and actions.

  3.  Others may become belligerent in turn as a defence. They can bully others as they've learned that this is the way to power and to avoid being the victim ever again. They may internalise this behaviour and learn from parents who are very bullying that this is how to behave.

  4.  There are well-known links with bullying and offending. (Olweus first demonstrated a link in his longitudinal studies and others have since shown this repeatedly. I have looked at a sample of prisoners and asked about bullying—the rate of response is extremely high.)



 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2007
Prepared 27 March 2007