Select Committee on Home Affairs Written Evidence


Supplementary evidence submitted by Mr Liam Byrne MP, Minister of State, Home Office on follow up questions on A2

  I would like to begin by correcting the impression that there were 38,000 approved applications under the A2 schemes in the first three quarters of 2007. In fact, this was the total number of applications (38,365, which includes 7,370 SAWS cards issued). Since January 2007 there have been 32,238 approved applications under the A2 schemes (which again includes the 7,370 SAWS cards issued).

    —  The number of Bulgarians and Romanians working in the UK under the A2 regulations who will become eligible to receive working family tax credits and/or child benefits once they have been working in the UK for a 12 month period.

    Eligibility for child benefit, child tax credit and working tax credit is not based on the period of time the migrant has been working in the UK.

    For child benefit and child tax credit purposes, A2 nationals must be present, ordinarily resident and have a right to reside in the UK. An A2 national who is authorised to work in the UK under A2 schemes or who is exempt from registration (such as the self-employed) has a right to reside and may therefore receive child benefit and child tax credit, provided they meet all the other relevant conditions of entitlement.

    For the working tax credit, A2 nationals may receive such support provided they are present and ordinarily resident in the UK and, again, meet all the other relevant conditions of entitlement.

    For both tax credits and for child benefit, the term "ordinarily resident" means that the claimant must normally reside in the UK.

    —  The proportion of the 380 Bulgarian and Romanian children in receipt of child benefits who are currently residing in the UK.

    There were 380 approved Child Benefit claims from Bulgarian and Romanian nationals in the UK from July to September 2007, the equivalent number for the period 1 January to 31 October 2007 is 1,322. These figures include all claims from A2 nationals and is not restricted to those who are authorised to work in the UK under the A2 schemes.

    In the vast majority of cases where a decision has been made, the children are based in the UK. As at 31 October 2007, in well over 99% of the cases where A2 migrants were receiving child benefits in the UK the children were also resident in the UK, there were only seven cases where this was not the case.

    All claims for child benefit and tax credits are subject to a wide range of checks throughout the life of each claim. Where claims are made on behalf of children living in another EEA Member State, HM Revenue and Customs do further checks to verify the information provided by the claimant, including verifying the composition of the family and to find out whether there are any other family benefits in payment in the other Member State. HMRC and other Member States have well established processes in place to ensure payments only go to those who are entitled. For child benefit, these cases are also subject to a regular annual review to see whether there have been any changes of circumstances that may affect entitlement. Where a claimant fails these checks, the award is terminated. For tax credits, all awards are subject to an annual review.

    —  The number of school pupils who have migrated to the UK from A2 and A8 countries.

    A8 and A2 migrant children cannot be identified in school census data as the census does not hold data such on nationality or country of birth. Schools will receive extra resources to help them with A2 and A8 migrants via the weighting in mainstream funding to children with English as an additional language (EAL).

    Local authorities also receive funding through Ethnic Minority Achievement Grant to provide support for minority ethnic pupils and pupils with EAL. The grant is £179 million in 2007-08 and is set to rise to £206 million by 2010. It must also be remembered that the amount of money spent on education has risen by more than 60% in real terms since 1996-97.

    Nevertheless, we are aware that it is vital that we take the social impact of immigration into account when we make migration decisions. That's why we set up the Migration Impacts Forum, so public services can help shape our points system which is introduced in early 2008.

10 December 2007





 
previous page contents

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008
Prepared 17 January 2008