Previous Section Index Home Page

18 Nov 2008 : Column 395W—continued

Retail Trade: Planning

Mr. Betts: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government what assessment she has made of the extent to which in-town trade diversion affects town centres; and whether this assessment will be taken into account in revisions to Planning Policy Statement 6. [236505]

Mr. Iain Wright: Our “Proposed Changes to Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning for town centres”, published on 10 July 2008, make clear that a key consideration to take into account when considering the impact of proposals for retail and leisure development is whether there will be an impact on in-centre trade/turnover, taking account of current and future consumer expenditure capacity in the catchment area of the proposal.

In formulating our proposals we have taken account of a number of studies, particularly “The Merry Hill Impact Study” (DoE, 1993); “The Impact of Large Foodstores on Market Towns and District Centres” (DETR, 1998); and our research into “The Policy Evaluation of the Effectiveness of PPG6” (ODPM, 2004).

We have also had regard to planning cases decided by the Secretary of State and Inspectors, as indicated in our consultation document. We have also drawn upon a number of other reports to inform our proposals, including:

As we said in our consultation proposals, we expect to implement our revisions in spring 2009.

Mr. Betts: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government how the proposed revision of Planning Policy Statement 6 will protect and promote retail diversity. [236506]


18 Nov 2008 : Column 396W

Mr. Iain Wright: Our “Proposed Changes to Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning for town centres”, published on 10 July 2008, set out a strong policy framework within which local authorities should plan for their town centres and retail development. Our proposals recognise the importance of achieving a broad range of retailer representation, both large and small, to improve the attractiveness of town centres and promoting competition and consumer choice. To achieve this we are asking local authorities to plan proactively for their town centres by making full and effective use of available tools such as their development plan policies, planning conditions, Local Development Orders and Article 4 Directions. We are also asking them to promote competitive town centre environments by, where appropriate, giving priority consideration to whether the established character and diversity of their town centres should be protected and enhanced.

Our proposed new impact test will also provide a more effective way of assessing the impact of unplanned proposals outside town centres by requiring applicants for such proposals to assess the extent to which a proposal will promote or undermine town centre vitality and viability, including the impact on local consumer choice and retail diversity in terms of the range, type and quality of goods.

Mr. Betts: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government when she expects to issue revised Planning Policy Statement 6; and whether the revised version will incorporate the recent recommendations of the Competition Commission on competition in the retail sector. [236508]

Mr. Iain Wright: As we said in our ‘Proposed Changes to Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning for town centres’, published on 10 July 2008, we expect to implement our revisions in spring 2009.

Whether our revised policy will incorporate a ‘competition test’ for planning decisions on larger grocery stores, as recommended by the Competition Commission (CC), will depend on the outcome of the Tesco appeal to the Competition Appeal tribunal and our further consideration of the CC's proposals. As we said in the Government's response to the CC inquiry into UK groceries retailing in July, we will report more fully on our decision in the light of developments. Our published response can be viewed on the BERR website at:

Severn Barrage

Mrs. Moon: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government whether she has provided guidance to planning authorities on the potential impact of a Severn Barrage on flooding in the south west and south Wales. [235333]

Mr. Iain Wright: A cross-Government study is assessing the feasibility of harnessing the tidal power of the Severn Estuary. Impacts of a power generation scheme on flooding issues are being addressed in the Strategic Environmental Assessment commissioned by the study. The feasibility study is scheduled to report during 2010. Given this, no planning guidance for authorities in the South West and Wales has been issued concerning the potential impact of any such development in the Severn Estuary.


18 Nov 2008 : Column 397W

Mrs. Moon: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government what responsibilities the Homes and Communities Agency will have for assessing the risk of flooding arising from the construction of a Severn Barrage. [235334]

Mr. Iain Wright: Homes and Communities Agency would have no role in relation to flood risk assessment for any Severn Barrage. This would be the responsibility of whoever builds it, with the Environment Agency taking a keen interest given its statutory role in relation to planning and flood risk.

HCA’s role with regard to flood risk assessment would be that set out in “PPS25: Development and Flood Risk”. For any development it planned, it would have to carry out a flood risk assessment. The HCA will develop its own flood risk/flood adaptation policy building on EP’s best practice guidance note covering PPS25 and building on EP’s work on sustainable urban drainage systems.

HCA will also seek to develop strong and early relationships with the Environment Agency to ensure that they are involved at both a strategic level and locally where flood risk or water availability is an issue.

South-East Plan

Anne Milton: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government to whom a hard copy of the South-East Plan consultation document was distributed by her Department during the recent consultation in (a) Guildford borough, (b) Waverley borough and (c) Surrey. [236609]

Mr. Khan: Hard copies were distributed to all south-east MPs and MEPs, participants at the Examination in Public, South East England Regional Assembly members, and local authority heads of planning. Public libraries and planning authority offices received copies for inspection.

In addition, a further approximately 100 hard copies have been distributed on a request basis across the region.


18 Nov 2008 : Column 398W

Duchy of Lancaster

Action for Sustainable Living: Finance

Mr. Pickles: To ask the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster how much funding (a) his Department, (b) its agencies and (c) Capacitybuilders has given to Action for Sustainable Living in the last 24 months. [233236]

Kevin Brennan: Neither the Cabinet Office, the Central Office of Information nor Capacitybuilders have awarded any grants to Action for Sustainable Living in the last 24 months.

Average Earnings: Coastal Areas

Chris Ruane: To ask the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster what the average earnings of (a) males and (b) females are in the principal seaside towns in England and Wales. [234936]

Kevin Brennan: The information requested falls within the responsibility of the UK Statistics Authority. I have asked the authority to reply.

Letter from Karen Dunnell, dated November 2008:


18 Nov 2008 : Column 399W

18 Nov 2008 : Column 400W
Median weekly pay—Gross (£) F or employee jobs( a) in Principal Seaside Towns in England and Wales for 2007
Male Female
Principal seaside towns Local authority Male Female Full-time Part- t ime Full-time Part- t ime

Bognor Regis

Arun

*356

**201

*389

x

**373

**128

Greater Blackpool

Blackpool UA

**362

*264

**447

x

*322

**134

Greater Bournemouth

Bournemouth UA

*382

*254

*449

x

*343

*145

Porthcawl

Bridgend/Pen-y-bont ar Ogwr

*479

*264

*488

x

*341

**123

Greater Brighton

Brighton and Hove UA

*403

*319

*456

x

*404

**163

Whitstable/Herne Bay

Canterbury

*393

**272

*433

x

*391

**135

Falmouth

Carrick

**365

**294

*425

x

*379

**151

Llandudno/Colwyn Bay/Conway

Conwy/Conwy

*350

**221

**397

x

**344

**93

Rhyl/Prestatyn

Denbighshire/Sir Ddinbych

*369

**262

*386

x

**353

**134

Deal

Dover

**449

**271

**522

x

**371

**117

Sidmouth

East Devon

*404

**219

*423

x

*315

x

Skegness

East Lindsey

**339

*213

**371

x

**302

**131

Bridlington

East Riding of Yorkshire UA

470

*212

*493

x

*370

*139

Eastbourne

Eastbourne

**443

**280

**480

x

**425

**167

Great Yarmouth

Great Yarmouth

**434

**226

*518

x

**331

**135

Hastings/Bexhill

Hastings

*357

**229

*406

x

**357

x

Isle of Wight

Isle of Wight UA

*421

*205

*474

x

*343

*159

Morecambe and Heysham

Lancaster

*466

x

*498

x

*362

**138

Ilfracombe

North Devon

**372

**239

**379

x

*311

**143

Weston-super-Mare

North Somerset UA

*513

*275

*539

x

*358

**151

Whitley Bay

North Tyneside

*391

*260

*408

x

*328

*136

St Ives/Penzance

Penwith

**312

**209

**349

x

x

x

Swanage

Purbeck

x

x

**546

x

**340

x

Newquay

Restormel

*384

**224

*418

x

*315

**162

Scarborough/Whitby

Scarborough

*389

**210

*411

x

**286

**140

Burnham-on-Sea

Sedgemoor

**396

**201

*459

x

*344

**136

Southport

Sefton

*383

*252

*422

109

*399

*139

Folkstone/Hythe

Shepway

**411

**239

**444

x

*292

**117

Southend-on-Sea

Southend-on-Sea UA

**350

*275

**414

x

*396

**142

Exmouth/Dawlish/Teignmouth

Teignbridge

*373

**241

*383

x

**307

**149

Clacton

Tendring

*348

**256

**376

x

*323

x

Thanet

Thanet

**401

*226

**429

x

**359

**154

Barry

The Vale of Glamorgan/Bro Morgannwg

**455

**275

**482

x

**402

**153

Torbay

Torbay UA

**326

**246

**360

x

*365

**127

Lowestoft

Waveney

*380

**172

390

x

**347

**113

Minehead

West Somerset

x

x

x

x

x

Weymouth

Weymouth and Portland

**314

x

*375

x

**316

x

Greater Worthing

Worthing

*425

**273

*460

x

*364

**158

(a) Employees on adult rates whose pay for the survey pay-period was not affected by absence.
Key:
The colour coding indicates the quality of each estimate for median gross weekly pay.
The quality of an estimate is measured by its coefficient of variation (CV), which is the ratio of the standard error of an estimate to the estimate.
Guide to quality:
The Coefficient of Variation (CV) indicates the quality of a figure, the smaller the CV value the higher the quality.
The true value is likely to lie within +/- twice the CV - for example, for an average of 200 with a CV of 5%, we would expect the population average to be within the range 180 to 220.
Key:
CV ≥= 5%
* CV ≥ 5% and <= 10%
** CV ≥ 10% and <=20%
X CV ≥ 20%
Notes:
1. Estimates provided are from the Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings (ASHE).
2. Figures are provided for median gross weekly earnings for employees on adult rates of pay, whose pay for the survey period was not affected by absence.
Source:
Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings, Office for National Statistics.

Next Section Index Home Page