Select Committee on Public Accounts Minutes of Evidence


Memorandum submitted by W A Smith

  I wish to draw attention to a problem which must affect many thousands of NHS patients throughout the country. I enclose a draft leaflet which we are developing to draw attention to a problem which must affect many thousands of NHS patients throughout the country. [8]

  Ultimately the Health Service is there to maintain and improve the well-being of patients, and the present system of supplying medicines to patients causes much difficulty for those patients who need to take many tablets every day. Thus, effectiveness is reduced, and NHS funds are misused.

  The essential problem is that a patient prescribed a generic medicine cannot rely on receiving the same brand every time, so that the tablets, the foil strips, and the packet can all look quite different for the same medicine. In addition, the brands all have different names so that a patient cannot always be sure that he is getting the same medicine, and it is very easy to get tablets mixed up.

  This clearly impedes the effectiveness of the medicines, causing inadvertent underdosing or overdosing, however careful the patient is, and may also indeed cause hazard.

  Of course, there is no problem for a patient who needs to take only a single medicine for a short period.

  This is a serious problem which is little recognised by politicians, administrators, and health professionals, perhaps partly because it is seen to be too difficult and complex to tackle. The problem relates to competition policy within this country and throughout the EEC, where patients in other countries may have more choice of brand of medicine.

  The problems are greater with items manufactured in other countries of the EEC, and in many cases even the same brand appears quite different if manufactured abroad. Often the label in English pasted on obscures other important information in another language.

  One approach might be to find ways of achieving a uniform appearance in all respects for all brands of a single general medicine, with the generic name larger and more prominent than the brand name. This could be difficult, but should not be shirked as it would solve the problem, no doubt other solutions could also be found.

  I believe that patients should be informed of the NHS cost of their medicines and it could be helpful if the price was printed on the pharmacist's label.

  Incidentally, why is it cheaper to produce medicines in other parts of the EEC than here, and who eventually gets the profit from doing this?

7 June 2007






8   Leaflet not printed. Back


 
previous page contents

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008
Prepared 17 January 2008