Select Committee on Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Minutes of Evidence


Annex A

Policies anomalies which make it difficult for Groups or individuals to implement effective environmental programmes

WASTE AND RECYCLING

  There are variances as to how local authorities treat school waste. Some local authorities categorise school waste as being the same as commercial organisations. This means that they are unwilling to provide recycling advice and/or services.

  Churches in some areas cannot have their recycling collected along with the doorstep scheme as they are also treated as commercial organisations. They, therefore, have to organise collections from private companies which discourages them from recycling as they have to pay for it.

  There are sometimes gross variations in facilities and services between neighbouring local authorities and even within a local authority. If you move neighbourhoods you often have to change your "at home" habits and even have to check with friends when you visit what you should/shouldn't put in the bin.

TRAVEL

  Many people pointed out the variances in the way travel fuels are taxed making it relatively much cheaper to travel by air than plane.

  People felt that car travel had become relatively cheaper than railways over the past decade. Government indicator information suggests that this is the case.

  The way that public transport pricing structures have been created makes it harder or more expensive for people to travel by public transport. For example, introducing pre-pay Oyster cards in London that can't be used on all transport in London, making it less convenient and more expensive to use some train lines/stations.

  Many people complained about the pricing systems for the railways which they found both confusing. The high cost of fares which are not pre-booked also prevented people from traveling on the railways.

  The deregulated bus services is also acting as a deterrent for people to travel on the buses. People cited lack of services on unpopular routes and too many buses on busy routes that increased congestion.

ENERGY USE

  We have received many complaints about lack of consistencies within the planning system with regard to installing micro-generation technologies. For example one business in Devon was able to install a wind turbine and PV cells in an area of outstanding natural beauty on Dartmoor. A near neighbour in a different council was refused permission for a similar installation.

  A common complaint has been the complexity of the planning process for micro-generation and the lack of standard and high quality advice available from planning officers.

  One of the major water utilities has told us that they would like to install micro-generation technologies on many of their sites, but have been deterred by the level of resources they would have to devout to the planning process.

  Several of our households have questioned why their electricity tariff goes down the more electricity they use—they feel it should be reversed.

SHOPPING

  A shopping related complaint is that supermarkets heavily promote buy-one-get one free offers which some of our participants feel promotes food waste.

  A number of our participants complained about over-packaging particularly for organic products which they feel is counter-intuitive.


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2007
Prepared 13 September 2007