Select Committee on Foreign Affairs Minutes of Evidence


Annex I

IRAN'S DOMESTIC POLITICAL SITUATION

Political structure

  1.  Under the Iranian Constitution, Iran is an Islamic Republic and the teachings of Islam are to be the basis of all political, social and economic relations.

  2.  The structure of authority is opaque, with competing power centres. Overall authority is vested in the Supreme Leader, currently Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, who was preferred in this role by Khomeini to be his successor in 1989, a choice then made official by the Assembly of Experts, a body of 96 religious scholars elected by universal adult suffrage from all over Iran. The President too is elected by universal adult suffrage, and serves a four-year term. He may serve no more than two consecutive terms in office.

  3.  The Majles (parliament) has 290 elected members representing regions or one of the three recognised religious minorities (Jews, Christians and Zoroastrians). The Majles also approves the members of the Council of Ministers (the President's Cabinet).

  4.  Political parties were legalised in 1998 after a 13-year ban and are still at an early stage of development. Factions, particularly in the Majles, are often defined broadly as "reformist", "hardline conservative" or "pragmatic conservative".

  5.  Legislation passed by the Majles must be approved by the Guardian Council, which reviews it for constitutionality and adherence to Islamic law. The Council is composed of six theologians appointed by the Supreme Leader and six jurists nominated by the judiciary and approved by the Majles. The Council has the power to veto candidates in elections to parliament, local councils, the Presidency and the Assembly of Experts.

  6.  The Council for the Discernment of Expediency was created in 1988 to resolve disputes over legislation between the Majles and the Guardian Council. It also advises the Supreme Leader on national policy and constitutional issues. It is currently led by former President Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani and includes the heads of all three branches of government and the clerical members of the Guardian Council. The Supreme Leader appoints other members for a five-year term.

Political situation

  7.  The "reformist" President Khatami was elected in August 1997 with an overwhelming majority, and re-elected in June 2001. However, there has been a swing towards more hardline conservative forces in recent years, in part because of the reformists' failure to address growing economic concerns. In the most recent Majles (parliamentary) elections in 2004, conservative candidates swept the board (after the Guardian Council—which can veto candidates it considers contrary to the interests of the Islamic Republic—blocked the candidacies of more than a third of the 8,000 candidates, most of whom were reformists, and 85 of who were incumbent MPs).

  8.  The vetting procedures dissuaded many potential candidates from even putting their names forward. The Guardian Council has vetoed all female candidates from standing in any presidential election as well as the December 2006 Assembly of Experts elections.

President Ahmadinejad

  9.  Ahmadinejad was elected in June 2005, on a platform of "economic justice" (especially improving the economic situation of the poorest), anti-corruption, and nationalism. His campaign stressed his humble background, simple lifestyle and personal piety.

  10.  Since coming into office, Ahmadinejad has used economic and political tools to entrench the control of his hardline supporters over the key levers of power. Members or former members of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), created by Ayatollah Khomeini in May 1979 to "protect the revolution and its achievements" have taken on more political roles (including Ministerial and provincial governor positions) as well as their growing commercial interests. There has also been increased activity by the IRGC-linked Basij (revolutionary volunteers) and morality police.

  11.  While Ahmadinejad is not the key foreign policy player, he has put his stamp on foreign policy, particularly through public statements—including his vitriolic comments about Israel, as well as the nuclear file.

  12.  But over the past year Ahmadinejad has come under increasing domestic criticism, for his confrontational foreign policy, poor management of the economy, and failure to fulfil campaign promises to tackle corruption. His relations with some other regime leaders are strained or hostile, and his support in the Majlis remains fragile. In December 2006, his candidate list, "The Pleasant Scent of Service", did poorly in local elections, on a high turnout. Pragmatic conservatives showed a stronger performance.

Economic outlook

  13.  Ahmadinejad's populism is also leaving its imprint on the economic outlook. He has tried to win favour among the poor with high levels of public spending. High oil prices helped him promote this agenda. Budget mismanagement and soaring inflation are evident. And the government's insistence that banks must pay out cheap loans has hit the financial sector hard.

  14.  Since Ahmadinejad came to power, much needed but painful structural reforms—eg on fuel subsidies—have been further delayed. The Revolutionary Guards are further extending their grip over the economy; huge contracts have been handed to companies they control, often without any form of tendering.

  15.  Ahmadinejad's confrontational foreign policy approach has also had an impact. Fear of possible future sanctions has hit economic and investor confidence: businesses are deferring investment decisions and the stock market has fallen below 10,000 points. Foreign investment has all but dried up, foreign export credit agencies are taking steps to limit their exposure and firms are finding it harder to raise international finance for major projects. US actions against Iranian banks and UN Security Council sanctions against Bank Sepah have made Western financial institutions more cautious and many have reduced services.

  16.  Technocrats in the oil industry are especially concerned. The health of the sector—which provides 50% of government income—is an indicator of overall economic performance. At present, projects lie stalled and foreign firms are increasingly reluctant to invest in Iran because of the political situation. As a result, and given the annual decline in production from some of the largest and ageing oil fields, Iran faces a real challenge simply to bring enough new production on stream to maintain stable production and export levels. In the current climate there is no prospect of Iran significantly increasing its small gas export volumes. Temporary solutions—such as turning to parastatal bodies and the Oil Stabilisation Fund to finance and deliver oil and domestic gas projects—continue to make the economy's structural problems worse medium term.



 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008
Prepared 2 March 2008