Select Committee on Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Minutes of Evidence


Examination of Witnesses (Questions 100-105)

MR BOB MOORE, PROFESSOR SHEILA CRISPIN, MS ANDREA JEFFERY AND MS JANE HERN

18 FEBRUARY 2008

  Q100  David Taylor: Against professional standards, against expectations, against whether or not you are trying to prevent ill health or merely treat it.

  Ms Hern: But we do not prescribe how—

  Q101  David Taylor: You should be part of it though, surely?

  Ms Hern: We do not tell veterinary surgeons how they should exercise their professional judgment.

  Q102  David Taylor: Ah, you say you are just packing up; you are just walking by on the other side?

  Ms Hern: No, but they have to exercise their professional judgment in relation to the animal and the client in front of them, and we do not go down the road of being prescriptive in all of those contexts.

  Q103  Chairman: Can I ask you one last question, very briefly? Continuous professional development: have you costed it out, and would you apply it to all the professions that we have so far talked about under the veterinary umbrella?

  Professor Crispin: For someone who has dealt all my life with education, I think this falls to me as well. There would be no extra costs involved. It really is market forces here. There is a lot of competition amongst the people who supply this continuing professional development, on a competitive basis. There would be no extra cost. We do spend a lot of money already on that, and a good practice will always build it into their practice plan, so that their veterinary surgeons have the CPD paid for.

  Q104  Chairman: If you made it a legal requirement. It would—

  Professor Crispin: It would make absolutely no difference financially.

  Q105  Chairman: Applying that same dictum to other professions—farriers to nurses, to everybody else—still no difference?

  Ms Jeffrey: We have already introduced it. In September, when we went down the self-regulatory route we introduced continuous professional development with team nurses, and they are finding it—and it is not too expensive. We have not had any complaints about it being expensive.

  Mr Moore: Continuous professional development does not necessarily have to be attendance at courses away. There is, written into the requirements that it can be distance learning, self-reading and so on. A very small proportion has to be attendance at courses, so it is not all expensive and can be tailored to suit the individual.

  Chairman: Thank you very much for your written and oral evidence, and thank you for briefing the Committee. We shall consider carefully what you have said. As I said at the beginning, if there is anything further you want to put in writing, please do. We look forward to the statistics on complaints that we asked for earlier.



 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008
Prepared 14 May 2008