Select Committee on Public Accounts Sixth Report


4  Acute hospital admission and care home experiences

19. Over 200,000 people with dementia are estimated to live in care homes, some 62% on average of all residents in such settings. However, only 28% of care homes places are registered as specialist dementia places, meaning a significant proportion of people with dementia live in homes where staff are not appropriately trained to care for them and meet their specific needs. Whilst the Commission for Social Care Inspection[28] (CSCI) has recorded an increase in the number of homes meeting these standards, the proportion of residents with dementia is also increasing.[29]

20. Many of the concerns about skills, training and turnover of domiciliary care staff are also relevant to care home staff. The challenge remains to ensure that staff recognise and acknowledge dementia and are equipped to provide appropriate care to meet the needs of people with dementia.[30]

21. Two out of ten care homes are not meeting the medicines management standards and there is evidence of people with dementia being administered anti-psychotics to manage behavioural problems. The latter is not recommended except in short term management of high risk situations, since the drugs have serious side-effects and may exacerbate dementia. Care homes require more effective specialist input from mental health services to ensure their input and advice in the care of people with dementia and other mental health problems, especially in the area of medicines management.[31]

22. The NAO's Lincolnshire whole system case study of health and social care and acute bed survey demonstrates that admission and readmission to acute hospital care can often be avoided for people with dementia, and their lengths of stay can be reduced by finding alternative non-acute care settings for these patients. Ambulance staff should have access to appropriate information to make an informed decision as to whether the person needs to be taken to hospital or can be better treated at home.[32]

23. On admission of older patients known—or suspected—to have cognitive impairment, acute hospital trusts do not routinely undertake a mental health assessment. Acute trusts usually only treat the physical symptoms which led to the admission, so the treatment and rehabilitation of people with dementia is not tailored to their needs to enable them to leave hospital earlier. Preventing unnecessary admissions and reducing lengths of stay would release resources for better care further upstream in the dementia care pathway. The Department is undertaking work similar to the NAO's whole system case study to identify the benefits of early intervention and management for people with dementia in terms of fewer admissions to acute hospital and shorter lengths of stay. The National Audit Office's analysis of acute admissions for fractured neck of femur also demonstrated there is a clear financial benefit from improving the treatment of people with dementia, as well as a quality of life improvement for the patients concerned. At present, a person with dementia who suffers a fractured neck of femur is over 2.5 times more likely to die in the six months following admission and almost 18 times more likely to be admitted in a care home following discharge than a person who is psychiatrically well and is only half as likely to be discharged at the end of six months.[33]




28   The Commission for Social Care Inspection registers, inspects and reports in adult social care services, and councils who arrange these services in England. Back

29   Q 57; C&AG's Report, paras 4.19-4.20 Back

30   Q 76-83; C&AG's Report, paras 3.13-3.14 Back

31   Qq 59-60, 100-104, 108-113; C&AG's Report, para 4.22 Back

32   Q 27; C&AG's Report, para 4.6-4.7 Back

33   Qq 27, 64, 135; C&AG's Report, paras 2.27-2.32, 4.7, 4.17-4.18; Figure 24 Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008
Prepared 24 January 2008